Wild Brown Trout Muddy Meathead

Muddy Meathead

by | Jun 30, 2015 | 13 comments

We slipped our way down the muddy trail in a controlled stumble, just on the edge of going ass-over-teacups into the drink at the end of the line.  The line was a well worn path Dad and I have been down many times before, leading to the top end of a favorite island on a favorite river. We came through the brush to once again meet this water on its own terms.


Not dirty, stained, cloudy, murky or any other of the various terms fishermen use to describe the stages of suspended particles in the flow. Muddy — the worst of the descriptors on the list. Visibility about six inches, at best.

We’ve been through this before. I’d estimate that a full seventy-five percent of our camping trips on this river have been blow-outs. That’s no joke. We’ve been doing this for ten years, and it almost always rains for this trip … a lot.  Often the river gets destroyed the day we get there and starts clearing as we leave. Again, this is not hyperbole. We’ve just not been lucky with river conditions there.

READ: Troutbitten | The River Doesn’t Owe You Anything



So we’ve learned to deal with what we’re given. We find places and ways to fish because Dad is stubborn enough to stick with a plan, and I am (of course) exactly the same way. I like to think of this trait as tenacious, persistent, dedicated conviction. But at its worst we become what wives in our family call obstinate and cranky. Either way, sometimes perseverance pays off . . .

The first day of the trip we traveled over an hour from camp to take a chance on another river. I knew the water was high, but I thought it would be more fishable there.  And it was. We enjoyed good action for a hot summer day, with alternating thunderstorms and sunny skies,  mostly catching wild trout on nymphs, and usually on the edges of faster currents.







In recent years, the muddy creek hasn’t mattered all that much. Because, for part of the trip, I bring my boys to the mountain for a couple days. And while they love to fish, they enjoy the other things that happen at camp even more, like hiking through ferns, mushroom hunting, flashlight games and campfires. You never can predict what will make the biggest imprint in a young boy’s mind. This time it was tailgate rides on Pappy’s truck.


Bad banana placement. My mistake.


It’s quiet out there. When the truck has stopped and the voices are calmed, the silence in the trees is stunning. Not many moments among the din of modern life come with such a pure absence of commotion. No buzz. No hum of electricity. The nothingness will fill up your soul if you let it.


— — — — — —

And so, after returning the boys to the civilized world, I found myself sliding down that muddy trail with my Dad — two hours of daylight left on the third day of Summer Camp 2015.

The sun came off the water about a half hour in, and the fish stirred a bit. I was still fishing streamers, not only because they matched the water type, but because I’m hip to the strip; because I’m totally committed. Because I’m all in. I’m really tough and really trendy. Because my streamer is bigger than yours, and because we all know the only way to catch large trout is on large streamers. Just kidding.

Actually, I’m mostly a nymph fisherman, but sometimes I keep fishing streamers because I’m stubborn . . . and there it is again.

Things started to happen. I moved two really nice trout — the kind of fish that makes you yell four-letter words as the opportunity vanishes — and I picked up a couple average sized browns. I went over to visit with Dad, and I plopped a few casts next to the bank across from him. He was at the top of the river-left side of the island. I walked across to the far side and waded through the high water by myself, into position to fish a place that’s a little special to the Troutbitten guys. I moved a small fish, then chucked the next cast as close to the water-logged tree stump as I dared.  Strip … drift … strip, strip … drift… strip … BAM!

Momentum carried him to the top of the brown water, and I saw the fish I’ve been waiting for. He swam hard to the tree stump, but with strong 2X I changed his mind. These are the moments fishermen live for. It was the culmination of a new streamer pattern, a new rig that Burke showed me, and relentless hope against forceful, muddy water.

He took a couple of runs, but considering his size, the fight was short. I surprised him with the net, aided by the cover of muddy water.


Muddy Meathead

Big Boy

It was the best fish I’ve caught since New Year’s Eve.

I sat and watched the moving water grow darker, until the moon reflected across the muddy surface.

