The Big Score | Meet the Bad Hombre

May 12, 2017

Spring fishing in Montana. It’s unpredictable and sometimes impossible once the runoff starts, but there are always places. It was a risky time to schedule a family fishing trip, but that’s what he did.

With mugs of steaming coffee and a cargo area damp with fishing gear, Matt and his two brothers drove the truck deep into a morning snowstorm. The air was thick with snow — enough to double their travel time. The crisp, dry snowflakes washed over the windshield in air-cushioned layers. No wipers needed. Just drive through.

“The snow will stop,” Matt told them. Finally it did.

The truck crested a ridge and poked through the clouds. They were above the storm for just a moment, then back down through it for a short period before finally shedding the snow for good. The truck entered an altogether different weather pattern about halfway into the valley. That’s Montana.

They parked in the dirt. It was clear and calm, with air and water temps in the low thirties. Matt tossed a fly box to his brother, Andy, as they pulled on fishing packs and jackets.

“Fish those ones,” he said.

They looped boot laces and tied knots in long leaders. They tucked sharp, curved steel around hook holders, reeled up snug and then walked in.

Photo by Matt Grobe

Matt and his brothers set up on a long pool about the size of a football field. At both the upstream and downstream borders — right where the end zones would be — the river raged with deep, high-gradient, bouldered runs. Between the goal lines, the flat water was shallow enough to be accessible, but deep enough to provide confidence and cover to trout. Big ones. Lots of them.

The raging, persistent water from downstream sounded like the machinery in a Pittsburgh steel mill, and Matt yelled over the commotion.

“If you really want to cover this water you need to stay focused. Find the seams and buckets. Try to make different drifts over each piece,” he told his brothers. And then Matt moved on.

Focused. Yeah, that’s what Matt had been for the two years since he’d moved to Montana. Day after day, he explored trout streams in every season. He found open water and solitude in the winter, so he fished through single digit days just to see what could be done. Why not? Matt didn’t know how long he’d stay in Montana, he just knew he was there right now. So he fished his ass off.

Matt walked to the top of the flat and set up on the inside seam, fishing a pair of nymphs on a tight line. He took a few steps downstream after every three or four drifts, working his way back to his brothers. A couple small fish came to net with sluggish, subtle hits, and Matt knew he needed a change. He added an indicator to the long leader and used it to even out the drifts into long, slow lanes, hugging the bottom of the river. In the cold water, trout weren’t moving far to eat.

Matt reached the bottom of the pool where Andy had crossed. He paused to change the dropper nymph and then started working back upstream, this time reaching further out into the river.


At the upper ten-yard line, Matt stopped. To prepare for a third pass he lengthened the leader, enough to probe the middle seam and get down into the heart of the flat he’d been saving.

Be methodical. That was Matt’s strategy since the day he’d arrived in Montana. He didn’t want to float rivers and rip streamers for a few big fish each day. He wanted to wade miles of water, tucking nymphs into every corner pocket, catching hundreds of fish and digitizing the data into memory. That’s how he fished.

Halfway down the flat, on the fifty yard line and right where the players meet for a coin toss, a small unremarkable nymph tripped over a stone and then recovered. It danced deep into the belly of a bucket, home to the largest and baddest brown in the river, and it paused . . .

One swift tail kick and an angled fin propelled the trout a few inches to the side. The hooked jaw open, captured and closed.

Matt saw the indicator hesitate, but should he set the hook? In an instant he calculated the chances of a take versus a simple bump on a rock. He considered the line’s position and saw the angle leading into darker, green-blue water, into the very guts of the pool. Matt knew where his fly was, and he set the hook hard.

The baddest brown didn’t move. After sixty seconds of strong side pressure, Matt finally forced the fish to yield, and it left the bucket. Matt and the great fish were locked into a tug of war for the next thirty seconds. The huge trout swam back toward the bucket, and Matt pulled as hard as he dared to keep him out.

Then finally, the fish surrendered his position. He turned downstream, and ran for the end zone. But Matt was ready.

Matt followed and stayed sideways. He kept the rod high as it flexed and pulsed and bent deep into the butt section. Matt pulled with side pressure as he raced downstream with the trout. And right at the last hash mark, just at the lip leading into the roaring, bouldered run where no angler could possibly follow, Matt made his goal line stand.

