The Aquaculture Culture (from Dirt Roads and Blue Lines)

May 4, 2018

This is too good to let pass. My friend, Chase Howard, restarted and rejuvenated his blog, Dirt Roads and Blue Lines. And recently, he penned a short commentary on the state of the stocked vs wild trout situation in Pennsylvania.

Chase calls the stocked trout syndrome “The Aquaculture Culture,” and his choice of words is appropriate. There truly is an ingrained culture. Many Pennsylvanians have grown to expect (and feel they deserve) stocked trout in their local creeks, not because the creek can’t support wild trout and not because there isn’t already a wild trout population that would thrive if given a chance. No, the Aquaculture Culture expects and downright demands stocked trout in the creek because that’s the way it’s always been (in their lifetime).

As I’ve argued countless times here on Troutbitten, stocked trout do have a place in Pennsylvania. Our state hatcheries could continue to raise trout and stock them in streams that cannot and do not already support wild trout. I’m thankful for stocked trout. I caught my limit of stocked fish today — I gutted them, filleted them, breaded and fried them. And my sons and I had fresh trout for supper. The fish came from a put-and-take, local stream that becomes far too warm in the summers for a wild trout population to thrive.

But in Chase’s region of Northern PA, where the water is cold and the woods are wild, there are too many creeks stocked with hatchery trout simply to follow a historic precedent — and because the culture expects it.

As Chase writes . . .

Can you imagine the fishery we would have in the state of Pennsylvania if instead of spending in excess of $12 million annually on raising hatchery fish (a small percentage of which survive their first summer) the bulk of spending budget went toward habitat improvement, fish migration studies, and otherwise protecting, conserving, and enhancing our aquatic resources? Imagine all of the funds from the last 50 years improving the health of our rivers instead of the short-sighted perpetuity of put-and-take fisheries. What would the state of our rivers be?

It’s something to think about.

Read The Aquaculture Culture over at Dirt Roads and Blue Lines


Enjoy the day.
Domenick Swentosky




Read More Troutbitten Commentary


What do you think?

  Follow the comments on this article.  
Notify of
Domenick Swentosky

Hi. I'm a father of two young boys, a husband, author, fly fishing guide and a musician. I fish for wild brown trout in the cool limestone waters of Central Pennsylvania year round. This is my home, and I love it. Friends. Family. And the river.

TCO Fly Shop
thunderstorm Fifty Tips Sawyer Troutbitten Fly Box Ask an Expert backcast fly tying cookout small streams split shot Weather musician dorsey yarn indicator Dry-Dropper fly patterns fishing with kids mayfly explore TU Floating falling in montana tracks friends ice Streamer fishing Press fishing tips gear traction Night Fishing Chapters wet wading drifting big fish Peace science matters spot burning camera Boat Backing Barrel wild trout brush fishing nymphing Namer safety Aiden Baseball LBI Bad Mother fly fsihing Camping Burke Dylan State College Discovery strip set summertime fishing wading Industry Stuff favorite brown trout big brown trout friendship Joe Humphreys tippet trout bum Orvis Pennsylvania Big Trout winter fly line How it Started tight lining mono rig Oakiewear Wild Brown Trout indicator nymphing Doh float Memories silence surf fishing PFBC wet flies tiny flies mistakes rookies wet fly fishing dead drift the Mono Rig Tippet Rings PSA streamside flies last cast high water efficiency Film Whiskey Drinker skunked DHALO photography indicator fishing stinky bass boys travel History family Wild vs Stocked eggs flood philosophy Fly Fishing carp fluke spawning Little Juniata River tenkara regulations snags reading water strategy Trust Dad George Daniel bar boots summer Rich angler types One Great Tip drop shot nymphing Buggers Fly Casting conservation leaders nymphs club fishing tips Float Fishing shark Stockies brookies Davy Wotten night-sighter Streamers It's just fishing Quote Trout Unlimited DJS Plans come on man Harvey Pusher mud river rules bite windows Euro-Nymphing dry fly fishing Resources Headbanger Sculpin dog backcountry droppers Joey stocked trout swinging BES Presentations Night winter fly fishing nymphing tips public land casting Night Fishing solitude Wild Mushrooms suspender fishing Grandfather PA Gold FishHard etiquette fall Galloup giveaway marginal water George Harvey home-stream DIY time Sighter Fly rods comp fishing mousing net rigs knots Gierach wading boots front ended tightline posted land Jeff winter fishing wildlife Grobe Whiskey waders fly rod Central PA walking fighting fish beadhead Spring Creek fly box dry flies Mystery catch and release hiking patience saltwater simplicity Christmas Lights tight line nymphing Fish Hard