I love the water.


Enjoy the day.
Domenick Swentosky



Share This Article . . .

Since 2014 and 600 articles deep
Troutbitten is a free resource for all anglers
Your support is greatly appreciated

– Explore These Post Tags –

Domenick Swentosky

Central Pennsylvania

Hi. I’m a father of two young boys, a husband, author, fly fishing guide and a musician. I fish for wild brown trout in the cool limestone waters of Central Pennsylvania year round. This is my home, and I love it. Friends. Family. And the river.

More from this Category

VIDEO: The River Doesn’t Owe You Anything

VIDEO: The River Doesn’t Owe You Anything

Today, I’m proud to announce the launch of Troutbitten videos, in collaboration with Wilds Media. The journey begins with a video adaptation of, “The River Doesn’t Owe You Anything.” This story has been a Troutbitten favorite since it was published in the spring of 2019. . . . The river gives you what you need. The river gives you what you earn.

The Secret

The Secret

There are two kinds of secret places, I suppose: one’s that are truly tucked away somewhere unknown, and ones that lies right underneath a fisherman’s nose. This place harbors a little of both . . .



Smith and I hopped the guardrail as traffic whizzed by at sixty miles an hour. Smith went first, with his rod tip trailing behind, and he sliced through the brush like a hunter. I followed with probably too much gear for a three hour trip and a puppy in my arms. River is our family’s eleven week old Australian Shepherd, and with a name like that, he has no choice but to become a great fishing dog. Time on the water will do it . . .

Aiden’s First Brown Trout

Aiden’s First Brown Trout

Hundreds of times Aiden has snagged the bottom, pulled the rod back, and either asked me if that was a fish or has told me flatly, “I think that was a fish.”  This time, he finally experienced the certainty that a couple of good head shakes from a trout will give you . . .

Waves and Water

Waves and Water

. . . But when all of that dries up, when the travel seems too long, when dawn comes too early and when chasing a bunch of foot-long trout seems like something you’ve already done, then what’s left — always — is the river . . .

The Foundation

The Foundation

There is tranquility and stillness here — a place to do nothing but think. And that alone is valuable. Because there aren’t many places like this left in the world . . .

What do you think?

Be part of the Troutbitten community of ideas.
Be helpful. And be nice.


  1. Read your about page… I Thought the vegetation looked like PA. Good story!

  2. Dom in my opinion the stories are your best work. I can recall there being writing like this in Field and Stream when I was younger and always appreciated how those stories evoked the excitement in me, just like this one did. Thank you.

    • Thanks for reading, John.

  3. Great story Dom. But what about this tease…”It was the culmination of a new streamer pattern, a new rig that Burke showed me”? ( By the way, if you hadn’t mentioned the banana 95% of the readers probably wouldn’t have noticed. Tip: It’s better to explain your faux pas after the fact than to draw attention to them at the get-go. Ask your Dad.) And I hope you realize I’m pulling your leg!

    • Nice.

  4. Great read .. awesome brown too.

    • It was a fun fish.

  5. Dom where’s the discussion of a new streamer pattern, a new rig that Burke showed you?

    • It’s not yet written down, brother.

  6. Dominic, this story is great! Made me laugh out loud twice…banana comment and the hip to the strip streamer fishing paragraph. What is it with steamer fishing!?!?! I guess if I got better at it I’d get it more. You’ve certainly got it figured out. I caught a big cutthroat on the snake a long time ago with high muddy water. Such a great feeling. You captured it well! Thanks.

  7. What a nice story – fishin’ & family. With a great happy ending!

  8. Great story. I wished night fishing was legal after dark on most trout streams in VA. I’ve tried it once before I found out it was illegal. Had a few bumps on my mouse in a pool known to hold huge stockers rainbows. I’ll keep looking for new opportunities. Keep it up.

  9. Great post, great site and you’ve opened new vistas, while eviscerating previous assumptions. And… fine photography.


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Recent Articles

Recent Posts

Pin It on Pinterest