What’s the Deal With Hare’s Ear?

by | Apr 8, 2020 | 18 comments

Last night, I slumped back in my chair and away from the tying desk. It’s lit like an operating room. With three hi-wattage beams shining on one very small object from left, right and center, my eyes don’t miss much. Combine that with 2X-power readers and some steady hands, and I can turn out well-crafted flies as small as you like. I have no trouble inserting details into a fly, but I’ve never approached fly tying with that kind of goal anyway.

Like most good fly tyers who are better fishermen, I learned long ago that realism in a fly is one thing to a trout and another thing to a fisherman. So I scrapped that bias and whittled my patterns down to the elements that I believe attract fish. My guiding theory on fly design is that trout are looking for a reason not to eat my fly. So I limit materials only to what’s necessary. Nothing more.

READ: Troutbitten | What Moves a Trout to the Fly?

I leaned a little further back in my chair to stretch my legs under the table, tickling the extension cords for all those lights. Then I crossed my arms and stared at the dubbing materials on my desk while I thought about all of this . . .

I believe too many triggers on a fly is a bad thing — it’s a turn-off to the wild trout that I fish for. What’s a trigger? It’s something that grabs a trout’s attention and helps convince them to eat.

And while many anglers may think about color or flash first, I think of movement as a primary trigger just as often. Motion of materials is endlessly talked about in streamer design. And on the big platform of a streamer — an inches long fly — it makes sense to think about how materials might move. But for patterns that imitate bugs rather than baitfish, movement is perhaps undervalued.

These things move: hackle collars, CDC wings, appendages like rubber legs and more. Peacock herl moves, and even the small barbules of pheasant tail wave in the currents, providing micro movement that seals the deal.

But, as I stared at my open nymph box with empty slots waiting to be refilled, I realized that much of the movement built into my flies comes from the dubbing that was spread across my desk — Hare’s Ear.

What’s so special about Hare’s Ear dubbing anyway?

Photo by Bill Dell

That’s the Stuff

I’m not the first to fall in love with Hare’s Ear. In fact, it’s a good bet that most of you carry a few flies with the good stuff dubbed onto a hook, in some form or fashion.

I learned to tie flies in the nineties, by following the tutorials in a Skip Morris book. The pics were good, and I remember that somewhere along the line, Skip espoused the values of Hare’s Ear dubbing.

But I was confused, so I talked to Woody, at my local fly shop. I told him I wanted to cut and blend my own dubbing, like Skip said I should. So Woody sold me a bunny mask in a bag that looked like something a toddler could wear for Halloween. Just add the elastic band to hold it on. He also gave me a package of Hare’s Ear Dubbing from Hareline. It had a label that read HD4. And that was the first of hundreds of packages I’ve bought since.

I did blend my own for a while. I used all of that skin mask and then another. I learned about guard hairs, awn hairs and underfur, and how different parts of the mask offered fur that was wiry or soft, short or long, thin or course. All of it was on that one mask.

Cutting and blending hair from those masks was a valuable lesson. And I daresay I know a little more about Hare’s Ear dubbing than most anglers who tie with the stuff. I did the same thing with a few other skins that I bought at Fly Fisher’s Paradise some years later: Fox Squirrel, Grey Squirrel, Muskrat and Beaver are the ones I remember. And I learned that no two fur types are the same — not even close.

After all of that, here’s what I learned makes Hare’s Ear special.

In the Mix

Good Hare’s Ear dubbing has a unique blend of soft and silky fine-fibred underfur and longer awn hairs (secondary fur) that are just barely stiff enough to stick out. It also has a naturally wide variation of color tones, dark to light.

The soft stuff is the base of the dubbing. It’s thin enough to float in the air. It’s easily swept into your nose, and if you’ve ever tied a dozen Walt’s, you know what I’m talking about. But then, look to your lap and you’ll see the other fibers — the stiffer, longer stuff. While the underfur almost floats in the air, the awn and guard hairs drop with gravity as they should.

Again, plenty of animal fur has this mix of underfur, middle fur and guard hairs. But a good Hare’s Ear blend is special. The longer hairs are not very stiff, and they dub easily. The mix forms a perfect dubbing noodle, because the stiff hairs are soft enough to bend and flex. Squirrel dubbing, for example, is spikier, with shorter, thicker and stiffer hair, but it’s not as lively. The shaggy parts of Hare’s Ear that stick out from the fly move more than most other dubbings.

