Mysteries, Mistakes and Misunderstandings | Drop Shot Nymphing on a Tight Line Rig — Pt.6

by | Jan 25, 2023 | 13 comments

** NOTE ** This is the sixth installment of the Troutbitten Short Series covering drop shot nymphing.

Find the full series HERE.

— — — — — —

I began this series on drop shot nymphing close to a year ago. And after five in-depth Troutbitten articles, I’ve received hundreds of comments and questions on the topic. There are themes within.

Although ancient in its fishing design, drop shotting remains a mystery to many anglers. There are confusions inherent, often stemming from the connotation of terms. More than ever, with drop shot, I’m reminded that words matter — that our understanding of anything new starts by wiping the slate clean from the bias of preconceived notions.

There is still more to write in this Drop Shot Nymphing On a Tight Line series. But next, let’s break through some of the mystery. Let’s clear up some misunderstandings and correct mistakes that arise when drop shot nymphing is brought up.

In no particular order . . .

No, Not That Heavy

This one is easily the most commonly misunderstood aspect of the subject. Drop shot does not mean we’re fishing heavy.

Throughout the series I’ve called this a finesse system. It is. The tight line advantage, the leader design and the way we fish it allows lighter weights to get down quickly.

Most drop shot rigs require more weight to counteract the resistance and drag of a bobber, of heavier lines and thicker leaders or tapers under the water. Instead, the system I’ve detailed throughout this series takes all the advantage of a tight line rig and merges it with the advantage of drop shotting.

The weights I use are no heavier than the weight of my beadhead flies. I most commonly use the drop shot balls that I showed in part three of this series. I fish these in 1/64, 1/48, 1/32, 1,24 and 1/16 of an ounce. That’s a range of about 40 cg to 180 cg. And for reference, most flies with a 3.5 mm bead on them weigh about 40 cg.

The point is, this is not a chuck and duck rig, with extra weight and hardware attached. (Avoid swivels and clasps, because you don’t need them.) The weight need not be heavy. I rarely fish the 1/16, and I most often fish the 1/32 ounce. All of this, of course, is dictated by the water you are fishing and your own needs.

READ: Troutbitten | The Weights — Drop Shot Nymphing On a Tight Line Rig, Pt. 3

Photo by Bill Dell

Tangles and Clumsy Casting?

I grant you this: A drop shot rig looks like it should tangle more — especially with two flies on tags, above the shot, as I’ve laid out in the rigging part of this series.

What’s the truth? It tangles less than traditional split shot placement.

With all the weight at the end of the line, the rig is a breeze to cast if you have solid fly casting fundamentals. Don’t lob. Don’t create wide open loops, as this takes away from your presentation options. Don’t rely on the weight for casting. Learn to cast the line and leader itself. Build good, clean fly casting loops into the presentation, and the rig will go where you put it, with the necessary grace to reach the bottom quickly. Do this, and you’ll have very few tangles.

A drop shot rig surely does tangle more than a single, weighted nymph. And when a drop shot rig tangles, yes, there is more to untangle. But the frequency of those tangles is less than placing split shot in between two flies, and it is much less than a bobber rig with two flies below.

READ: Troutbitten | The Rigging — Drop Shot Nymphing On a Tight Line Rig, Pt. 4

Not So Far

Those first couple were misunderstandings. Now, here’s a mistake that I see happen with drop shotting — fishing too far away.

With more weight, we lengthen our sagless reach on a tight line. Just ten centigrams makes a big difference. And it’s tempting to go heavier in an effort to reach further. However, fishing longer comes with complications. We are less accurate, we can’t see into the water as much, and we have poor strike detection at long distances.

Many anglers fall into the trap of thinking longer drifts are better drifts, while the opposite is true. Short, effective drifts catch more trout.

Absolutely, I use drop shot to help improve my effective fishing range. It’s a great problem solver that way. But it’s easy to fall into the habit of using that greater range too often. Long, far off drifts are intoxicating. Don’t get addicted.

READ: Troutbitten | Know Your Weights and Measures

Photo by Bill Dell

Lazy Fishing

Along these same lines — and whether we’re far off or up close — a drop shot rig might make you complacent. If you’re using a drop shot to tick the bottom and treat that as a reference, it’s easy to think you’ve got everything right down there, just because you feel the shot make contact.

But that’s not good enough.

It takes awareness and discipline to drift a nymph rig in one seam — the only route to a true dead drift. And with the extra contact that drop shot provides, it’s up to us to decide everything about the course of the attached flies: the speed, depth, angle and lane choice are all in our hands. And that’s a big responsibility.

