The Fundamental Mistake of Tight Line and Euro Nymphing Anglers

by | Jun 13, 2021 | 20 comments

The tight line game is a wonderful way to fly fish. From euro nymphing to streamers, from dry flies to indicator setups, employing a tight line advantage puts the angler in control of everything from rod tip to fly. Performed with skill and intention, the cast is snappy and elegant — deadly accurate and efficient. For these reasons the popularity of tight line and euro nymphing tactics have soared in recent years.

These rigs are radically different from a standard approach, and success can come quickly. In short order, anglers double their catch rate and may become complacent about the tactics. But more is possible. In truth, it takes years of study and attentive angling to get beneath the surface and find the next level. And then, with an angler who’s in control of every element, from the cast through the drift, the possibilities for variation and improvement are infinite.

READ: Troutbitten | Beyond Euro Nymphing

It takes seasons of dedication. And like so many other disciplines, there is a natural path to follow. There are steps and stages to tight lining. There are baseline skills to develop before moving on — before adding in more complicated tactics and maneuvers. Skipping ahead hurts the angler far more than it helps put trout in the net. And yet, many anglers have no idea what to focus on first or next. (An upcoming Troutbitten series, Essential Skills for Tight Line and Euro Nymphing covers all of this.)

There is no hierarchy of tactics in fly fishing, but there certainly is a preferred order of things to learn. We build a series of skills, and one building block is placed upon the foundation of the others.

The Biggest Mistake

Anglers fish too far off, too soon. Read that again.

It’s the fundamental mistake of tight line and euro nymphing anglers. The critical tight liner’s skills must be learned up close before they can ever be performed at distance. There are no shortcuts.

Turn the flies over, tuck the flies in and stick the landing with a sighter angle of about forty-five degrees. If you can’t do that at twenty feet then you surely can’t do it at thirty. You must learn accuracy, hitting the target repeatedly at close range before trying to shoot any further. So fish close until you can land the fly, tippet and sighter the same way — in the same seam, over and over again.

Far too often, anglers are tempted to extend the cast beyond what they can control. They watch too many videos with fly fishers who cast far but never take time to break down the basics. They see fellow anglers bombing casts across stream, well beyond what is necessary or prudent. And because bigger always seems better, many anglers fall into the trap of trying to emulate this. They want big casts and long drifts when exactly the opposite is what catches trout on a tight line.

Too far too soon. That’s the biggest mistake.

READ: Troutbitten | The Case for Shorter Casts

River. Ever watchful.

It’s a Short Range Game

Somewhere among the flow of informative articles and video tutorials the true effective range of a tight line approach has gotten lost. In the last few years, we’ve witnessed an obsession with casting lighter flies at longer distances. Make no mistake, it’s a great tactic, but going extra long and light is a fringe technique. It has a place, but it’s a specialized approach that’s rarely necessary. What’s more, all long range tactics have their effective roots in the baseline of short range techniques.

Three times the length of the rod — that’s the range for your tight line nymphing system. Streamers or indy rigs on a tight line can be pushed out to another rod length, but that’s about it. For tight line and euro nymphing, it’s three times the length of the rod. Somewhere around thirty feet is the end of the effective range of a tight line system. And yes, you can cast it a few more feet, but soon enough, you lose the pure tight line advantage, no matter how thin the leader build or how good the tuck cast.

So then, the operating range of tight line nymphing is from right under your rod tip, (about ten feet) out to about thirty feet. And within that range there is a world of difference in casting, drifting and leader performance. Yes, fishing thirty feet away requires more skill than fishing twelve. But it’s often less productive.

READ: Troutbitten | Series | Know Your Weights and Measures

Truly, the only way to drift effectively at the maximum range of three times the rod length is to first learn to drift at twice the rod length. Master the short game. Because that’s the only way to go longer.

Let’s dig in a little more . . .

Choose the Right Water for Learning

For many years, I kept a rough fishing log. I wish I’d been more thorough and consistent in my record keeping, but my log does give enough of a reference to realize this truth: I tight lined for five years, focusing on perfecting only my short range. At the time, I had no interest in fishing further away, because I didn’t need to. Fifteen to twenty feet was my game. And twenty-five was pushing it.

Sure, I fished dries or streamers when the trout suggested it was necessary. But my day-to-day focus was on perfecting the foundation for good tight lining. I didn’t think of it that way, though. I was just catching a bunch of fish in fast riffles, runs and pocket water — so many that I had no reason to do otherwise.

When I reached the top of a run and saw the tailout above, I skipped the pool, walked past the flat and moved into the next section of fast moving water. I knew these were the bug factories — the feeding zones for trout. And I caught more and bigger fish by focusing on where trout feed the most. Because I was in broken water, with a mostly upstream approach, I waded within short casting range. I tucked in my tight line and focused on getting perfect drifts — short and targeted rides in pockets and lanes. Then I set the hook into my backcast. And with one swift motion I was back into the seam in a second. With the line in the water constantly, I picked apart one seam at a time. Nothing could be more efficient.

This is perfect water for tight lining at short distance. Look at all those tight targets.

