Perfect from the Start

by | Jun 28, 2020 | 15 comments

Call them educated. Say they’re picky, experienced, touchy or selective. The wild trout that many of us target are efficient feeders, and they don’t buy lousy presentations of a fly.

In many regions, the rivers are so rich with bug life and baitfish that these trout have options. They eat what they want. In some places, like the spring-fed streams of limestone country, trout feed all year long, with no pause for water that’s too warm or too cold. It isn’t, so they eat whenever they want. There is no “feeding season,” because it happens 365. And when a trout can feed on what it wants, when it wants, that trout doesn’t eat poor presentations of a fly. The cast and the drift — our presentation — must be perfect.

Photo by Bill Dell

From the Start

I know experienced anglers who believe that if the fly is drifting naturally as it approaches the trout, it should be enough. But they’re wrong. It’s not enough.

A dry fly angler may cast well above a rising trout and drop the fly in the same lane at long distance. But if drag sets in quickly, the cast is useless. Can you mend to feed enough slack above the dry and set up a perfect drag-free look as it passes over the rising trout? Sure, if you’re handy with the fly rod. But selective wild trout rarely buy it. Because, before the dry settles into the drag-free drift, our trout has already seen the fly dragging far upstream. And the fly is refused before it ever gets close to the trout.

READ: Troutbitten | Fifty Fly Fishing Tips: #10 — Mend Less

I’ve met anglers who’s nymphing strategy starts with long casts, well above their target water. They believe in giving the fly time to drop through the column by casting further upstream of the trout, eventually setting up the right level and speed of drift before it reaches the fish. But this is another mistake. Because the extra line on those far-off casts causes drag, and the trout see it coming further than most of us estimate. Then, just like the dry on the surface, trout refuse the dragging nymph long before it approaches them.

These are wasted casts. And they are long moments spent drifting flies that will never be eaten.

What’s the solution?

Stick the landing.

READ: Troutbitten | Stick the Landing While Tight Lining

We must make casts that show a perfect presentation from the start. And for dry flies and nymphs, that means providing a drag free drift at the beginning.


Much of our success, in whatever we do, goes back to refining the basics. And fly fishing is no exception.

Choose shorter casts over longer ones, for the extra control. Wade as close as possible. Stay mobile and take two steps over rather than stripping off another six feet of fly line.

READ: Troutbitten | Be a Mobile Angler

And remember, perfect presentations on a dry fly are often set up in the air rather than mending line on the water.

Likewise, the best dead drifts with a nymph include a tuck cast, turning over the line and the leader to poke our flies through the surface with only the tippet that must enter. The rest stays above the water. Yes, we tuck cast, even in shallow water.

READ: Troutbitten | Fly Fishing Strategies — The Tuck Cast

Sometimes, longer drifts cannot be helped. But it’s up to us to make the presentation perfect from the beginning, or at least as soon as possible.

Photo by Trevor Smith

Never underestimate how far away a trout can see upstream. And never underestimate how far away a trout will refuse a fly. It might drift perfectly, right past the trout. But the decision — the refusal, may have already been made with the fly twenty feet upstream.

Make it perfect from the start.

Fish hard, friends.


Enjoy the day.
Domenick Swentosky


Share This Article . . .

Since 2014 and 600 articles deep
Troutbitten is a free resource for all anglers
Your support is greatly appreciated

– Explore These Post Tags –

Domenick Swentosky

Central Pennsylvania

Hi. I’m a father of two young boys, a husband, author, fly fishing guide and a musician. I fish for wild brown trout in the cool limestone waters of Central Pennsylvania year round. This is my home, and I love it. Friends. Family. And the river.

More from this Category

Tight Line Nymphing — Strike Detection is Visual

Tight Line Nymphing — Strike Detection is Visual

Smith set up over my right shoulder and watched for a while, quietly examining my backhand drifts and spitting sunflower seed shells on the water. I landed two trout and missed another . . .

“Did you feel those strikes, or did you set the hook because the sighter twitched?” Smith asked . . .

“They rarely hit hard enough to feel it,” I told him. “And if you’re waiting for some some kind of tug or tap, you’re missing a lot of strikes.”

The Sweet Ride

The Sweet Ride

There’s a sweet spot to every drift. For each swing of a wet fly, strip of a streamer or drift of a dry, there’s a range — a distance — where the fly looks its best. This is the moment where the fur and feathers tied to a hook are most convincing or most natural. It’s when the fly is really fishing and not just dragging through the water. Good anglers recognize this sweet spot of the drift. They maximize its length. They position themselves in the river to control it with their rod tip or with slack line. And they set it all up to happen over the best trout in the river . . .

We’re looking for the best part of what happens after a cast. We’re searching for the sweet ride. And we’re trying to make it last as long as possible . . .

Tight Line Nymphing: Drift with a Stable Sighter

Tight Line Nymphing: Drift with a Stable Sighter

A simple piece of colored monofilament might be the most important element in a tight line nymphing rig. The sighter, placed just above the tippet section of the leader, shows us everything about the drift. When fished well, a Mono Rig or a euro nymphing setup provides the angler with amazing control over the course of the flies. So it’s important to use it to our advantage.

Reading the sighter is an unending education. Like so many interesting pursuits in life, tight lining is something you can refine to no end.

Everything we read from the sighter follows from first gaining contact. Learning to make that contact happen, and learning to see whether we are in touch with the flies, is the primary skill. Everything else follows from there.