Inattention to these details is the primary reason I believe anglers turn away from drop shot after a few uses. Without strict attention to the details mentioned, trout simply won’t buy the presentation. Never settle. Aim for perfect drifts.

Wrong Weights

I’d never tell you that you need the drop shot balls that I use to fish this rig. Although it’s as easy as clipping the hook shank from a lead ball jig, I’m aware that most anglers won’t take this step. (You should. The balls cannot be beat.)

Split shot is fine, and anglers have been doing this for a century or more.

But I do recommend lead shot over non-toxic. Stone me for my recommendation if you must, but nothing bounces over rocks like lead. The non-toxic shot is a fair substitute, but I love the feel of lead at the riverbed. It is dense and drops quickly, yet it bounces and glides over rocks. Tungsten weights are also fine, if you can find them, but they bounce less. Tungsten putty is the worst choice, because its softness deadens the feel that I’m looking for in a drop shot rig, taking away one of the premier advantages of the system. All of this might sound like hocus-pocus. I understand that. But try all of your options before letting skepticism take over.

If you do choose split shot, I’m strongly in favor of using one shot rather than a string of them. I cannot understand the belief that four shot will hang less than one, especially if they are spaced out at the bottom of the leader. Instead, four shot equals four points to grab the next rock or tangle on the next tree part.

So fish one shot instead of multiple for fewer hang ups. That’s my experience.

Touch Too Much

All this talk about the drop shot ticking and using the riverbed as a reference can tempt you into too much of a good thing.

Extra contact might make the flies jump, jiggle and stall too much. That’s not a dead drift. So if they aren’t eating your presentation that touches ten times on the way down through, try cutting that in half, and then in half again.

Remember, these decisions are yours. The choice is in your rod tip.

Strikes and Feel

I feel more strikes on a drop shot rig than I do with any other style of nymphing rig. That can be attributed to the flies being above the shot. Because we’re most in touch with the heaviest thing on our line, we are in contact and in control of the drop shot, so when a fish eats a fly above, we just might feel it.

But we might not.

This is no different than a fly on a tag above another weighted fly in a standard euro-nymphing setup. And no good angler I know expects to feel the takes on the upper fly in that setup. Of course you might. But trout may just as well take the fly with subtlety and caution. They may drift back with the fly a bit or turn back down slowly after eating it.

If you’re waiting to feel the strikes on any tight line rig, you’re behind the set way too often. As always, on a tight line system, strike detection is primarily visual. Watch that sighter.

Do It

Approach drop shot nymphing on a tight line rig the same as you approach it with the flies and weights in any other configuration. That is — get good dead drifts.

And while the drop shot provides some unique advantages to those drifts, it can just as well hurt the presentation. Drop shot is not a magic bean.

But if you use it well, knowing the advantages and remaining disciplines within the system, you’ll have another tool that excels in many river situations.

Fish hard, friends.

** Subscribe to Troutbitten and follow along. (It’s  free.) ** 

** Donate ** If you enjoy this article, please consider a donation. Your support is what keeps this Troutbitten project funded. Scroll below to find the Donate Button. And thank you.

 

Enjoy the day
Domenick Swentosky
T R O U T B I T T E N
domenick@troutbitten.com

 

Share This Article . . .

Since 2014 and 900+ articles deep
Troutbitten is a free resource for all anglers.
Your support is greatly appreciated.

– Explore These Post Tags –

Domenick Swentosky

Central Pennsylvania

Hi. I’m a father of two young boys, a husband, author, fly fishing guide and a musician. I fish for wild brown trout in the cool limestone waters of Central Pennsylvania year round. This is my home, and I love it. Friends. Family. And the river.

More from this Category

When Gear Gets In the Way

When Gear Gets In the Way

No matter what we’re into, there’s a time when the learning of skills reaches a critical mass, when it’s time to do rather than read more about it and buy more gear.
. . .There’s a time for learning. There’s time for preparation. And then there’s time for doing — for putting all of it into practice, making the casts, covering water and catching fish . . .

Five Keys to Reading the Sighter (with VIDEO)

Five Keys to Reading the Sighter (with VIDEO)

Control. Options. Precision. These are the most attractive aspects of fishing a tight line system, and the sighter is the key to it all.

A sighter is more than a strike indicator. It also shows depth, angle, speed and contact. It points to our flies and takes away the guesswork. For an angler who learns to read all of this on the sighter, that colored line above the water provides a most significant advantage to the underwater game . . .

