Streamer Fishing Myth v Truth — Eats and Misses

by | Oct 21, 2020 | 13 comments

I first dedicated significant river time to the long flies in my twenties. Until then, I was like most anglers. I’d occasionally attach a Wooly Bugger to the line when I couldn’t get anything else going. It was a last resort that provided new hope and novel entertainment if not always a trout in the net.

Looking back, I know exactly the day when I shifted my focus to streamers for the first time. It was early fall. And although I went out of my way to find solitude on a river, I found myself in a pleasant conversation with an old-timer on the walkout. He told me that when the colorful maple leaves and brown oaks made their way to the water, it was prime streamer season. Fair enough, I thought. And in that moment I promised a full season’s dedication to fishing streamers. It was the beginning of my first streamer phase.

— — — — — —

It began as it does for most, I assume. I had a number of lack-luster days with few fish and more frustrations. I fished five days a week back then, so I had the time to make mistakes and try to correct them. I was largely influenced by the writings of Joe Humphreys. And by my count, he had four different ways to fish streamers. I practiced them all.

I remember it was a wet fall, with consistent rain that kept the rivers full and the anglers few. (These are still my favorite river conditions, no matter the season.) I carried only streamers, leaving all other flies behind. And after about two weeks and ten trips, I saw a distinct trend — I was missing a lot of trout.

My first streamer phase ended with the fall season that year, and I remember nymphing most of the winter. But I’d learned and developed enough of a streamer game to keep it in my rotation.

A few years later, I read Kelly Galloup’s Modern Streamers for Trophy Trout, and it re-sparked my interest. Galloup’s ideas were new to me, with large flies and aggressive presentations. Surely, I thought, this would improve my hookup ratio. I wouldn’t miss trout so often. But, of course, the opposite was true. I caught fewer trout because bigger flies gave the fish more to reject. And faster presentations made the streamers harder to catch. I just missed more trout.

READ: Troutbitten | Modern Streamers | Too Much Motion? Are We Moving Them Too Fast?

Photo by Nicholas Roman

But why?

That was the question.

Around this time, I found my first group of fishing friends. There were about ten of us who fished hard and shared ideas. It was the original Troutbitten group. Most of these guys had been through streamer phases as well, and everyone told the same story: Streamer fishing is full of missed takes. So at least I wasn’t the only one.

From our conversations, a better question developed. Were we missing the takes, or were trout missing the fly? Over time, over endless conversation, cases of craft beer and thoughtful theories, we came to understand that our hook sets were rarely at fault. No, we set fast and hard. We were good anglers, with crisp, attentive sets. The high percentage of misses were really the trout’s decision. We summarized it this way: Sometimes a trout misses the fly. Sometimes a trout refuses the fly. And sometimes a trout attempts to stun the fly before eating it.

READ: Troutbitten | Streamer Presentations — The Head Flip

Now, many years later, I believe this more than ever. Those missed takes are simply part of the streamer game. Sure, we can improve the odds by finding the perfect pattern and a precise presentation that convinces a trout to commit. But overall, streamer fishing is full of drive-bys and collisions. Trout like to attack the fly at full throttle. Then we set hard and feel nothing but an empty hook and a loose line. That’s the streamer game. And every good, honest angler I know tells the same story. Compared to dry flies, wets and nymphs, a solid streamer eat is far more rare.

Trout miss our fly in three ways. Here they are . . .

The Refusal

Through fifteen feet of water, Old Granddad catches a glimpse of polar chenille flashing through the backside swirl of his dead-log pocket. He’s the dominant wild brown trout here, and the oak log is at the edge of his territory. Something like stubborn aggression is triggered by the invasion of an apparently small trout through his staked-out spot. Old Granddad surges for your streamer, covering the expanse with two swift tail kicks and paddling fins.

You notice the charge, and you suppress an amateur urge to set too quickly. Time slows, and you pause, waiting the extra milliseconds required for the trout to hit your fly.

It happens, and you strip set. But you feel nothing — just a touch of contact and then loose line. Old Granddad recedes back to the shadows and you’re left with nothing. Correction — you’re left with the address of an apex predator. And that is something valuable, indeed.