The Tools In Our Hands

In those five early years, I fished an 8’ 6” five weight St. Croix Avid fly rod, paired with a long leader that was quite similar to the Standard Mono Rig that I use today. That’s right. Eight feet. Six inches. Five weight. These days, the uninitiated would chuckle at my rod selection for euro nymphing. But back then, this was well before any company had branded their product a “Euro Rod.” And though I would have gladly fished a longer tool, I simply used what I had and what I could afford.

I’m very, very glad that I did.

The short rod forced me to stay close. Anything further than twenty feet, and the leader sag started hurting my presentation, which I intuitively understood in short time. The close range allowed me to see more, feel more, control more and fish more effectively.

The stiffer five weight forced me to speed up my cast — to flex the rod and cast the leader. The turnover and tuck came naturally, and sticking the landing with the sighter just made sense. But it all came from building speed in the cast. It still does. Even when I fish a two or three weight rod these days, I have the same built-in speed and a tight casting V, which offers amazing control over both fly and the tippet placement.

The truth is, if I’d started on a two or three weight rod, with its extra flex, I may have missed a world of available options. And this is what I see from the vast majority of tight line and euro nymphing angler who use light, flexible rods. They lob weights around instead of casting the leader and the flies with precision.

READ: Troutbitten | Fly Fishing the Mono Rig — It’s Casting, Not Lobbing

Make no mistake, specialized rods are wonderful tools for their applications. But, like all fly rods, they are used most effectively with a great casting stroke. Without some knowledge, without eyes wide open, these specialized tools can encourage bad habits that are very hard to break.

But no matter the tool, no matter the rod, line or design of the leader in hand, the tight line angler must focus on the short game first. Perfect it until accuracy is repeatable, until all the skills are refined at short range. Then start fishing at progressively longer distances (but only when it’s necessary.)

River claws. That’s the kind of traction to envy.

The Good Stuff

All the best things happen at short range, and it’s folly to cast further without full control.

We see more at close range: rocks, logs, ledges, breaks, trout, strikes and even (sometimes) the fly itself. With a better visual for where the fly is and what it might run into next, we set a better course for the drift.

We control more at close range. We see the seam and now we can more accurately hold the fly in one lane, lead it around the next rock, or permit it to drop into an upstream bucket.

We feel more at close range. Tight lining is about contact. We feel the flies tick the bottom, we feel more strikes, and we feel the minor load of the strike zone pulling slightly on the rod tip, all better at close range. Longer lines simply deaden the feel. That sensitivity is dispersed over longer lengths of leader.

We can fish without stripping line at close range. All the slack recovery can be managed by either lifting or leading with the rod tip. Good line hand technique is a challenging hurdle for many tight line anglers, and the learning is simplified by using a fixed line at short distances.

We learn the proper angles of delivery and drift when fishing at close range. We see the negative effects of flies crossing seams by watching the entry point of the tippet, an angle that either rides perfectly parallel with the current or goes against it.

READ: Troutbitten | One Great Nymphing Trick

Discipline

Perhaps most importantly, focusing on short casts and targeted drifts forces the angler to be disciplined. Instead of stripping more line off the reel to reach an extra eight feet, we wade. We take a couple steps upstream or across. Such an approach keeps the angler mobile, in constant motion by shuffling, stepping, wading and leaning to perfect the drift, refining each and every seam.

With this discipline we get in rhythm. Longer casts require adjustments to the stroke, but fishing short range keeps us casting in time like a ticking clock. Cast, drift, set, cast. With no interruption but the netting of a trout.

Your next time out with a tight line, be mindful of your casting distance. Stay within two rod lengths and find a rhythm. If you feel like you have to fish further away, then you’re in the wrong water. Relocate, get close, and perfect your short game. Even for advanced anglers who can stick the landing at thirty-five feet, if the action is slow, fishing short is almost always the best solution. Get back to the basics and refine them.

Fish hard, friends.

** Subscribe to Troutbitten and Follow Along (It’s Free). **

** Donate ** If you enjoy this article, please consider a donation. Your support is what keeps this Troutbitten project funded. Scroll below to find the Donate Button. And thank you.

 

Enjoy the day
Domenick Swentosky
T R O U T B I T T E N
domenick@troutbitten.com

 

Share This Article . . .

Since 2014 and 600 articles deep
Troutbitten is a free resource for all anglers
Your support is greatly appreciated

– Explore These Post Tags –

Domenick Swentosky

Central Pennsylvania

Hi. I’m a father of two young boys, a husband, author, fly fishing guide and a musician. I fish for wild brown trout in the cool limestone waters of Central Pennsylvania year round. This is my home, and I love it. Friends. Family. And the river.

More from this Category

Leaders Relaunch in the Troutbitten Shop

Leaders Relaunch in the Troutbitten Shop

Troutbitten leaders are back in the Shop. There are some unique features to Troutbitten leaders that make a big difference. These are hand tied leaders in four varieties: Harvey Dry Leader, Standard Mono Rig, Thin Mono Rig, and Micro-Thin Mono Rig. Standard Sighters are also available, and they include a Backing Barrel. The Full Mono Rig Kit contains each of the three Mono Rig leaders, three foam spools and a twenty-inch Rio Bi-Color extension.

