Why Everyone Fishes the Same Water — And What to Do About It

by | May 11, 2021 | 10 comments

There are a few extra anglers on the water these days. It’s a Covid thing. And crowded streams have become a popular subject at the bars, in online discussions and in the fly shops. More fishermen is something that most established anglers disdain. It’s a funny thing, because we all know how much enjoyment being on the river brings to our lives, and we truly want that for others. We just don’t want more people throwing a line in our favorite spots out there.

However, even with extra angler pressure, it’s as easy as ever to predict what places will be crowded and to avoid them. Because, for the most part, everyone fishes the same water. But why?

Much of what makes fishing special is the solitude. Right?

Not necessarily. Many fly fishers enjoy seeing and being seen. It’s human nature, I guess, to strut a bit. Decked out with shiny new gear, there’s a measure of pride taken in being an angler, and I think that’s alright. Eventually, the worn-in creases in a pair of waders, the ratty boot laces and the faded vest becomes its own badge of honor, but it takes some time to understand all of that.

READ: Troutbitten |Angler Types in Profile — The Gear Guy

Keep in mind that different types of people take up a fly rod, and while I think there are more introverts that stick with the game — more of us who are looking to get away from everything — there seems to be just as many of the see-and-be-seen types out there, the ones that are more interested in holding a conversation than casting a line, in telling stories than improving tactics. This is part of it. It’s fishing. It’s people. And that’s alright.

There’s a lot more recreation happening on and around our waters too — more kayakers, dog walkers, bikers, runners. You get the point. Perhaps the best thing about Covid is that people are remembering what they liked about being outside. Personally, fresh air and walking around in trout streams makes me a nicer person. So just imagine how happy the world would be if everyone was out there fishing . . .

Hold on. Let’s not do that.

If you keep your ear to the ground, then by now you’re probably a little weary of all the complaining over angler pressure. Maybe you’ve been doing some of the complaining too — I’m guilty of it myself. But if solitude and a little casting room really matters to you, then finding your own water starts by understanding the habits of anglers — especially the beginners.

New anglers tend to fish the same places. Hell, seasoned anglers fish the same places too. In fact, I think about ninety percent of the anglers fish the same ten percent of the water. That’s a fair estimate. Because I guide and live around some of the greatest wild trout waters in the world, I see it every day. I can almost guarantee where I will find other anglers and where I will not. Within a favorite three-mile stretch of water, if there are fifteen cars on a Wednesday evening in May, eight of them will be in the same gravel lot.

Why?

There are a few reasons. And they all make sense, if you think about it. So if you’re to the point where you really do want to get away from other anglers, it helps to first understand where most of them go.

Why does everyone fish the same waters?

READ: Troutbitten | How to Stay in the Fly Fishing Game for a Lifetime

Big Names

Popular rivers have access points with catchy names. Everyone has a story about fishing Three Dollar Bridge, Rainbow Riffle or Tunnel Road. These places are easy to remember and easy to communicate.

There are legendary places in our fly fishing world, and most of us want to fish them.

FOMO (Fear of Missing Out)

When everything you read about a river mentions these big name access points, when every video features these locations, the draw to repeat what you’ve seen and heard is too much. You simply have to fish these places a few times, because you don’t want to miss out on the good stuff.

Even if epic fish catching doesn’t happen like it did in the video, at least now you’ve fished there. Right?

Fly anglers are no different than tourists this way. If I ever go to Paris, then yes, I’d like to see the Eiffel Tower and visit the Louvre. And when Dad and I first went to Montana, we fished the Madison and the Gallatin. We started at the big names, and we hit the popular access points.

River

Take the right dog fishing, and they’ll encourage you to find water that’s off the beaten path.

The Sure Thing

The nine cars in a gravel lot that can hold ten looks mighty inviting to many anglers. All those fishermen can’t be wrong, you’d think. So the new or traveling angler pulls in and fills the last spot.

We’re all looking for clues about where the fishing will be best. And a bunch of fishermen is like a shining beacon of a sure thing for some folks.

Make it Easy, Please

Add in a picnic table, a porta potty and some signage, and you have the best of the good spots. The draw of easy access, with one turn of the steering wheel into a parking lot next to a manicured lawn and trimmed trees is too much for some fishermen to pass up.

It’s a hell of a lot easier than a muddy pull off on the side of a dirt road, where donning your waders happens at slanted angles among something you’re pretty sure is poison ivy.

Easy access draws crowds.

Public | Private

So many states in the union have confusing stream access laws that travelers are rightfully hesitant about where it might be legal to fish. So accessing the rivers and the places written about in guidebooks is a safe bet. No one wants a pissed-off landowner spoiling their day.