Getting Closer

Getting Closer

When I start wondering why the fishing seems slow, I first check my distance. Have I started creeping the cast too far beyond that perfect baseline? If so, I reel in a couple turns. I wade closer, staying behind the trout and being cautious with my approach.

Hook Sets Are Not Free

Hook Sets Are Not Free

Mike had landed on a common phrase that usually triggers a response from me. It’s one of the myths of fly fishing, and it carries too much consequence to let it go. Hook sets are not free. There’s a price to pay. Oftentimes that cost is built into our success. And other times, the costs of too frequently setting the hook pile up, stealing away our limited opportunities . . .

Fly Distance — What You’re Missing by Following FIPS Competition Rules — Part Three

Fly Distance — What You’re Missing by Following FIPS Competition Rules — Part Three

Fly distance restrictions unnecessarily limit the common angler from taking full advantage of tight line systems. If you choose to fish under FIPS rules, do so by choice, with your eyes wide open and for good reason. Take a fresh look at why you are choosing your flies, your leaders, your fly rods and your tactics. And be sure that you’ve thought through both the benefits and the consequences inherent.

What do you think?

Be part of the Troutbitten community of ideas.
Be helpful. And be nice.

13 Comments

  1. Excellent article. The tactics you highlighted are spot on. Especially your remark about anglers not trying it long enough.. Without the fundamentals you described, it becomes just another nymph rig that can catch some fish.

    Also, drop-shot is very useful for Great Lakes steelhead. The rig and flies need to be scaled up, but never as much as you’d think. Contact II 6 weight, along with the trout size models, is the perfect rod series for this.

    Reply
    • Dom as usual,,enjoy the specifics here.. we all experienced here visualize what we experienced on eventful trips even the big events that stick long term memory decades ago.. Yes Dom agree with all the above.. practicing the basic fundamentals makes better and knowledge by experience even better 1) As for my 2023 approach ( god willing I get the time off to go on my usually NY Catskill blue ribbons)For now learning much from you and thanks!Looking forward to 2023 on the creeks.. Great detail preparation thanks to you…. I have yet to catch a trout on a euro nymphing setup.. I still look forward to my old traditional dry fly setups.. but know this euro rig stuff is going to be more interesting! newbie I am, but with your articles I feel most confident.. .. all Troutbitten articles are perfect for me and some!..casting tying knots tandem rigging helps make things work better .. control..options as from choice of gear to the bottom bug on tippet .. Dom cheers and tight lines good buddy!.. OH BTW..I ordered that 4lb Seaguar lazr.06in.dia,, figure it’s a good go too strong not too stiff low memory flouro for tandem rigs ( any update on tippet material appreciated).. I been testing last seasons and even older tippet brands 100% fluorocarbon from 7x to 1x using the tug of war between a split ring 2.5mm…. As for time to fish test weights drop shots etc..it’s tough I can’t wing it on the stream but I’ll just practice casting my new euro setup in my backyard ( presentation leaders micro leaders targetets on the inground covered.. As for knots.. I like the Davey knot double Davey .. getting fast tying them all .. also the 16-20 same knot penny /pitzner knot” surgeons orvis blood knots.. all them I’m finding out how to tie them much faster even without forceps..cheers!

      Reply
  2. Excellent – will try this technique and see how much it reduces the dreaded tangles

    Reply
    • Good stuff. Respectfully, it is casting that reduces tangles much more than rigging.

      Reply
  3. Correct about clipping the shot off of a jig head, started doing that after your article awhile back, easy to tie on, no crimping needed.

    Reply
  4. I am a fly fishing guide in North Central Arkansas for trout and I use the drop shot method of fishing on all my guide trips regardless of how much water is being generated. I sometimes fish tight to an indicator or tight to my tandem fly setup. I do like to use the clam shot from Bass Pro over the round split shot. While I have sighter material I very seldom use it because I prefer to teach my clients the feel of a take versus the bottom of a stream. There is a distinct difference between the two and all anglers should learn it.

    Reply
  5. Great article Dom, just a quick question do you feel that with this type of rig you actually feel more strikes than you see as we’re trained to do with a tightline rig Thanks for another great article Dom.

    Reply
  6. Every time I read something here I learn more and more, and it always comes when I think I’m starting to figure it out.

    Thanks for always teaching Dom,

    Cheers

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Articles

Recent Posts

Domenick Swentosky

Central Pennsylvania

Hi. I’m a father of two young boys, a husband, author, fly fishing guide and a musician. I fish for wild brown trout in the cool limestone waters of Central Pennsylvania year round. This is my home, and I love it. Friends. Family. And the river.

Pin It on Pinterest