Why do we miss trout on a nymph?

by | May 31, 2020 | 2 comments

Missed ‘em. How many thousands of times have we said that? And why do we miss so many hits, takes or eats on our nymphs?

Late hook sets are a problem, as is guessing about whether we should set the hook in the first place. But I believe, more times than not, when we miss a trout, the fish actually misses the fly. However, that doesn’t let us off the hook either. It’s probably still our fault. And here’s why . . .

Out of Touch

Under a conventional nymphing setup, let’s say, with flies hanging below a bobber while the fly line and leader lay on top, there’s a lot of slack in the system. Mending line to free the bobber from the effects of drag deliberately introduces slack. And I’ve seen some anglers purposely feed more slack to the nymph trying to allow for a deeper ride.

The conventional nymphing system is flawed, in my view. But that’s another discussion. Point is, it’s a method with a mess of slack and a loss of contact. So of course we are going to miss strikes while fishing. When a trout eats, we might have no indication until the fish is already letting go. We set the hook by picking up all the slack to get tight, and more precious milliseconds are wasted. By the time we’re tight and snapping the hookset, the trout is ejecting the fly.

Missed ‘em.

In that case, it’s probably true.

Photo by Bill Dell

But what about our contact methods of nymphing? What about tight line, euro nymphing and all of the in-touch, contact stuff? How can we be missing strikes then? Why is it that even the best tight line nymphing anglers still miss fifteen to twenty percent of the fish? (Ask around, they’ll admit it.) If we’re in touch, how do we miss the take?

READ: Troutbitten | Euro Nymphing and the Mono Rig

I think we don’t. Instead, I believe two other things are far more common. And here they are . . .

Refusals

Think back to the last time you stripped streamers for a few hours with decent action. Maybe it was just yesterday. I’d bet my best fly box that you had a trout chase, swipe, tap or swirl, but he didn’t take. Right?

It’s expected. Refusals are part of the streamer game.

We see the same thing on top. Trout track our dry as it’s drifting beautifully down the seam. They tilt back and rise with the current against their belly, lifting them to the surface to meet the dry at the perfect time, and . . . they turn away. In softer water, the toughest trout even bump and nudge our dries before deciding not to eat them. Refusals are part of the dry fly game too.

So why would the nymphing game be any different?

We rarely get chances to sight fish in my limestone region. So I cannot say that I’ve seen many trout refuse the nymphs. But of course they do. They slide over to the fly and inspect or eat it, and they refuse the fly at the last instant. Maybe they even bump it while turning away.

Surely this tendency explains some of the accidental foul hookings too. Trout are picky. And when something about the fly turns them off, they may have already bumped our line. Remember, the leader is tight. So we see the sighter move and the tippet hesitate, or we feel the strike.

Hook set!

Missed ‘em.

He didn’t miss this one. Photo by Bill Dell

Bad Drifts

Another thing the best tight line anglers will admit after a few beers is that over half their drifts are bad. Most of the time, we fish them out anyway. Because we’ve learned that trout are full of surprises, and a line in the water catches more trout than a line in the air.

So in our struggle for perfection, we deliver a lot of imperfect casts and unnatural drifts. Sometimes, the drift of the nymph is so close to natural that the trout buys it. And maybe he goes all in and tries to eat the fly. He slides over to the south bank seam to intercept our offering. Having seen ten-thousand nymphs and other things drifting naturally in that south bank current, this trout has some expectations. And when our imperfect drift approaches the trout, the nymph may slide away from him ever so slightly. It’s just enough for the trout to touch our line but not get the fly. Or he gets a half bite instead of a full one.

Missed ‘em.

Fish hard, friends.

 

Enjoy the day.
Domenick Swentosky
T R O U T B I T T E N
domenick@troutbitten.com

 

Share This Article . . .

Since 2014 and 600 articles deep
Troutbitten is a free resource for all anglers
Your support is greatly appreciated

– Explore These Post Tags –

Domenick Swentosky

Central Pennsylvania

Hi. I’m a father of two young boys, a husband, author, fly fishing guide and a musician. I fish for wild brown trout in the cool limestone waters of Central Pennsylvania year round. This is my home, and I love it. Friends. Family. And the river.

More from this Category

Turnover

Turnover

In short, turnover gives us freedom to choose what happens with the line that’s tethered to the fly. How does the tippet and leader land? With contact or with slack? And where does it land? In the seam and partnered with the fly, or in an adjacent current? By having mastery of turnover, we dictate the positioning of not just the fly, but the leader itself. And nothing could be more important . . .

Regarding Classic Upstream Nymphing

Regarding Classic Upstream Nymphing

Classic upstream nymphing feels a lot like fishing dry flies. The challenge of making precision casts is there; it can be employed at extra distance if necessary, and it’s most often performed with tight loops and light flies than don’t change the cast.

While pure tight line nymphing is performed with no line on the water, classic upstream nymphing does the opposite.

Then there’s the induced take and floating the sighter . . .

The Case for Shorter Casts

The Case for Shorter Casts

Find water you can fish close up, and work on deadly accurate casting. You’ll find that, when fishing shorter, you can fish harder. Instead of hoping a trout eats or wishing for a strike, the kind of precision possible at short range lets you make something happen with intention . . .

When Drifting Low Isn’t Low Enough

When Drifting Low Isn’t Low Enough

The next time your beautiful dead drifts are ignored in the strike zone, consider getting dirtier. Sure, you’ll stick some rocks and tree parts down there. You’ll lose more flies and waste more time retrieving snags. But you may quickly find more trout in the net too. Live on the bottom for a while, and see what happens . . .

Six Knots to Know for Trout Anglers on the Fly

Six Knots to Know for Trout Anglers on the Fly

One simple thing can change an angler’s enjoyment and success on the water, maybe more than any other — knot tying skill. But I meet too many otherwise excellent fly anglers who complain about knots or lament the amount of time it takes to make tactical transitions on the river.

You need six knots. Two, really — and then four more to fill in some technical stuff . . .

What do you think?

Be part of the Troutbitten community of ideas.
Be helpful. And be nice.

2 Comments

  1. Hey Domenic, I just finished reading your recent essay (Why do we miss trout on a nymph?) and a question came to mind. Here it is. With all of the underwater studies and videos of Trout eating available today, has anyone timed the true/reliable “expulsion lag.” That is the time a morsel is intercepted and enters the trouts mouth through to the time the trout expels that morsel. I’d love to know what I’m up against.
    BTW. Tell Bill Dell that I like his picture but I usually get upset when my fly gets stuck in a tree. He got his rod ‘n reel stuck. Wow…Some cast!

    Reply
  2. A related incident of an undetected fish rejection.
    A friend and I sometimes bring a spinning rod along with our golf clubs to fish some ponds on the course. I was standing on an elevated slope watching the action of Al’s spinner as he retrieved it in clear water when a bass inhaled the lure and spit it out without Al feeling anything. Did the bass not close its mouth, can a fish reject it that fast without causing a pause in the lure, or ???. Wonder if trout can sense a fly as non-food and reject it before it closes its mouth. Another missed fish. Something to consider.

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Articles

Domenick Swentosky

Central Pennsylvania

Hi. I’m a father of two young boys, a husband, author, fly fishing guide and a musician. I fish for wild brown trout in the cool limestone waters of Central Pennsylvania year round. This is my home, and I love it. Friends. Family. And the river.

Pin It on Pinterest