Roll Your Eggs — Tips For Nymphing With Egg Patterns

by | Nov 30, 2022 | 12 comments

There is no other fly in my box that requires such a singular presentation to sell it to a trout. They want the drift of an egg just right. Dead drifts that are deader than dead, I like to say, because eggs don’t swim — they hug the bottom and bumble along, sliding and rolling over the riverbed, either touching rocks or coasting through the lowest depths of the strike zone — the last inch of cushion above the rocks. Find that skinny layer, and you’ll fool trout on an egg.

That’s what works — deader than dead, rolling your egg. And if you nail it, you then have the skills to drift any nymph the same way, all year long. That low roll is a great look for a nymph. It’s a good baseline from which to deviate. And on the egg it’s a necessity. Sure, you’ll catch the outlier during a good bite, when trout move a little further and expand their horizons. I’ve even had days when trout were eating eggs on the drop. But these are rare times — and those fish are an unexpected reward for putting in your time and learning to roll your eggs.

A couple years ago, I published an article with many tips for fishing egg patterns in the winter months. You can find that here . . .

READ: Troutbitten | Fly Fishing in the Winter — Egg Tips

In that text, I touched on the necessity for a very particular presentation. Now, here’s a more thorough breakdown of just the right look to fool trout on one of the simplest and best flies around.

What’s the Roll?

Imagine what an egg looks like down there. If you’re lucky, you’ve seen this a few times.

I’ve watched the eggs of a sucker drop from a spawning hen and then drift downstream about ten feet before I lost sight of the small clusters. I’ve witnessed this at least a half dozen times, and I’m always struck by the same thing — eggs drift s-l-o-w-l-y. They roll over the rocks with a neutral buoyancy of sorts, ready to rest and settle on the rocks, but easily transported by whatever currents pick them up.

Trout have seen this a hell of a lot more than I have, and trout know what they’re looking for. An egg isn’t going anywhere. It’s either traveling with that bottom-most current or it’s dropping to the next rock.

Deader than dead, right? Any movement to a dead drifted egg fly looks wholly unnatural, and it will be rejected by all trout with a measure of self respect. Our drifts on an egg need to match what the trout sees. Remember, there’s just one presentation of an egg, because it does only one thing — it rolls slowly and hugs the bottom.

Photo by Bill Dell

How to Roll

So does this mean we should scrape and crawl an egg pattern along the riverbed? Not at all. But I will say, you’ll get more takes with that kind of presentation than you will with an egg drifting twenty inches off the bottom.

For me, the target zone for an egg is extremely narrow. It’s that last few inches of water before the riverbed, and it’s the rocks themselves. Because that’s where the real eggs are, and that’s what trout expect.

For nymphing with egg flies, I prefer a tight line presentation over an indicator setup. I do fish eggs with a tight line to the indicator rig a fair amount, but I much prefer the full-drift control of a pure tight line. Once I find the riverbed, I can paint the bottom with the fly — or more to the point, paint that last inch of water that glides over the rocks.

This is a hard task, because the riverbed is imperfect. Most trout rivers are full of rocks that get in your way. Just when you establish a beautiful bottom roll, here comes the next unseen chunk of bedrock to break it up. That’s alright. Deal with it. Do everything you can to see through the water and read the rocks below. Learn what surface swirls and slicks signal about unseen structure. Choose fishing angles that allow you to see into the water. Always wear polarized lenses, even on darker days, because every bit of glare that is blocked helps us read where and how to drift our nymphs.

Find the bottom and keep the egg traveling downstream. That’s the game. I talk a lot about reading the speed of the sighter (or the indy) to find the strike zone, but just being somewhere in the strike zone isn’t good enough with an egg. Most often, it has to be lower.

Because my target zone is so low with an egg, I touch the bottom more than with any other style of nymph. But that becomes a problem itself, because too much bottom contact comes with a host of issues. Aside from sticking a hook in the next rock or running into watery wood down low, the materials that we use for building egg flies gather salad. For both of these reasons, I choose unweighted eggs and fish them with split shot or drop shot. In truth, I’m a firm believer that the presentation of the egg improves dramatically by keeping weight out of the egg and using shot to get the fly down. Keeping the split shot about five inches up allows the egg a little freedom for the currents to make the decisions instead of the angler. And by putting ourselves slightly out of touch with the egg, more hits come. It also keeps the fly from hanging on the bottom or gathering greenery as often.

READ: Troutbitten | Fly Fishing in the Winter — The Go-To Nymph Rig

Split shot five inches above the nymph is still my favorite way to roll the bottom with eggs. But in the last few years, I’ve turned to drop shot when I want the slowest rides and the most bottom contact. With the drop shot touching and rolling the bottom, I can suspend the egg in that bottom two inches of the strike zone, right where I want it.

READ: Troutbitten | Drop Shot Nymphing on a Tight Line Rig

This kind of ride on a drop shot takes exceptional focus. The shot should never (or very rarely) rest. It should not pause and go but just tick and slide down one seam. Great drop shot technique takes time to master. Do not become complacent — never be satisfied just because you got the drop shot down. Anyone can do that. Be stubborn about simulating that natural egg roll, and your discipline will pay off.

VIDEO: Seven Ways to Get your Fly Deeper

Photo by Josh Darling

Fear No Snag

Eggs are a quick tie at the vise and a cheap buy in the fly shop. So go lose a few.