Old Granddad never actually tried to eat your streamer. He changed his mind at the last second. He saw your fly for a fake and turned away, refusing your streamer at the final instant before committing. His momentum carried him into the fly. And as he turned away with swiftness, it surely looked like he tried to eat your streamer. But he didn’t. We all make this assumption for a while. Our eyes can’t gather enough frames per second to see this happen. So we assume that the trout missed our fly. Or maybe we set late or in the wrong direction.

But, no. This time, the trout refused our fly. And I think it happens more than anything else.

The Stun

Trout do another thing that looks like a missed eat. They sideswipe or T-bone their prey to stun it.

I first learned about this from Galloup. And since then, it’s been correlated through videos and other sources. I think I’ve even processed enough frames per second once in a while to witness it first hand.

With larger baitfish or juvenile fish of much size, trout must eat their prey head first. Swallowed at this angle, the fins lay down, allowing the prey to slide down a trout’s throat. But eaten tail first, a small fish can become stuck in a trout’s throat, because the fins stand up and resist being swallowed.

Trout can force this head-first angle in two ways: They can swim to ambush the fly head first, or they can broadside their prey with a solid strike, then come back to eat the drifting food form with a confident, leisurely gulp. I’ve seen this happen twice on a float — not to my fly but to small, unlucky fall fish. This swift aggression and measured plan was something to see. And it made a confident believer out of me.

Sometimes trout hit our streamers hard, with no intention of eating them on that first strike. Logically, then, following the strike by dead drifting our streamers immediately after the assault should seal the deal. Right? But it almost never works. Instead, trout sense the fake on the first hit. On the stun, they realize their mistake. And the best fish in the river are not about to make that same mistake twice.

READ: Troutbitten | Streamer Presentations — The DEATH Drift

Photo by Nicholas Roman

The Miss

Sometimes, trout simply miss our flies. They take aim, timing their strike to eat the whole fly, expecting certain natural, predictable movements from their prey. When the motion we impart on our streamer doesn’t meet their expectation, our fly doesn’t end up where the trout had planned. And just a half-inch bankside can mean the difference between a direct eat and a clear miss.

So when a trout does miss our fly, I believe the error is usually in our presentation.

Acceptance

Most misses on streamers are not the angler’s fault. And we must accept these refusals as part of the game.

We can cover more water, to show the streamer to more trout.  We can work on refining the presentation, to find a fly and a retrieve that seals the deal — making trout an offer they can’t refuse. And we can stay on point — ready to strike swiftly only after the trout eats the fly.

Beyond that, there’s not much to do about missed opportunities on a streamer. But we should always note the locations of the best trout in the river and come back swingin’ next time.

Fish hard, friends.

READ MORE : Troutbitten | Category | Streamers

 

Enjoy the day.
Domenick Swentosky
T R O U T B I T T E N
domenick@troutbitten.com

 

Share This Article . . .

Since 2014 and 700+ articles deep
Troutbitten is a free resource for all anglers.
Your support is greatly appreciated.

– Explore These Post Tags –

Domenick Swentosky

Central Pennsylvania

Hi. I’m a father of two young boys, a husband, author, fly fishing guide and a musician. I fish for wild brown trout in the cool limestone waters of Central Pennsylvania year round. This is my home, and I love it. Friends. Family. And the river.

More from this Category

Podcast — Ep. 5: Fly Fishing the Mono Rig — Versatility and the Tight Line Advantage Taken Further

Podcast — Ep. 5: Fly Fishing the Mono Rig — Versatility and the Tight Line Advantage Taken Further

After hundreds of Troutbitten articles featuring the versatility of the Mono Rig, now there’s a podcast. My friends Josh, Austin, Trevor and Bill join me to discuss how each of us fishes this hybrid rig as a complete fly fishing system, detailing the ultimate flexibility of this amazing tool.

The Troutbitten Mono Rig is a hybrid system for fishing all types of flies: nymphs (both tight line and indicator styles), streamers, dry-dropper, wets, and small dry flies. With twenty pound monofilament as a fly line substitute, better contact, control and strike detection are gained with the Mono Rig versus a traditional fly line approach. And yet, the casting here is still a fly line style cast. Ironically, it takes excellent fly casting skills to efficiently throw a Mono Rig.