In a future article, I’ll break down all the elements of reading a sighter, but for now, let’s focus on just one important aspect — keeping the sighter stable . . .

Tending your tags and point flies — A DIY hack for multiple hook keepers

Tending your tags and point flies — A DIY hack for multiple hook keepers

One of the more irritating trends in the fly rod market these days is the absence of a hook keeper above the cork. Plenty of us think it’s an oversight. And I’m tired of the worn out excuse that there’s a hook keeper at every guide. Rod guides aren’t the same. Give me that thin little u-shaped hook keeper just above my cork, please.

Even with a hook keeper for the point fly, those of us who use tags for a second fly are often frustrated by the tangling tag while walking to the next honey hole.

Solution: mini rubber bands.

Here are a few tricks to get it just right . . .

Everything that touches the river drags — Everything underneath drags even more

Everything that touches the river drags — Everything underneath drags even more

This one is simple. Line, leader or tippet laying on the water drags. It’s a plain truth staring right back at us. Meaning, it’s pretty easy to see the results of drag on the water’s surface. It’s harder to see drag happening under the water and out of sight, but once you’ve put in a few thousand river hours, intuition mixes with experience and the subtle visual signals above the river reveal the same telltale drag.

. . . Only the line that has to touch the surface should be wet. Even more importantly, only the line that must go under the surface should disappear. Here’s how and why . . .

What do you think?

Be part of the Troutbitten community of ideas.
Be helpful. And be nice.


  1. I think the degree to which any individual trout refuses a fly due to long distance drag depends a lot on their mood. Happy, steady risers seem to be less sensitive to slight imperfections in presentation. In my neck of the woods, a lot of wild trout are caught by guided clients who have anything but perfect presentation skills.

    • Thanks for the thoughts, Rick.

      Happy and steady risers are a rare thing, honestly, no matter where you are. Out of a full year, that’s a small percentage of time.

      But certainly trout can be taken with less than perfect presentations. I think we agree with that, and I’ve been through it here on Troutbitten. But do you want to catch more trout, and do you want to catch tough trout in tough waters? Get things perfect from the beginning.


      • Happy, steady risers are getting scarcer than ever around hear. They are a godsend when you find one for sure. So much pressure from drift boats and anglers in general. Not to mention the return of eagles and osprey which are all over the UDR system. No one can argue against the benefit of a drag free presentation from the get go. And completely agree that aerial mending beats water mends 9almost) every time. Hey, I hope your streams have more water in them the freestones up here. Been an unusually dry June. Keep cranking out your unique takes on the sport. Cheers

        • Those big wild bows on the UDR are a lot more forgiving than the browns when it comes to a perfect drift.

    • I think that to many monorigged are caught up with long drifts. In true pocket water or highly oxygenated runs my drifts start with a tuck cast and sticking the landing. This might be a 1 to 3 second drift which covers 3 to 10 feet. Hook set at 2 to 3 o’clock and redeliver. It works

    • Ahhh! Tenkara!!

  2. Because of drag or poor presentation a trout will refuse a fly. What does the trout think the fly is or what’s wrong with the fly. I understand that it may look unnatural, but I can’t imagine that every real fly in the water looks perfect.

    • Gary Borger put it this way: Imagine you have cut up your steak into bite size pieces and while you’re eating one of the pieces suddenly crawls off your plate. Are you really going to stab it with your fork and eat it?

      • Oh what a visual that is! I’m going to use that in teaching my grandson fly fishing.

  3. Love your blog! So how far *can* a trout see upstream? Here’s my situation:

    I’ve spotted a nice fish, but the only way I can get a good drift is from directly upstream. I want to land the fly close to minimize drag and avoid having to put more slack into the system (maybe a bucket cast?). I have had a couple refusals and ended up putting the fish down.

    For next time, how far in front of it do I need to drop an emerger or dun so that it comes into its vision “naturally” versus just “appearing” on the water? Maybe I should throw a terrestrial, which is more likely to just plop in its face?

  4. Another great LESSON.

  5. An exception to your rule is French Nymphing in crystal clear slowe water – still with no fly line on the water for drag but longer presentation drifts while avoiding being seen by Mr. Trout.

  6. I’m just leaving one comment, and technically it’s not even mine.

    ‘Perfection is not attainable, but if we chase perfection we can catch excellence’ V Lombardi.

  7. Mending right after casting to get a drag free drift is critical for dries. It’s hard to do right and not pull the fly a bit so most people dont do it. If you can master it you will have good drifts right from the start. Pros can do all of the fly line and have the mend stop at the leader with no motion of the fly. Most of us (me included) end up figuring out how to cast some slack in the right spot to avoid mending.

    When the action is slow i spend my time looking for tough situations and figuring out how to mend well to get the drag free drift for when the hatch is on. after many years i am still terrible at it.

    • Hi Mauro,

      Honestly, I’d say the “pros,” as you put it, know how to cast with slack and be accurate before the line hits the water. I think that’s a greater challenge than mending.

      I agree with you that a good mend is also hard to do.

      But I’m a big advocate for mending less, almost always.

      This article explains my thoughts more:



Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Recent Articles

Recent Posts

Domenick Swentosky

Central Pennsylvania

Hi. I’m a father of two young boys, a husband, author, fly fishing guide and a musician. I fish for wild brown trout in the cool limestone waters of Central Pennsylvania year round. This is my home, and I love it. Friends. Family. And the river.

Pin It on Pinterest