Fishing Report — Yarn Wins the Day

by | Dec 9, 2025 | 15 comments

Long ago, the Troutbitten crew had a private forum where we exchanged ideas and stories every day. At the heart of those stories were the fishing reports. We fished hard, and we fished often. Those reports contained the details. Most times, it was nothing but the conditions, the tactics, the flies and an account of our success or failure. But what did we learn? That was always the question. Fishing Reports is now a series at Troutbitten . . .

The Setup

December 7, 2025

(For more info about tactics and decisions, follow the highlighted text links in the paragraphs below.)

In recent weeks, my short trips have been more successful than my longer ones, meaning I’ve had a better catch rate and found more trout. That’s probably because I’ve gotten into a better rhythm and stayed in it. With just an hour or two to spend on the water, I usually limit myself to one or two tactics, so no messing around with full leader changes. I still swap out different flies, but I leave the wholesale shifts for longer days on the water. And I think that commitment has kept me in the game and more focused, which has been especially important in the tough conditions of low, cold, clear water.

The Fishing

I started with streamers, just because I wanted to. Standard Mono Rig, relatively close at 30 feet, targeting bank water and the in-stream structure of rocks and logs. Low water allowed many of the troughs and potholes to stand out, so I treated those as structure as well. After about a hundred yards and a half hour, I gave up on the streamers, with not a single look from a trout.

I swapped the 4X and the Half Pint over to 6x and a pair of fur nymphs. I alternated between a single #4 or #1 split shot about six inches above the point fly. I’ve turned to simple, small, unweighted nymphs frequently this fall and early winter, and it worked again. I immediately caught a trout in the next pothole.

Tightlining the skinny stuff produced more action than deeper slots. I turned just two trout in water of more than two feet deep — not what you might expect in water at 39 degrees Fahrenheit.

The spawn is mostly finished, but there were males to be seen guarding the redds. I still gave them space, because I don’t fish for trout near the redds. But I noted the locations, got a good look at the gravel, and I’ll be careful not to walk through these sections from now through March, when the eggs finally hatch.

Right now, I do believe the trout’s preference for thinner water is connected to the spawning process, at least in this river.

Every trout that I caught or missed ate the lower positioned nymph, so I clipped the top fly, just to simplify things. And I changed my target water focus away from the deeper stuff.

I felt that I needed to stay back a few extra feet in the lower conditions and thinner water, so I floated the sighter in some spots. The drifts were fine, but I wasn’t quite satisfied. Instead, I chose a small yarn indy, mounted on a piece of 4X, just below the sighter. That allowed me to truly suspend the flies. I now had the distance that I wanted, and I had tight line principles taken further than a natural tight line range, with the use of the indy.

But the wind caught the yarn too often . . .

I could have benefited from a regular Standard Mono Rig, The butt section in my hands was #18 lb, rather than 20# lb, and the difference in power was noticeable. But adding a #6 split shot just above the yarn, helped overcome the wind, and I was back to comfortable casting. Adding the shot there is an odd solution, but one that I’ve used for many seasons. It’s a problem solver and for me a better choice than attaching a bobber style indy.

Tb Yarn Indy Hack

The next hour and a half was fun. Trout ate a very small Sucker Spawn and a Walt’s Worm about equally as well, as I switched every 15 minutes or so. That, along with sliding the indy up or down to accommodate for depth, were the only changes I made.

After all these years, I’m still stunned by how many trout cannot be seen in low, clear conditions. Sometimes I even saw the small yellow fly but couldn’t see the trout until the yellow disappeared. Fish on.

With quitting time approaching, I spent the last ten minutes back on a Half Pint. I caught one trout with a Slow Slide.

Good times. It’s getting cold out there.

Stats and Thoughts

Time: 200 mins

Caught: 13

Lost/Missed: 5

Flies Eaten: #16 Sucker Spawn (yellow). #20 UW Sexy Walts, #18 UW Cress Bug, Half Pint (mini version, jig hook 3.5 bead)

Leaders: Standard Mono Rig (18 lb variant)

Terminal Tippets: 6X

Weather: Clouds. 25 degrees and breezy. Pressure 30.01 and stable.

Water: Super low, super clear

Comments

If I had more time, I would have liked to see if the streamer would produce more at the end. The Standard Mono Rig is really perfect for the indy approach, and it’s arguably the best way to gain distance. I had good control over placement of fly then indy, in the same lane, and on the longest casts, the Standard mended easily to keep tension off the indy. I’ve been fishing a Crossover Thin a lot lately, but today I was reminded how helpful the power of the thicker butt section is in so many situations. I only wished for the Crossover again while fishing the streamer. As time goes on, I’m liking a Thin leader for streamer work.

Fish hard, friends.

 

** Donate ** If you enjoy this article, please consider a donation. Your support is what keeps this Troutbitten project funded. Scroll below to find the Donate Button. And thank you.

** Subscribe to Troutbitten and follow along. (It’s  free.) ** 

 

Enjoy the day.
Domenick Swentosky
T R O U T B I T T E N
domenick@troutbitten.com

 

Share This Article . . .