Finding the (Almost) Invisible Potholes — Reading Water

Finding the (Almost) Invisible Potholes — Reading Water

Just as the taller rock creates a surface wave, the pothole, bucket or depression in the riverbed has a corresponding feature on the surface. It’s a flatter, calmer piece of water — smoother than the surrounding surface currents. Is it harder to recognize? Sure it is. It’s also not as reliable of a sign. But quite often, if you find a calm piece of water, surrounded by mixed currents and minor waves, a pothole lies below.

Be careful what you’re reading, though. The stall, or slower piece of water that lies just downstream of every rock, is not the same thing as a pothole — not at all . . .

#8. The Strike: Nine Essential Skills for Tight Line and Euro Nymphing

#8. The Strike: Nine Essential Skills for Tight Line and Euro Nymphing

The strike is the best part of fishing. It’s what we’re all out there waiting for, or rather, what we’re trying to make happen all day long. And the trout eats because we get so many things right.

We fool a fish, and we fulfill the wish of every angler.

When the fish strikes, we strike back. Short, swift and effective, the hook finds fish flesh. Then we try to keep the trout buttoned and get it to the net.

In the next article, this series concludes with the focus on putting it all together . . .

The Backing Barrel Might Be The Best Sighter Ever

The Backing Barrel Might Be The Best Sighter Ever

A simple piece of Dacron, tied in a barrel, is a visible and sensitive addition to your tight line and euro nymphing rig. The versatile Backing Barrel serves as a stand-alone sighter, especially when tied with a one-inch tag. Better yet, it draws your eyes to the colored monofilament of any sighter and enhances visibility threefold. The Backing Barrel adds a third dimension of strike detection, with the Dacron flag just stiff enough to stand away from the line, but just soft enough to twitch upon even the most subtle takes . . .

Podcast — Ep. 3: Night Fishing, and the Mouse Emerger Concept

Podcast — Ep. 3: Night Fishing, and the Mouse Emerger Concept

My night fishing friends, Josh and Trevor join me for a fun and detailed discussion about mouse emergers. This style is about taking the benefits of a top water pattern at night and making it a little harder for the trout to resist. Then, sometimes, we fish similar patterns that remain in the first 3-12 inches of the water column. My friends and I also trade night fishing stories about the scariest and most unusual things that happen while fly fishing after dark.

What do you think?

Be part of the Troutbitten community of ideas.
Be helpful. And be nice.

13 Comments

  1. This may sound crazy but what do the trout think the fly is when they refuse it? I understand that the size or color may be off or just a little different, but why does a trout go after your fly and then refuses it at the last second. What changed its mind. Do they know it’s artificial and not real.

    Reply
    • Hi Greg. They realize it’s fake. I think it’s that simple.

      Reply
  2. The last time you fished streamers – were you successful or did you want to go right back to nymphing?

    Reply
    • Hey Beau,

      So, most days out there I switch over to streamers a few times throughout the day, just to see if I can find a good streamers bite or to do something different. If I don’t get any response from the trout in about 20 minutes, I go back to another tactic.

      Last time was last night. And I did not have any takers or even looks. So I went back to a dry fly.

      Make sense?

      Cheers.
      Dom

      Reply
  3. I think the streamer game is quite similar to swinging soft hackles for trout. You won’t connect on every bite, but the ones that do are enough to keep you at it. Only difference is you can catch fish on the swing all day long at times, while the streamer bite seems to occur early and late for me…

    Reply
    • Interesting. Swinging wets doesn’t work very well here — not on any regular basis.

      Reply
  4. Had a “streamer moment” last week.

    Arrived at my spot (a tiny semi-alpine lake) and had the place to myself. Saw quite a lot of rainbows in the water . Started off with a dry dropper setup……..nothing. No strikes, no interest, no action. Poked around a few different spots, varied my retrieve hear and there, tried some other flies…………….still nothing. Fish weren’t really rising but tried a couple of dries that usually do well here just because……………..and still nothing. I always do well at this spot with a basic tan scud, either hanging off an indicator, or slow retrieve along the bottom so I tried that……………….annnnnd, nothing.

