Commentary Stories Tips/Tactics

When fishing for stockies, it may not pay to be ambitious

on
May 2, 2018

Western Pennsylvania, June, 2002. On a Wednesday morning, Brandon and I ditched a three-hour summer college course called “Oceans and Atmospheres” in favor of a more inspiring classroom.

Weather was perfect, cool and cloudy with that late-spring feeling of freedom — a tangible impression engrained from years of anticipating summer vacation as a child. And it was too much temptation to resist. Brandon and I drove twenty miles north, into the hills, knowing that a local freestoner had received a second stocking of trout just a few days before.

Brandon barely cut the engine before I jumped out of the truck and into my waders, stringing up lines and laces in no time at all.

“I’m gonna head upstream past the second flat, into that woodsy section away from the road. When I pick off a few fish up there, I might circle back around to the lower end,” I said to Brandon.

“K. Those are big plans.” he replied flatly.

I waded quickly across a side channel and pushed my way through new-green underbrush.

Walking hurriedly, with planned purpose and high hopes, I turned back to see Brandon casually walking down the dirt bank, into what we called the Road Hole.

I ducked and dodged around a maze of low-hanging limbs and briars, looking all the while for anything like a deer trail but finding none. Within a few minutes, I realized I’d overdressed again. The effort to reach the roadless area surpassed any need for an extra layer of fleece. So I took the time to unravel from my vest, belt and waders. I removed the thick black shirt, stowed it away, and redressed.

Honestly, one less layer left me no cooler.

Two hours later, worn out and frustrated, I walked back to Brandon’s truck, much slower on my return downstream than was my hopeful and hurried journey upstream. I brought with me the tale of just one native brook trout, caught and released because it was too small to keep.

Brandon was still in the Road Hole.

“How’d you do?” I started to ask.

Brandon interrupted me with a tilted head and a high hand, open palm faced toward me and holding me off, demanding my silence and stillness.

I paused on the bank across from Brandon and stared while he finished the drift with his rod high. After another cast, he spoke.

“Caught my limit,” he said. And he motioned to the stringer on the bank.

“What the hell, man?” I protested.

Brandon spoke while staring at the water. “Dom, when fishing for stockies, sometimes it does not pay to be ambitious.”

In the next hour I fished directly across from my friend on the small creek. And I filled my own stringer with stocked rainbow trout.

We had a good fish fry that afternoon.

— — — — —

I’ve kept this gem with me. Brandon’s wisdom went against everything I’d grown into as a trout fisherman, because I’d been taught early on to walk in, spread out and find your own water, to explore and get off the muddy fisherman’s path.

But Brandon was right — sometimes it does not pay to be ambitious. Sometimes, fishing for stocked trout is just different. Maybe all the fish were dumped into the Road Hole because they didn’t have enough volunteers to float stock the creek this year. And even after the fish have had time to spread out, upstream and down, they may still group up in slower water. And freshly stocked fish may not respond to a “proper” dead drift presentation as much as something bright and swung against the current.

My Dad’s buddy ties and fishes an ace-in-the-hole pattern that he calls the Hardy’s Hand Grenade. It’s a grape-sized, fluorescent glow bug, and it kills on his favorite, stocked, Maryland streams.

Does stuff like that always work on stocked trout? Nope. But it’s worth the time to consider the trout. How freshly stocked are they? And what’s their life experience up to this point? Stocked trout can be pretty gullible for a while, so why not take advantage of that?

Fish hard, friends.

Enjoy the day.
Domenick Swentosky
T R O U T B I T T E N
domenick@troutbitten.com

 

 

Stories

Read More Troutbitten Stories

TAGS

4
What do you think?

2 Comment threads
2 Thread replies
2 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
3 Comment authors
  Follow the comments on this article.  
Notify of

I used to fish the Sierra’s every summer with family. My dad came up one year which wasn’t the norm. I grew up being told by my uncles that the best fishing was far away from people. When the sun came up I was gone and away from camp as much as possible. I came back one afternoon and my dad said why don’t you fish the stream here next to the tent? I smiled and I’m sure gave a look like he didn’t have a clue what he was talking about. He said “I’ll bet you $10 there are… Read more »

Tom Regan

So, last Tuesday I got hall pass and went out fishing to the lower part of Muddy Creek, York county’s special regs section. Got there 11 am-ish, and was anxious to get on the creek. There was a pick up already parked and he was fishing a near-by usually productive venue and a guy (older than me) puled up and started getting his waders on. I decided to get a fast start and hike a mile up stream to avoid all contact and do my most productive winter spots. This is a rigorous jaunt and, therefore, see few casual folks… Read more »

Domenick Swentosky
BELLEFONTE, PA

Hi. I'm a father of two young boys, a husband, author, fly fishing guide and a musician. I fish for wild brown trout in the cool limestone waters of Central Pennsylvania year round. This is my home, and I love it. Friends. Family. And the river.

STICKERS
STICKERS
TCO Fly Shop
TAGS
Wild vs Stocked safety spot burning Streamer fishing front ended philosophy fly line Doh Little Juniata River Joey carp leaders streamside fishing with kids thunderstorm tracks surf fishing big fish Sighter dry fly fishing stinky bass Ask an Expert Namer Gierach gear tippet Aiden Trust mud brookies Jeff silence nymphs wet fly fishing waders falling in time float catch and release Joe Humphreys tenkara Discovery bite windows snags Streamers nymphing fly box George Harvey Baseball boys explore backcast Memories droppers tight line nymphing camera mono rig tips Fly rods spawning History Backing Barrel Night Fishing Dry-Dropper Fly Casting Wild Brown Trout indicator fishing Fish Hard fighting fish FishHard Floating Galloup dorsey yarn indicator rookies Presentations cookout Dad wild trout Grandfather friendship Bad Mother PFBC ice trout bum solitude Trout Unlimited Night Quote night-sighter Float Fishing Fly Fishing Camping hiking Buggers Wild Mushrooms drop shot nymphing the Mono Rig etiquette How it Started summertime fishing Boat Night Fishing Chapters dry flies public land wet wading wildlife club fishing home-stream beadhead family Headbanger Sculpin winter fishing nymphing tips BES strip set Mystery Sawyer big brown trout Troutbitten Fly Box efficiency Burke bar boots indicator nymphing favorite Fifty Tips conservation reading water State College comp fishing rigs Euro-Nymphing winter backcountry stocked trout wading boots Big Trout fishing tips small streams Christmas Lights knots Plans DJS wading travel traction Peace Spring Creek drifting fly fsihing winter fly fishing science matters rules fluke flies last cast wet flies tightline musician angler types friends brush fishing giveaway Davy Wotten dead drift casting Industry Stuff Whiskey strategy photography flood marginal water Central PA fall fly patterns suspender fishing posted land brown trout Resources saltwater Film Dylan skunked summer swinging tight lining mousing One Great Tip TU Press PA Gold mayfly DIY shark mistakes Pennsylvania It's just fishing LBI river Harvey Pusher DHALO net fly rod come on man PSA Whiskey Drinker high water George Daniel Weather Orvis dog fly tying tiny flies patience Tippet Rings regulations Stockies Grobe simplicity walking Rich eggs Oakiewear split shot montana