With one last thrust backward, Matt pulled hard on the rod. Every knot in the leader tightened and strained. And just before the 4X transition could snap, the baddest brown resigned.

The trout turned and rolled toward the inside seam, and Matt reeled against the weight. When he finally saw the size of the trout, another surge of adrenaline rushed through Matt’s blood, and he recommitted to end the fight.

With much of its super-strength spent, the great fish surged three more times, but Matt carefully held on. He positioned himself below the trout, somewhere around the twenty yard marker, and he brought the fish near the sidelines, scooping it swiftly into the net.

Sweating and shaking, Matt looked up to see his brothers near the bank.

“This is the one I’ve been waiting for,” Matt breathed heavily.

The trout measured in above the two-foot mark. So Andy asked,

“What’s his name?”

Matt chuckled as he slid the massive wild brown trout into the water and held its tail.

“The Bad Hombre,” Matt said.

With one solid tail kick, and with fins scooping like oars, the baddest brown returned to the fifty yard line, back into the guts of a river.

NOTE: Troutbitten tradition is to name all fish over two feet. And Matt Grobe is the one who started all this nonsense in the first place. It may be a silly tradition, but it’s our tradition. Meet: The Bad Hombre.

Photo from Matt Grobe

Enjoy the day
Domenick Swentosky

Here are a few more Troutbitten posts about namers

What do you think?

7 Comment threads
6 Thread replies
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
8 Comment authors
  Follow the comments on this article.  
Notify of

What an awesome fish. Cool retelling of the battle. That would certainly be a trout of a lifetime for me.


Looks familiar…is that the Depuy Spring Creek above Livingston?

Chase Howard

Love it. All of it. Great fish Grobe!

That is a trout of a lifetime.

Kerry Gubits

What a gorgeous fish.


Outstanding! I just returned from Montana, but will go back with similar resolve. Great article….Thanks!

Steve Troutman

Phew. What a read and definitely the trout of a lifetime. Pure magic.

Domenick Swentosky

Hi. I'm a father of two young boys, a husband, author, fly fishing guide and a musician. I fish for wild brown trout in the cool limestone waters of Central Pennsylvania year round. This is my home, and I love it. Friends. Family. And the river.

Bad Mother wet flies wet fly fishing high water fly rod fall Spring Creek simplicity dry flies Tippet Rings George Daniel Camping Mystery winter fishing mousing Backing Barrel friendship Whiskey fighting fish Dry-Dropper etiquette front ended Davy Wotten strategy silence indicator nymphing catch and release bar boots Big Trout marginal water Grobe Fifty Tips Night solitude travel Harvey Pusher cookout summer TU tracks waders philosophy stocked trout snags fishing with kids Streamer fishing Little Juniata River nymphing Aiden Orvis knots home-stream Night Fishing Trout Unlimited Fly Casting fly patterns leaders Streamers come on man science matters tips Night Fishing Chapters indicator fishing Jeff Dylan wildlife dorsey yarn indicator DHALO fishing tips trout bum reading water explore thunderstorm bite windows Burke swinging family night-sighter Stockies Plans last cast surf fishing Euro-Nymphing Namer gear rigs Pennsylvania patience regulations Fly rods Rich traction flies Peace Grandfather tight lining musician boys tippet time tenkara Dad PA Gold Joey fly box streamside Memories Whiskey Drinker spawning club fishing camera montana BES safety shark flood wading boots tight line nymphing DJS fly line drifting Gierach drop shot nymphing suspender fishing walking hiking Wild Mushrooms summertime fishing mud nymphs wading rules Industry Stuff comp fishing brush fishing PFBC Boat Trust How it Started backcountry George Harvey History Central PA mono rig net Resources Press nymphing tips Headbanger Sculpin Sawyer Presentations Quote photography conservation big fish backcast Galloup big brown trout split shot dead drift mayfly wet wading winter Doh falling in Fly Fishing Oakiewear winter fly fishing Floating fluke Weather giveaway dry fly fishing saltwater mistakes Christmas Lights angler types brookies skunked Sighter posted land Wild Brown Trout efficiency LBI One Great Tip Wild vs Stocked Float Fishing casting wild trout PSA rookies brown trout Fish Hard public land tightline Baseball ice fly fsihing carp Buggers dog tiny flies stinky bass beadhead favorite Ask an Expert droppers fly tying small streams spot burning DIY friends float Troutbitten Fly Box It's just fishing Discovery the Mono Rig