Playing it safe will have you cautiously trying to keep your egg pattern from sticking and hanging up. And you might get really good at bringing that little morsel through the strike zone, without touching and snagging up at all. But you won’t catch trout.

So if you get to the upper end of a good run, if you look back to what should have been a productive section and you’re wondering why you couldn’t catch a trout, ask yourself how many times you snagged up. It probably wasn’t enough.

Successfully fishing egg flies requires full commitment to rolling your eggs.

Fish hard, friends.

 

** Donate ** If you enjoy this article, please consider a donation. Your support is what keeps this Troutbitten project funded. Scroll below to find the Donate Button. And thank you.

 

Enjoy the day.
Domenick Swentosky
T R O U T B I T T E N
domenick@troutbitten.com

 

Share This Article . . .

Since 2014 and 900+ articles deep
Troutbitten is a free resource for all anglers.
Your support is greatly appreciated.

– Explore These Post Tags –

Domenick Swentosky

Central Pennsylvania

Hi. I’m a father of two young boys, a husband, author, fly fishing guide and a musician. I fish for wild brown trout in the cool limestone waters of Central Pennsylvania year round. This is my home, and I love it. Friends. Family. And the river.

More from this Category

When Gear Gets In the Way

When Gear Gets In the Way

No matter what we’re into, there’s a time when the learning of skills reaches a critical mass, when it’s time to do rather than read more about it and buy more gear.
. . .There’s a time for learning. There’s time for preparation. And then there’s time for doing — for putting all of it into practice, making the casts, covering water and catching fish . . .

Five Keys to Reading the Sighter (with VIDEO)

Five Keys to Reading the Sighter (with VIDEO)

Control. Options. Precision. These are the most attractive aspects of fishing a tight line system, and the sighter is the key to it all.

A sighter is more than a strike indicator. It also shows depth, angle, speed and contact. It points to our flies and takes away the guesswork. For an angler who learns to read all of this on the sighter, that colored line above the water provides a most significant advantage to the underwater game . . .

Getting Closer

Getting Closer

When I start wondering why the fishing seems slow, I first check my distance. Have I started creeping the cast too far beyond that perfect baseline? If so, I reel in a couple turns. I wade closer, staying behind the trout and being cautious with my approach.

Hook Sets Are Not Free

Hook Sets Are Not Free

Mike had landed on a common phrase that usually triggers a response from me. It’s one of the myths of fly fishing, and it carries too much consequence to let it go. Hook sets are not free. There’s a price to pay. Oftentimes that cost is built into our success. And other times, the costs of too frequently setting the hook pile up, stealing away our limited opportunities . . .

What do you think?

Be part of the Troutbitten community of ideas.
Be helpful. And be nice.

12 Comments

  1. I love the drop shot and have used it with some success trouting and carping. Problem is it appears to be illegal in CA. My last reading of the regs seems to confirm this but I understand enforcement is rare. I have had fish and game examine my rigs, I assumed looking for barbed hooks but who knows. Just saying

    Reply
    • Right on. I addressed the legality of all that in the Drop Shot article linked above.

      I think it sucks when states implement overarching laws that should have nothing to do with you

      Dom

      Reply
  2. Dom
    If you did pair an egg with another fly what would you choose?

    Reply
  3. Hello Dom. I was on a stream in your local area yesterday and I was nymphing with an egg pattern. With the creek being low and clear, it was very easy to see my orange Nuke egg. I was switching between tight lining and using an indicator (thingamabobber) It was obvious when I had a good drift going and even more obvious when it was not. I could see when the egg was blowing through a slot way too fast. I did my best to slow it down, with adding weight, and it paid off pretty good. This was the first time that I was really happy to have clear water. It helped me see what was really going on with my egg, and I could understand how much I could slow it down, or speed it up if needed. This article was perfect timing. I could easily connect it with what I just experienced. Thank you for all the great info that you give us. Even though I have learned a lot from Troutbitten, I am looking forward to learning a heck of a lot more. Even though I only get to Central PA about 10 times a year, one of my favorite times is winter. Very few people on the creek along with hungry fish, equals a great experience. The solitude is worth the 3 1/2 hour drive. I am already planning my next trip down there. It will be awesome, no matter the results! Thank you for all you do.

    Reply
  4. I really like fishing egg patterns in the winter and have learned a lot from you.When you dropshot am I to understand that your weight is only 2 inches from your fly?Thanks for all the great info.Pete

    Reply
  5. Incredible tactical lesson, the kind that is very hard to find anywhere. Exactly the kind of info I crave. Great job!

    Reply
  6. I’ve always been reluctant when it came to fishing egg patterns, primarily because of not being very successful with them. That is, until now. After reading about how to properly set up my rig, and how to apply it, I headed to my favorite river, and was very successful with this technique. Thank you Dom, for all of the great information you’ve shared not just in this article, but all throughout the Troutbitten site, and pod casts.

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Articles

Recent Posts

Domenick Swentosky

Central Pennsylvania

Hi. I’m a father of two young boys, a husband, author, fly fishing guide and a musician. I fish for wild brown trout in the cool limestone waters of Central Pennsylvania year round. This is my home, and I love it. Friends. Family. And the river.

Pin It on Pinterest