Lost Trout Are Your Fault — Streamer Fishing Myth v Truth

by | Nov 5, 2020 | 8 comments

There’s a difference between missing a trout and losing a trout. As I wrote in the previous installment of this Troutbitten short series, missing trout on streamers is usually the fish’s fault. I believe trout reject our flies on purpose. They’re curious enough to take a look, but they decide not to eat our fake at the last instant. (There are other reasons for misses too. See the article for more.) We set the hook, feel no contact with the fish and believe we missed our chance. But usually, there’s not much we can do about these refusals, other than try and make the next presentation even more convincing.

However, losing a trout is different. When you hook a fish, have it on for a few moments and then it comes off, that’s a lost fish. And more often than not, I believe the blame lies with the angler.

— — — — — —

Late last week, I geared up underneath my 4Runner’s hatch. Kneeling in shallow puddles, I laced my wading boots before I stood tall, zipped my raincoat and stepped out from the shelter of the hatch. With pure joy I looked up to the sky and watched big raindrops fall through yellow maple leaves. Some of them hit my face, and I just stood there, grinning to the heavens like Tim Robbins in Shawshank Redemption.


Yeah, that’s a little dramatic. But finally, after no significant rain for three months, we had enough of the wet stuff to bump the rivers. It was the perfect time for streamers, and I had two hours before the fading daylight would force my surrender.

The streamer bite did not disappoint. And in the first half hour, I had a handful of trout to the net. I also had about ten misses and something a little more frustrating — I’d lost a few fish. And one of them, in the high teens, I would have liked to have seen closer.

So when another good trout slipped the hook, I paused to regroup. No sense getting angry, after all. And I’d learned through the years that most issues can be solved with a little observation, some insight and a willingness to adjust.

Thinking back, every trout I’d lost was on top. These trout spit the hook when they were above the water or they were splashing on the surface. All of them were hooked for at least a couple seconds but remained buttoned for no more than five. Why? I’d horsed them in. And if I could just settle down a bit — if I could stay calm and allow these trout to get back underneath, I would be able to hold onto them.

— — — — — —

Problem | Solution

We all do it. Streamer fishing is fun. And a good streamer bite comes with a shot of adrenaline, especially when the strips are fast and aggressive. As we see a wild trout attack the fly, our natural reaction is one of excitement. We set the hook, and all too often we continue the fast and aggressive motions of our retrieve. The trout never has a chance to get back down through the water column, and we mistakenly fight the fish fast and near the surface. Unfortunately, that’s the worst place for a trout, if you want it to stay attached.

Trout are best fought in the lower two thirds of the water column. The riverbed is a bad place to fight a trout, and so is the surface. And I notice that these two places are where most losses occur.

In the rain the other evening, my excitement got the best of me, until I realized my mistake and finally corrected it. I settled down and changed my approach. Once the trout was hooked, I maintained tension but stopped myself from pulling the fish too high in the column. Instead, I set the hook and allowed things to calm down for a moment.

It made all the difference. And I lost just one trout the rest of the night.

This Too

There are a couple more points to be made here.

When fishing streamers, we fish stronger tippet than when we’re fishing other fly types. The leader is thicker. It flexes and stretches less. So pulling against the trout with our rod tip is amplified.

I first noticed this when night fishing for trout. It took me a full season to realize why I was losing so many fish. Answer: I was using twelve pound Maxima Chameleon as terminal tackle and a heavier rod. With much less flex in the system, my standard fish-fighting techniques were overkill, resulting in too much influence and unwelcome pressure on the trout.

READ: Troutbitten | Night Fishing for Trout — You’re Gonna Need a Bigger Rope

This isn’t to suggest that a fight with any trout should be a long one. Not at all. I’m referring here to only the first few seconds after a fish is hooked. Let him swim back to the lower two-thirds of the water column. Avoid the barrel roll near the top. Let things calm down for a second, get your side pressure, and then fight him hard.

READ MORE: Troutbitten | Category | Fighting Fish

One More Thing

It’s the average-sized trout that seem to come unbuttoned more than the large ones. Anything in the upper teens and beyond has a big enough mouth that the larger hook of a streamer finds a solid home. I still try not to horse these fish in for the first few seconds, but most times, the extra weight of such a trout dampens whatever unnecessary pressure I apply.

Photo by Bill Dell

Tame Yourself

Streamer fishing is a fun changeup from everything else we do on a fly rod. It’s not delicate. It’s not slow and methodical. It’s often about pulling large flies across currents rather than dead drifting small flies in one seam. It’s enjoyable. But our extra enthusiasm can cause too many lost fish until we realize our mistake. And that’s something I’m forced to remind myself time after time.

Fish hard, friends.

READ: Troutbitten | Streamer Fishing Myth v Truth — Eats and Misses

READ: Troutbitten | The Meat Eater Minority | Streamer Fishing Myth v Truth

READ MORE : Troutbitten | Category | Streamers


Enjoy the day.
Domenick Swentosky


Share This Article . . .

Since 2014 and 700+ articles deep
Troutbitten is a free resource for all anglers.
Your support is greatly appreciated.

– Explore These Post Tags –

Domenick Swentosky

Central Pennsylvania

Hi. I’m a father of two young boys, a husband, author, fly fishing guide and a musician. I fish for wild brown trout in the cool limestone waters of Central Pennsylvania year round. This is my home, and I love it. Friends. Family. And the river.