    I could see the trout most of the time, and they simply had no interest in what I was offering (or how I was offering it). A few came over and poked a bit, but they just weren’t having it.

    Next I tied on a basic black wooly bugger (with a tiny bit of flash). Cast it out and as soon as it hit the water….BAM, trout on. Okay, let’s try that again. I proceeded to land a fish on my next six casts in a row. Hmmmmmm, maybe there’s something to this. So, I kept casting it, tried different spots, tried different retrieves, and basically everything worked. Fish just kept grabbing it. After a while it was getting too easy, so I switched out to other things…..and yep, absolutely nothing else got the slightest bit of action. But when I switched back to that wooly bugger (or another similar one as the first ones got worn out!), I would catch a fish more often than not.

    I stopped counting at 3 dozen fish.

    So, I guess this was a streamer day.

    d.

    Reply
  5. It’s like you freekin see into my mind and questions. For last month have been fishing buggers 95% of time. I have had 8 fish days,they’re fun to fish,and personally tired of the extreme care needed for nymphs. But while love the hard hit on swing have found most effective either Euro fishing close,or dead drifting as long as possible,striking on every pause. But main reason for comment is exactly your subject,misses. A lot!! And love trying to analyze why. For most part always figured fish missed,due to erratic movements on my part,or just didn’t get full fly in mouth. Don’t have luxury of ever watching,so just hypothesis. But the other reasons given seem totally logical,and have noticed even small,aggressive trout if miss a hit rarely can be fooled into hitting again. Love the articles,thanks again

    Reply
    • On the back of that black wooly bugger about 24 inches, I always tie on a soft hackle. I especially like a soft hackle pheasant tail nymph, or I use a soft hackle based on what has recently been hatching.

      The fish usually attack right at the end of the swing just as that first small strip of line.

      Just last week caught four nice trout in the tail of a run by switching out that tail fly. Caught 1/2 fish on bugger and 1/2 on soft hackle.

      Try it you’ll like it

      Reply
  6. Interesting take on streamer fishing, Domenick. You mention the take where the fish stuns the prey first then eats on a second take to avoid swallowing tail first. It is steelhead season here now, and I have taken several fish this past week all on streamers. The fish taken have all hit once and hard and were securely lip hooked. I have had several quick hits and nothing. I wonder if the size of the streamer compared to the fish matters. I suspect a three/four inch long streamer to a several pound fish matters little if it is taken head or tail first. Also streamers can imitate other critters that do not grow fins, such as large nymphs and especially crayfish. The pattern I have enjoyed the most success steelheading in the fall, is the Autumn Splendour which I believe imitates a crayfish…and fish of all stripes enjoy their crawdads! Also, the “stun hit” would mean that following this type of take the angler should simply relax the line and let the fly drift ready for the second hit. I have tried this on a number of occasions and never been successful.

    Reply
  7. Hi Dom,
    Interesting article as usual. Glad I’m not the only one who misses a lot of fish when fishing streamers. Of course, I miss a lot of trout when fishing dries as well. I either set too slow or too fast. Of course a lot of misses are probably last second refusals. Blaming the fish is a nice excuse for my ineptitude. For example, I was fishing a small hopper on the Yellow Breeches this week. At one point I had missed 7 fish in a row before finally connecting. Several misses were clearly my fault – I was fishing upstream and allowed too much slack in my leader so when the fish rose I missed because of the extra line and leader on the water. B.T.W. I saw almost no flies on the water the whole day and very few fish rising so I was surprised at how many fish came up to the hopper. I also fished a parachute ant, one of my go to flies on heavily fished slow sections of PA trout streams and had almost no takers. Best rig for the day was the hopper on top and a zebra midge on the bottom. Caught fish all day long in both the slow sections and the riffles.

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Articles

Recent Posts

Domenick Swentosky

Central Pennsylvania

Hi. I’m a father of two young boys, a husband, author, fly fishing guide and a musician. I fish for wild brown trout in the cool limestone waters of Central Pennsylvania year round. This is my home, and I love it. Friends. Family. And the river.

Pin It on Pinterest