This Must Be the Place

Ain’t no place around that looks like this place, so this must be the place. — My Grandfather

Add it all up: the catchy name, easy access and a legendary reputation, and you have the ultimate draw. So for anyone new to the area or new to the game, this is where they begin. When Dad and I pulled into the lot at Three Dollar Bridge, we knew where we were, and we expected to see a few other cars — we did. All of that was reassuring.

Then, later that day, we did something different, we explored the no-name stream behind our campsite. But we also had our story about fishing Three Dollar Bridge.

Put some miles on your boots.

Find Your Water

Occasionally, I run into someone who’s mad about so many other guys fishing their favorite spot in the river. I also see experienced anglers chastising beginners for not exploring and looking beyond the big names and popular access points.

But it’s easy to forget that we were all new once. My first trips to the waters that I now live around and guide were to the popular access points. It’s where the fly shop jockey sent me. It’s where the guidebook sent me. And these were great starting points. As a new angler, I didn’t have the confidence to be an explorer, especially in unfamiliar terrain.

READ: Troutbitten | Explore — Learn — Return

What’s the upside to all of this? The habits of anglers are predictable.

Yes, the big names might be crowded this spring. So what. If you’ve been around long enough and have confidence in your skills, then move on to new waters. Accept the challenge of exploring a bit. Find access outside of the special regs areas. Walk further away from the lot, duck through the brush and forge your own trail. Fish an untouched small stream or choose a piece of water that no one talks about.

For every big name piece of water that’s overcrowded, there are hundreds of miles of trout water that are rarely seen by any angler. If ten percent of the water sees ninety percent of the fishermen, then be that small percentage angler who finds wide open places in a high percentage of water.

Fish hard, friends.

 

** Donate ** If you enjoy this article, please consider a donation. Your support is what keeps this Troutbitten project funded. Scroll below to find the Donate Button. And thank you.

 

Enjoy the day.
Domenick Swentosky
T R O U T B I T T E N
domenick@troutbitten.com

 

Share This Article . . .

Since 2014 and 600 articles deep
Troutbitten is a free resource for all anglers
Your support is greatly appreciated

– Explore These Post Tags –

Domenick Swentosky

Central Pennsylvania

Hi. I’m a father of two young boys, a husband, author, fly fishing guide and a musician. I fish for wild brown trout in the cool limestone waters of Central Pennsylvania year round. This is my home, and I love it. Friends. Family. And the river.

More from this Category

They Don’t Have to Eat It to Learn to Reject It

They Don’t Have to Eat It to Learn to Reject It

You’ve probably heard this a lot: “These trout have been caught on that fly before, so they won’t take it.”

Or this: “Once trout are caught on a fly a few times, they learn that it’s a fake.

But trout don’t have to be caught on a fly to learn that it isn’t real. In fact, just seeing one bad drift after another is enough to put trout off of a particular pattern . . .

Never Blame the Fish

Never Blame the Fish

When everything you expect to work produces nothing, don’t blame the fish. Think more. Try harder.

When your good drifts still leave the net empty, then don’t settle for good. Make things perfect. Never blame the fish . . .

Super Fly — The Story of a Squirmy Wormy

Super Fly — The Story of a Squirmy Wormy

Occasionally (rarely) something comes along that makes trout go a little crazy. Why? Who the hell knows. But it trips some trigger in trout that makes them move further and eat more than they do for just about anything else. In my life there’ve been only four of these super flies.

In dark bars and seedy internet gatherings, I keep my ear to the ground for rumors of the next super fly. Because those who find one can’t keep a secret for long. And I want to be in on the next fly from the ground up again. I want long months of virgin trout that lust for something original yet familiar, the right mix of bold but non-threatening, curiously edible and irresistible. I want to fish another super fly . . .

How the Bobber Hurts a Fly Fisher

How the Bobber Hurts a Fly Fisher

Don’t be a bobber lobber. Bobbers are an amazing tool in certain situations. But learn to cast it with turnover first. Avoid the lob.

Instead of using the bobber as a shortcut to getting the line out there, first learn a good casting stroke — with speed, crisp stops and turnover. Then, attach the bobber and see the supreme advantage gained when the fly hits first and the bobber comes in downstream, with the fly and indy both in the same current seam. Oh, hello dead drift. Nice to see you . . .

Fly vs Bait

Fly vs Bait

I know this is a minority opinion. The average angler assumes that bait will fool more trout than an artificial. Just yesterday, I came across the frequently repeated assertion that bait outperforms flies. I saw it in print and heard it in dialogue on a podcast. It was stated as fact, as though no one could possibly argue otherwise. But it’s wrong. It’s a common wisdom that isn’t very wise. And I think those who believe that bait has the edge over flies have probably spent very little threading live bait on a hook and dunking it in a river . . .

