Upper Honey

January 30, 2018

Stop me if you’ve heard this one before.

You gear up, lock the truck and hike down the ravine. Following the path of a shallow ditch, you enter the water where the spring-seep trickles in, and you cross the river where it’s wide and shallow. On the far side, you navigate over a maze of zig-zagging deer trails and around fallen timber for about a half mile. You climb the hillside to the railroad tracks and walk another quarter mile, scanning the river below for the spot — the one you and your fishing buddies refer to as Upper Honey.

In the off season like this, there are no leaves on the trees, and you can usually spot the ancient sycamore teetering bank-side, leaning about thirty degrees over, patiently waiting, month after month, year after year, for the day when it slips the bonds of its streamside earth and crashes into the water.

And oh my, those roots. Underneath the massive sycamore sits an exposed tangle of underground limbs — wet, flexible pipes as thick as your leg, with a shadowy cover where no sunlight penetrates.

How far back do those roots go? And how many monster brown trout live in the black water swirling through? It’s a wonderful mystery — the kind of unanswerable question that motivates you to walk these distances, to hike in hot waders anytime you earn the necessary free hours away from the rest of life.

Upper Honey is down there somewhere below these tracks. And you know you’re getting close.

Photo by Ben Bishop

Walking fast now, and peering down from the iron rails, you start to think that maybe you passed it up. You slow down. Then you finally stop, lift your sunglasses and wipe the sweat from your eyes — too many clothes for such a long walk. Hands go to your hips, exasperated. Did you walk too far again? Did you pass it up? Is it before the bend in the tracks or after?

Just as you turn around to retrace your steps, you spot it. There’s the giant sycamore — towering over the head of a heavy run, right where it’s supposed to be. The sheltered inside bend is the only shadow on the river here at midday. And the branches provide an awning of wood, of limbs wide and numerous enough to lay a continuous blanket of shade over the water, even without leaves or buds on the dying tree.

A hundred yards downriver and a fifty foot drop above sea level from the railroad bed, the last stretch is mired in dense brush, with thorns that surely add to the leaks in your waders, but who cares? When you break free and leave the thick mess of resistance behind . . . there are the roots.

As you wade slowly across the river, you wonder just how this perfection was created. Was the riverbed already in this shape and the tree grew with it, or did the massive structure stand boldly against the face of flood waters — “You shall not pass!” — and force the river to go around? Did the giant tree itself create this place?

That’s the question you whisper as you reach to the hook-keeper above the cork on your rod handle. You remove the back hook of an articulated sculpin, and you drop the olive pattern of rabbit fur into the cold water at your feet. You let that fly soak for a moment as you gaze up to the wide canopy of white and tan sycamore bark blocking the sun. You slowly follow the limbs down to where they meet the split trunk, then further down to the soft ground and finally the dark roots. Oh my, those roots.

And you cast with all the confidence in the world.

Enjoy the day.
Domenick Swentosky


Read More Troutbitten Stories


What do you think?

1 Comment threads
1 Thread replies
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
2 Comment authors
  Follow the comments on this article.  
Notify of
Vincent trzeciak

Ok.ok. then you notice someone is fishing there. Oh no. All that wonderful water gone. What do you do.. wait. Try to fish below as you wait for the person to leave but they never do. Watching as they spin fish the hell out of the damn place and catch a monster brown. Maybe if you got there earlier next time. Sorry to ruin this great story. But that’s what usually happens in my neck of the woods.

Domenick Swentosky

Hi. I'm a father of two young boys, a husband, author, fly fishing guide and a musician. I fish for wild brown trout in the cool limestone waters of Central Pennsylvania year round. This is my home, and I love it. Friends. Family. And the river.

photography How it Started winter dry flies tightline family Baseball Davy Wotten the Mono Rig angler types home-stream montana Memories spawning silence George Daniel Wild Mushrooms stinky bass fall rookies fluke leaders PFBC catch and release wet fly fishing Quote mistakes tenkara Oakiewear Aiden nymphing waders Harvey Pusher brookies solitude fly box Rich History DJS mud camera fighting fish Grandfather Trust Trout Unlimited tiny flies Peace Bad Mother Wild Brown Trout spot burning surf fishing mayfly public land friendship One Great Tip split shot Streamers fly patterns dorsey yarn indicator Boat front ended wild trout cookout casting Press TU comp fishing trout bum mousing droppers Dry-Dropper wading boots Weather walking club fishing fishing tips winter fishing Night efficiency wading Stockies saltwater Floating suspender fishing fishing with kids poetry brown trout Christmas Lights big brown trout big fish Backing Barrel Ask an Expert backcast stocked trout philosophy Fly Casting Streamer fishing winter fly fishing boys nymphing tips swinging marginal water Presentations Camping mono rig dead drift Industry Stuff drifting tracks wet wading DHALO explore carp beadhead conservation float It's just fishing Night Fishing Chapters Fly Fishing simplicity shark George Harvey tight line nymphing musician Grobe indicator fishing tight lining Fifty Tips bite windows fly line Jeff tips Whiskey Drinker etiquette thunderstorm rigs Galloup wet flies Fish Hard giveaway night-sighter PA Gold PSA Sighter knots Orvis Little Juniata River Whiskey summertime fishing Discovery Euro-Nymphing fly tying tippet hiking nymphs streamside Dylan Headbanger Sculpin ice gear travel indicator nymphing net Buggers Tippet Rings Gierach Pennsylvania Resources last cast Fly rods time dry fly fishing Night Fishing Namer dog Troutbitten Fly Box BES small streams come on man skunked bar boots LBI Wild vs Stocked Plans high water summer brush fishing Dad Mystery science matters favorite friends Spring Creek Burke Central PA flood patience Joey Big Trout backcountry flies rules Sawyer wildlife regulations DIY reading water Float Fishing