More from this Category

Podcast — Ep. 5: Fly Fishing the Mono Rig — Versatility and the Tight Line Advantage Taken Further

Podcast — Ep. 5: Fly Fishing the Mono Rig — Versatility and the Tight Line Advantage Taken Further

After hundreds of Troutbitten articles featuring the versatility of the Mono Rig, now there’s a podcast. My friends Josh, Austin, Trevor and Bill join me to discuss how each of us fishes this hybrid rig as a complete fly fishing system, detailing the ultimate flexibility of this amazing tool.

The Troutbitten Mono Rig is a hybrid system for fishing all types of flies: nymphs (both tight line and indicator styles), streamers, dry-dropper, wets, and small dry flies. With twenty pound monofilament as a fly line substitute, better contact, control and strike detection are gained with the Mono Rig versus a traditional fly line approach. And yet, the casting here is still a fly line style cast. Ironically, it takes excellent fly casting skills to efficiently throw a Mono Rig.

Finding the (Almost) Invisible Potholes — Reading Water

Finding the (Almost) Invisible Potholes — Reading Water

Just as the taller rock creates a surface wave, the pothole, bucket or depression in the riverbed has a corresponding feature on the surface. It’s a flatter, calmer piece of water — smoother than the surrounding surface currents. Is it harder to recognize? Sure it is. It’s also not as reliable of a sign. But quite often, if you find a calm piece of water, surrounded by mixed currents and minor waves, a pothole lies below.

Be careful what you’re reading, though. The stall, or slower piece of water that lies just downstream of every rock, is not the same thing as a pothole — not at all . . .

#8. The Strike: Nine Essential Skills for Tight Line and Euro Nymphing

#8. The Strike: Nine Essential Skills for Tight Line and Euro Nymphing

The strike is the best part of fishing. It’s what we’re all out there waiting for, or rather, what we’re trying to make happen all day long. And the trout eats because we get so many things right.

We fool a fish, and we fulfill the wish of every angler.

When the fish strikes, we strike back. Short, swift and effective, the hook finds fish flesh. Then we try to keep the trout buttoned and get it to the net.

In the next article, this series concludes with the focus on putting it all together . . .

The Backing Barrel Might Be The Best Sighter Ever

The Backing Barrel Might Be The Best Sighter Ever

A simple piece of Dacron, tied in a barrel, is a visible and sensitive addition to your tight line and euro nymphing rig. The versatile Backing Barrel serves as a stand-alone sighter, especially when tied with a one-inch tag. Better yet, it draws your eyes to the colored monofilament of any sighter and enhances visibility threefold. The Backing Barrel adds a third dimension of strike detection, with the Dacron flag just stiff enough to stand away from the line, but just soft enough to twitch upon even the most subtle takes . . .

Podcast — Ep. 3: Night Fishing, and the Mouse Emerger Concept

Podcast — Ep. 3: Night Fishing, and the Mouse Emerger Concept

My night fishing friends, Josh and Trevor join me for a fun and detailed discussion about mouse emergers. This style is about taking the benefits of a top water pattern at night and making it a little harder for the trout to resist. Then, sometimes, we fish similar patterns that remain in the first 3-12 inches of the water column. My friends and I also trade night fishing stories about the scariest and most unusual things that happen while fly fishing after dark.

What do you think?

Be part of the Troutbitten community of ideas.
Be helpful. And be nice.


  1. Great points made and read Dom! Who doesn’t get that rush tossing streamers when a fish smacks it?!! Enjoyed the ‘Andy’ reference and pic too. Tight lines brother

    • Thanks Dom,
      I was hoping you were going to tell me it was not my fault.

  2. I too was trying to analyze why more bugger and streamer caught fish seemed to come undone,and agree,usually in first 10 or 20 seconds. One theory I came up with is whether or not a lot of these fish might of been lightly foul hooked,and first hard pressure caused fly to pull loose. For some reason I’ve foul hooked a ridiculous amount of fish over the years,regardless of Euro,indicator,dead drifting buggers or even swinging flys. And while have gone days with neither foul hooked or losses,some days it’s an epidemic.

  3. Dom,
    Spot on! You explained it! I lost several this weekend in the exact surface conditions you were talking about…I blamed it on the fish, then I blamed it on the hooks (my fingers were raw from sharpening them on the stream…) Sounds like I just gotta get control of the ‘buck fever’ and let ’em come to the net with less coaxing. Keep up the blogs; they’re awesome! (looks like your little Border Collie is becoming quite the fish hound) -TIM

  4. Funny that when people lose fish that they are always”big”. Losing fish makes them bigger. That is the funniest lie that fisherman make. Other than that, great article and couldn’t agree more.

  5. Excellent article and please keep writing them! You are right on regarding fighting the fish on the surface and the smaller trout are the ones that I have my LDR’s (Long Distance Release) occur with. Fishing this Saturday, I had two smaller trout that easily were brought to the surface and then the streamer popped loose as they were only hooked on the rear hook. The bigger trout I let them to dive due to their size and when brought to net, they had the whole Barely Legal streamer in their mouths.

  6. Great advice i agree if i can get past the first 5 seconds of the fish doing the washing machine move on the surface,, then get em down its pretty sure i get them in,but that first 5 seconds are hair raising thats why we fish lol


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Articles

Recent Posts

Domenick Swentosky

Central Pennsylvania

Hi. I’m a father of two young boys, a husband, author, fly fishing guide and a musician. I fish for wild brown trout in the cool limestone waters of Central Pennsylvania year round. This is my home, and I love it. Friends. Family. And the river.

Pin It on Pinterest