Trail This — Don’t Trail That

by | Aug 31, 2016 | 7 comments

Last week, my friend sent the picture of a plump, wild brown trout, including the caption, “He took the Green Weenie off the trailer, just like you said!” And I immediately cringed. I never run the Weenie off a trailer — unless it’s very small, beaded and tied with fine chenille instead of medium. Isn’t life complicated?

My friend’s catch demonstrates an important point: everything works sometimes. That’s especially true with nymph rigs.

If you don’t know what a Green Weenie is, by the way, this may not be the post for you. Tune in next time for a story about fishing. This one’s about tactics.

In these posts, I try to dig a little deeper than the “Nymphing 101” kinds of articles that you might find elsewhere. In fact, the small intricacies of rigs and methods that I write about are often the kind of things that will help catch just one or two extra fish in a full day. But I forcefully believe that many of these small adjustments add up to big results. Put them all together, and you’ll catch many more trout in a day.

A while back, I posted about Tags and Trailers. Going back to read that one will really help in processing this one. Please note: I prefer tag droppers in most situations, but I run trailers for a variety of reasons.

A trailer is a nymph that rides along with its parent fly or anchor. It is lighter than the parent fly andis guided along the river bottom by following (trailing) the larger and heavier fly.

I use the term “parent” almost interchangeably with “anchor.” Point is, it’s your main fly. It’s the one you are in touch with, the one you are fishing, the one you can feel, and the one that provides the weight to get down to the bottom. I do use split shot instead of weighted flies sometimes.  I keep the split shot as close as possible (4-6″), and I still consider the parent fly to be the first one after the split shot.

Here it is

Use small, lightly weighted, slim flies as your trailer. Large, bushy or unweighted trailers don’t track as well behind the parent fly, and they are easily tossed around by the currents. That either causes slack between the parent and the trailer, or tension is created, pulling both flies out of their natural drifts. Slack equals poor strike detection. And a nymph drifting unnaturally equals fewer bites. What a large, unweighted, bushy fly does on a trailer isn’t good.

You can easily see this demonstrated in low, clear water. Use a visible parent fly, and then attach an unweighted Green Weenie as a trailer. In mixed currents (as in pocket water) you will see the Green Weenie drifting all over the place. It can end up anywhere within the trailer-line radius of your parent fly. Not good.

Now tie on a visible trailer that is small, slim, and lightly weighted. I know, most are hard to see — try wrapping a cigar shape of chartreuse thread on a #14 hook, just for the test. You will find that the trailer now tracks behind the parent fly much more often. The natural drift of both flies is better, and the strike detection is improved. Is it perfect? Certainly not. Life is a struggle against imperfect things.

My Trailers

Some of my favorite trailers are Pheasant Tails, Walt’s Worms (tied tightly), small cress bugs, RS2’s, Zebra Midges and WD40’s. You’ll notice that none of those patterns fit every requirement of small, slim and lightly weighted. They don’t need to. As long as they are not the opposite of all those descriptors, then you probably have a good trailer. The WD40 is not weighted, but it’s small and slim. The Walt’s Worm is not slim, but I usually add a brass bead to the ones used for trailers. However, I don’t use big stoneflies with appendages or full-hackled Wooly Buggers as trailers.

The Bait-and-Switch

A lot of this started years ago, when my friend, Pat Burke, was nailing fish on what I’ve now started calling the Bait-and-Switch. The idea is to trail a small, natural nymph behind something large, colorful or otherwise attention getting (e.g., trail a Zebra Midge behind an egg pattern, or trail an RS2 behind a stonefly). The Burke rig has become my favorite way of presenting small nymphs, size #18 and under.

Trailing the right flies helps keep both of your nymphs in one lane under the water. And that keeps your flies looking natural down there, improving strike detection.

Of course other ways work. You will catch fish trailing large, bushy, unweighted flies. But I think we should be careful about what we learn from an experience. You may catch a trout trailing the Green Weenie, but what if you could have caught three of them doing it the other way?

Enjoy the day.
Domenick Swentosky
T R O U T B I T T E N
domenick@troutbitten.com

More Troutbitten articles on nymphs:

The Mono Rig and Why Fly Line Sucks
Tight Line Nymph Rig
Sighters: Seven Separate Tools
Learn the Nymph
Tags and Trailers
The Backing Barrel
Take Five
The Add-On Line
One Great Nymphing Trick
The Trouble With Tenkara — And Why You Don’t Need It
It’s a Suspender — Not Just and Indicator
Stop the Split Shot Slide
Trail This — Don’t Trail That
For Tight Line Nymphing and the Mono Rig, What’s a Good Fly Rod?
Depth, Angle, Drop: Three Elements of a Nymphing Rig
Over or Under? Your best bet on weight
Modern Nymphing, the Mono Rig, and Euro Nymphing

Share This Article . . .