Natural vs Attractive Presentations

Natural vs Attractive Presentations

. . . Let’s call it natural if the fly is doing something the trout are used to seeing. If the fly looks like what a trout watches day after day and hour after hour — if the fly is doing something expected — that’s a natural presentation.

By contrast, let’s call it attractive if the fly deviates from the expected norm. Like any other animal in the wild, trout know their environment. They understand what the aquatic insects and the baitfish around them are capable of. They know the habits of mayflies and midges, of caddis, stones, black nosed dace and sculpins. And just as an eagle realizes that a woodland rabbit will never fly, a trout knows that a sculpin cannot hover near the top of the water column with its nose into heavy current . . .

What do you think?

Be part of the Troutbitten community of ideas.
Be helpful. And be nice.

10 Comments

  1. Man oh man Dom, great read. I’m guilty as charged. I will say that I’ve pushed myself to at least 10 new streams in the last year. When I say new, I mean “new to me.” I’m finding that I’m looking at a map more, and trying to find new tribs and blue lines. As far as shiny gear, well my waders are currently standing on their own, thanks to aqua seal. And my boots are barley recognizable as boots at this point. And yes I do wear them as a badge of honor. They didn’t get that way from being stuffed in a basement storage room. I’m fishing more now than I ever have. I own a WV, PA, MD, and NC license at the moment, and have fished them all in 2021. Again, great read

    Reply
  2. The extra pressure in those popular pools and runs pushes fish into less pressured water.
    So getting away from the crowds can also get you into those fish that are there for the same reason that you are. Ha!

    Reply
  3. Getting away from the crowds requires 2 things, time and confidence. Now that I have less time but more confidence, I’m learning that even the most popular rivers can be fished in solitude by being willing to hike or fish the heavy water 95% of anglers can’t or won’t. Just came back from a full weekend on a “name” central pa stream with perfect weather, water and hatch conditions and saw only a handful of anglers all weekend. It’s a big world out there, no sense in complaining about other people enjoying it too! Just go where they aren’t.

    Reply
  4. North Carolina stocked streams have become totally over run so a couple years ago our TU chapter had a presentation on wild mountain streams. Sounded great and I gave it a try, but I found at 75 I’ve become too old for rock hopping on the small wild mountain streams. I’ve given up and have taken my fly rod to the lakes for bluegill. Sad to see what has happened to trout fishing here.

    Reply
  5. Celebrating my first brown trout of the year.
    Love your dog.

    Reply
  6. Once you get decent, you learn to explore a bit. I personally like the solitude and quiet of nature. Rather hear a bird sing sometimes. This means figuring out where to go to get away.

    If you can get out mid-week, you have more options. If you can only get out on the weekends, you have to look a little harder and maybe explore further out.

    There is an upside. Good to have more folks caring about water quality. Maybe get more folks to pitch in a few bucks to Trout Unlimited to keep the water for the next generation.

    Personally, I am starting to plot where to ride my bike in to get to water most don’t think about. There are a few places left out there for sure.

    Also, little brook trout in the mountains are another topic altogether

    Reply
  7. Great post Dom. Timely. I spent most of last year forcing myself to fish new water on the Farmington. Driving the 21 miles of TMA sometimes for hours waiting for spots to clear. Doing this made me a much better angler and I enjoyed the solitude. Night fishing has and will be a mainstay for me now. Even the most popular spots are completely void of anglers at night. Granted my results in the dark have been lack luster but the peace and quiet are worth it. The thundering herd is always around us in many aspects of life. The good news is it’s easy to identify their patterns and then fish against them.

    Reply
    • I’m a creature of habit and remember the fish I’ve caught in those select pools. This is encouragement to branch out to other spots and make new memories

      Reply
  8. This issue reminds me of all the bitching about traffic. When we pull out onto the road, all those other cars are the problem, but not us.

    Funny creatures, humans.

    Reply
  9. While the famous central Pennsylvania streams seem to be invaded by newbies, I keep hacking at Little Valley Creek and Valley Creek. Or more appropriately, I am being educated by these streams. They’re 13 miles from Philadelphia and class A trout streams holding wild browns to at least 28 inches in abundance. I would feel like I was blowing the biggest secret about Pennsylvania trout if it weren’t a wide open secret already.
    Dom, my only wish would be to watch you angle these educated, wary fish in their usual low, clear water.
    Russell Levin

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Articles

Recent Posts

Domenick Swentosky

Central Pennsylvania

Hi. I’m a father of two young boys, a husband, author, fly fishing guide and a musician. I fish for wild brown trout in the cool limestone waters of Central Pennsylvania year round. This is my home, and I love it. Friends. Family. And the river.

Pin It on Pinterest