All Troutbitten leaders come on a three-inch spool, making long leader changes a breeze . . .

#3. Sticking the Landing: Nine Essential Skills for Tight Line and Euro Nymphing

#3. Sticking the Landing: Nine Essential Skills for Tight Line and Euro Nymphing

The goal is to stick the landing on the sighter — to end in the final position perfectly, rather than struggling to find it after the landing. The best anglers learn to adjust the amount of slack — and therefore, time to contact — within the cast. That’s the art of a good tuck cast. So we tuck and then stick the landing on the sighter at an angle and depth where we expect to catch that contact . . .

Wet Wading Gear and a System for Fly Fishers

Wet Wading Gear and a System for Fly Fishers

Did you know that breathable waders only effectively breath when they’re underwater? Fun fact, right? The permeable membranes can only pass water vapor while submersed. Not such a big deal when you aren’t producing much water vapor (evaporating sweat), but it’s a messy, clammy situation when the mercury climbs and the water drops. Amiright?

What to do, then? Wet wade. Good wet wading has nothing to do with a pair of old sneakers and cargo shorts. Don’t do that. Instead, here are the elements of a good wet wading system . . .

What do you think?

Be part of the Troutbitten community of ideas.
Be helpful. And be nice.

20 Comments

  1. Thank you very much for your interesting post and insight!

    Tight lines

    Reply
  2. Dom, I imagine this article will stir up a lot of comments. This is hands down the most important tight line piece I’ve read. It clearly articulates the key skills that matter. I will read and re-read this piece for years. Coming from a 5wt floating line background with the headset that longer, “heroic” casts are always better (as if the fish cared) this advice also applies to swinging with a 2 handed rod where it is easy to confuse casting prowess with what is happening underwater.

    Reply
    • Right on. I think it applies almost everywhere.

      There’s fly casting, and there’s fly fishing.

      Dom

      Reply
  3. Good article Dom. This is my third year of euro nymphing, and I have actually found as well, that I do best by stripping off roughly one rod length of line from the reel. I use either a 10 foot or 10 foot 6 inch rod. This really seems to give me great control over the drift and by just lifting the rod I don’t have a need to strip line. Now this is not possible all the time, and I will use longer line and a “float the sighter” technique on slow water. But I certainly prefer using the shorter line whenever possible. Have a good day!
    Dave

    Reply
  4. Greetings,dig your articles & always look forward to them.Curious as to why you never touch on “drop shoting” techniques.I dabble with the Euro Nymphing but seem to have better success with drop shoting,might have something to do with my skill set,but there’s something about having constant contact with the bottom also.
    Regards,

    Reply
  5. Excellent article Dom!

    Reply
  6. Thank you for writing your articles. i always look forward to reading Troutbitten every morning. Also, thank you for what you do to help Fly Fishermen and Fly Fisher Women. your articles always make me think of how i can improve my Euro Nymphing and also points out what i am doing wrong. i work at a local High school and i started a Fly Fishing Fly Tying club a few years ago. i always pass along your information to the student to help get them catching more trout. Again, Thank you for what you do!

    Reply
  7. I use an 8’ Winston TMF. It’s perfect for the small creeks I fish in the Driftless area of Wisconsin and Minnesota. I can make the mono rig behave just about anyway I want with this rod. Granted, I’m fishing spring creeks that can be leaped across in most cases, but that’s the adaptation I have made to make tight lining work for me and my casting/fishing styles and the creeks I fish. Somewhere else,I might rig up differently.

    I couldn’t agree with you more Dom: Get on top of those fish with your best heron like approach and keep those casts as short as possible. Control, control, control.

    Reply
  8. Good article, Dom. I have one question about a phrase you used to describe your technique: you mentioned “sticking the landing with the sighter”. Not sure what you meant by that, please elaborate. I understand what you wrote right before that, about the turnover and the tuck cast. Thanks.

    Reply
  9. When I fished with you 4 years ago, one of my first questions was “should we be fishing this close?” Always was amazed at how many fish are caught in a rod length.

    Reply
  10. Dom,
    As I read this, I could hear your voice in my ear! Dan and I fished the narrows with you back in March, at the end of the day, as we were walking back to the cars, you left me with a single piece of advice, “Fish the water in front of you.”
    I have repeated this to myself countless times since then (usually when I’m standing inside the backend of a 50′ pool and about to cast up the far corner of the head… old habits; ) Each time I check myself back to the short game, I not only catch more fish, I tend to make better adjustments, and get a much better understanding of the water. Thanks for the great advice, as always.

    Reply
    • That’s the truth, Brian. Same here. Reminding myself to stay close just cleans everything up.

      Dom

      Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Articles

Recent Posts

Domenick Swentosky

Central Pennsylvania

Hi. I’m a father of two young boys, a husband, author, fly fishing guide and a musician. I fish for wild brown trout in the cool limestone waters of Central Pennsylvania year round. This is my home, and I love it. Friends. Family. And the river.

Pin It on Pinterest