Since 2014 and 600 articles deep
Troutbitten is a free resource for all anglers
Your support is greatly appreciated

– Explore These Post Tags –

Domenick Swentosky

Central Pennsylvania

Hi. I’m a father of two young boys, a husband, author, fly fishing guide and a musician. I fish for wild brown trout in the cool limestone waters of Central Pennsylvania year round. This is my home, and I love it. Friends. Family. And the river.

More from this Category

Turnover

Turnover

In short, turnover gives us freedom to choose what happens with the line that’s tethered to the fly. How does the tippet and leader land? With contact or with slack? And where does it land? In the seam and partnered with the fly, or in an adjacent current? By having mastery of turnover, we dictate the positioning of not just the fly, but the leader itself. And nothing could be more important . . .

Regarding Classic Upstream Nymphing

Regarding Classic Upstream Nymphing

Classic upstream nymphing feels a lot like fishing dry flies. The challenge of making precision casts is there; it can be employed at extra distance if necessary, and it’s most often performed with tight loops and light flies than don’t change the cast.

While pure tight line nymphing is performed with no line on the water, classic upstream nymphing does the opposite.

Then there’s the induced take and floating the sighter . . .

The Case for Shorter Casts

The Case for Shorter Casts

Find water you can fish close up, and work on deadly accurate casting. You’ll find that, when fishing shorter, you can fish harder. Instead of hoping a trout eats or wishing for a strike, the kind of precision possible at short range lets you make something happen with intention . . .

When Drifting Low Isn’t Low Enough

When Drifting Low Isn’t Low Enough

The next time your beautiful dead drifts are ignored in the strike zone, consider getting dirtier. Sure, you’ll stick some rocks and tree parts down there. You’ll lose more flies and waste more time retrieving snags. But you may quickly find more trout in the net too. Live on the bottom for a while, and see what happens . . .

Six Knots to Know for Trout Anglers on the Fly

Six Knots to Know for Trout Anglers on the Fly

One simple thing can change an angler’s enjoyment and success on the water, maybe more than any other — knot tying skill. But I meet too many otherwise excellent fly anglers who complain about knots or lament the amount of time it takes to make tactical transitions on the river.

You need six knots. Two, really — and then four more to fill in some technical stuff . . .

What do you think?

Be part of the Troutbitten community of ideas.
Be helpful. And be nice.

7 Comments

  1. I don’t fish a trailer very often because I fish near lots of trees. (Hence the name Windknots & Tangled Lines!) But I know how effective they are. You’ve motivated me to practice more.

    Reply
  2. Dom; Just stumblied on to your site….Wow.
    Have been fly casting for over 50 years, even still have my first Western Auto, glass 9 wt rod. Amazing how a lot of the techniques i’m reading We used in the 60’s and still work today !! Keep it up !

    Reply
    • Thanks, Jeff. Glad you found the blog.

      Yeah, that’s not much new in this world, right?

      Reply
  3. A very belated question: if you want to fish small, unweighted, stuff, say midge larvae, do you prefer trailing it behind a large nymph or egg, or using a drop shot rigging. Both are ways to get a tiny and light fly down, but their drift characteristics differ. Which would you choose and under what conditions?

    Reply
    • Hi Alex.

      I almost always choose to trail tiny nymphs behind something larger or attention-getting. I have used drop shot and tried for the same results with tiny flies, but I don’t get them. I think it has to do with permitting tiny nymphs a lot of motion.

      Cheers.

      Dom

      Reply
      • Thanks, Dom.

        Almost like trailing would be to use a heavy fly on a dropper and a tiny nymph on point. Could you tell me why you would prefer a trailer to that arrangement?

        Reply
        • Hi Alex, if I understand your question correctly, then my answer is this: When I run a tag, I keep the flies at least 16 inches apart and usually more. Anything closer, and they tend to tangle with the tag system. But I like trailing as close as 10 inches. Also trailers tend to track better than if I set it up the way I think you were asking about.

          Take note, I’m certain you could catch fish with your suggested rig. I just have higher confidence in the way I’d rather rig it, and that also takes into account my own casting style and idiosyncrasies.

          As always, thanks for the ideas.

          Cheers.

          Dom

          Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Articles

Domenick Swentosky

Central Pennsylvania

Hi. I’m a father of two young boys, a husband, author, fly fishing guide and a musician. I fish for wild brown trout in the cool limestone waters of Central Pennsylvania year round. This is my home, and I love it. Friends. Family. And the river.

Pin It on Pinterest