Since 2014 and 1500+ articles deep
Troutbitten is a free resource for all anglers.
Your support is greatly appreciated.

– Explore These Post Tags –

Domenick Swentosky

Central Pennsylvania

Hi. I’m a father of two young boys, a husband, author, fly fishing guide and a musician. I fish for wild brown trout in the cool limestone waters of Central Pennsylvania year round. This is my home, and I love it. Friends. Family. And the river.

More from this Category

(VIDEO) What’s In That Vest? Laying Out the Essentials and More

(VIDEO) What’s In That Vest? Laying Out the Essentials and More

The key to a good carrying system is efficiency. Carry lots of gear or be a minimalist. But however you carry your gear, make sure it works for you. Think it through. And then change something if the system is holding you back, if it’s getting in your way or taking you out of rhythm. A carrying system should be designed around the way you fish, and not the other way around. Think about that. Don’t change the way you fish to suit a poorly chosen pack.

My vest is the most important piece of gear that I own. Because it holds everything that I work with. And having things laid out with a purpose keeps me efficient and ready to adapt. 

(VIDEO) The Fly Rod Dip and Swish — A Useful Trick You Might Have Missed

(VIDEO) The Fly Rod Dip and Swish — A Useful Trick You Might Have Missed

What do you do when the fly line to leader connection comes back through your rod guides? How do you get to fly line back out there? And if you’re using a long leader system or a tight line nymphing system, and the butt section of your leader wraps around your rod tip, how do you get it unwrapped?

The fly rod dip and swish. That’s the answer you do. It’s a really useful tool that solves a lot of problems . . .

A Good Fishing Pace

A Good Fishing Pace

A good fishing pace need not be fast, but it should flow and be efficient. And it might be the most important thing out there.

It comes from intention, from having a plan and following through. Surely, adjusting our plan along the way is part of the fun, but pace remains an element that every angler can set, every day . . .

Fifteen Knot Tying Tips (with VIDEO)

Fifteen Knot Tying Tips (with VIDEO)

Being a versatile angler comes down to changing things. And on the river, that means tying knots. Good anglers need the facility to tie knots, with ease. This is my best advice for tying quick, clean, strong knots.

The Good Wader

The Good Wader

The good wader keeps moving, believes in traction, casts in rhythm and makes no excuses. The good wader becomes the good angler . . .

The Easy Way to Release a Snag (with VIDEO)

The Easy Way to Release a Snag (with VIDEO)

Snags happen. I’ve fished with people who see every hang up as a failure — every lost fly as a mistake. But inevitably, that mindset breeds an overcautious angler, too careful and just hoping for some good luck.

Hang ups are not a failure. For a good angler, they’re a calculated risk — an occasional consequence after assessing probability against skill, opportunity against loss. We all hang up the fly sometimes. So what.

Now let’s talk about how to pop that underwater snag loose . . .

What do you think?

Be part of the Troutbitten community of ideas.
Be helpful. And be nice.

15 Comments

  1. Dom,

    Of all your great advice I’ve implemented over the years the split shot at the Dorsey helped me the most. On some tailwaters I fish the type of indicator makes a huge difference and the wind would shut me down. I first read your split shot at Indy tip a few years ago and immediately had a solution to what I thought was an unsolvable problem that negatively impacted my catch rate. It’s good to see it reiterated here.
    Scott Miller

    Reply
  2. You parked those flies out there! I enjoyed reading this.

    Reply
    • Hey Dom, love this outing report! I can picture the changes in tactics. Whoa, you miss fish too? That’s fishing. I’ll have to try the weight with the yarn next time it’s breezy.

      Reply
      • Oh, buddy. Everyone misses trout. I think plenty of trout refuse a nymph at the last moment, just like we see them reject a streamer or dry. So they might bump the nymph, but never eat it. In that case, we never had a chance to hook the fish. We tend to think of misses as our fault, but I don’t think that’s always the case.

        Cheers.
        Dom

        Reply
  3. Love this new feature, Dom. What a treasure trove of info and resources you continue to compile. Thanks for everything you do!

    Reply
  4. Great article! Thank you for the write up. Would you mind answering what you used to take the pictures in this article?

    Thanks,

    John

    Reply
    • Sony a6700. My camera gear choices are always centered around portability. I’m fishing, first. Filming second. Cheers.

      Reply
  5. Good stuff Dom,

    I liked all the details in here: (i.e.) seeing how much time/distance you dedicated to a streamer before switching, clipping off the top nymph, what streamer retrieve worked etc….These are the details that make us all love Troutbitten. Thanks for all the content!

    Reply
  6. Good stuff, I like it.

    Fishing streams a few hours from you this is good interesting information and can use it.

    Tom

    Reply
  7. Hello Dom great article very enjoyable.

    MayI ask a quick question about using / modifying the standard mono rig. On one of my favourite rivers leader length is limited by regulation to max length of 19ft6” including tippet.

    To maintain power in the leader and accommodate the length limit rule how would you suggest modifying the standard rig

    All the best for the “holidays”

    Reply
  8. Please give us one of these reports for a nights shift.

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Articles

Recent Posts

Pin It on Pinterest