This, That and the Other Thing

I leaned forward in my chair again, back under the halo of warm light. And I reached into my drawer to leaf through my Hare’s Ear selection. I chuckled as I realized that I’ve collected a full row of the stuff.

I used to cut and blend my own. I did that for years, until finally I realized that what I was aiming for was very much the same stuff that came in the Hareline Hare’s Ear dubbing mixes. The texture of dubbing in those packages is just about perfect. There are some variations between packages, and I do like to look through a dozen or so bags to find just the right one, but overall, what comes from Hareline is the mix I’m looking for.

That said, I still mix a lot of dubbing, more for the color than anything, and I often like to blend in a little flash, some sparkle yarn or a bit of antron.

While thumbing through the row of Hare’s Ear dubbing variations and blends I noted these colors most: Natural, Olive and Dark Hare’s Ear. I also have many colors of Hare’s Ear plus, with antron already mixed in.

I glanced up at the small white coffee grinder at the back of my tying desk. The hinge is broken, but I always hold the lid down before hitting the power button.

Over time, I’ve learned to mix the Hare’s Ear Plus with one of the regular bags, because I want a little less antron than what comes standard in the Hare’s Ear Plus packages. A few spins in that coffee grinder is a good thing. And I use the grinder to blend materials together, to add a little flash or some extra spikiness of squirrel hair, or just to fluff a chunk of dubbing before I start working with it.

Favorites

Hare’s Ear dubbing is one of my confidence materials as a fly tyer. And if you’ve tied flies long enough you know what I mean. It’s just the dubbing that I keep coming back to.

I use it for my Bread-n-Butter and the Black-n-Tan. It’s the key to all my Walt’s Worm variations, and it forms the dubbing collar for many other nymphs in my box. My favorite dubbing makes it onto many of my streamers too.

I like Hare’s Ear so much that I even use it on many dry flies. It’s the extra movement and natural color variation that does it for me. I tie a Parachute Hare’s Ear because Tom Rosenbauer recommended it in a book that I read long ago, and I’ve never looked back. Most of my Klinkhammers are really spin-offs called a Sledgehammer, from Hans Weilenmann. And Hare’s Ear dubbing is used for the sunken . curved part of the body.

The Black-n-Tan and the Bread-n-Butter

Buggy Bugs

Good Hare’s Ear dubbing is soft but spiky. The underfur flutters and undulates in the currents, and the wiry pieces are still thin enough to flex and move with the push and pull of a river.

The stuff looks buggy. And I often use a piece of Velcro or a bore brush to rough it up and make it buggier.

So while modern nymph design seems to push more and more slimline flies like Perdigon variations, the buggy look of well-dubbed flies will never go out of favor, either. I want both styles in my fly box.

— — — — — — —

Olive Walt’s on a scud hook. Best damn imitation of a caddis that I know. And it’s often my best fly during a BWO hatch. Go figure.

I leaned toward the desk to sit under the lamps again. Then I picked up the bobbin and lined it with 8/0 Uni-Thread in dark brown, ready to tie a half-dozen Olive Walt’s on a scud hook with a silver bead. Simply, buggy and deadly with one single material — Olive Hare’s Ear Dubbing Plus.

Fish hard, friends.

 

** I’m sure you have your own dubbing preferences and your own reasons for those favorites. Feel free to share in the comments section below. **

 

Enjoy the day.
Domenick Swentosky
T R O U T B I T T E N
domenick@troutbitten.com

 

Share This Article . . .

Since 2014 and 600 articles deep
Troutbitten is a free resource for all anglers
Your support is greatly appreciated

– Explore These Post Tags –

Domenick Swentosky

Central Pennsylvania

Hi. I’m a father of two young boys, a husband, author, fly fishing guide and a musician. I fish for wild brown trout in the cool limestone waters of Central Pennsylvania year round. This is my home, and I love it. Friends. Family. And the river.

More from this Category

Troutbitten Fly Box — The Bunny Bullet Sculpin

Troutbitten Fly Box — The Bunny Bullet Sculpin

In a world of oversized, articulated streamers drenched in flash and draped with rubber legs, the Bunny Bullet is naturally sized and tied on a single hook — with just a little disco . . .

If the average modern streamer is an exotic dancer, then the Bunny Bullet is a stay-at-home Mom who gets stuff done . . .

It’s olive. It looks exactly like something trout love, and it’s designed to look vulnerable. (It seems like an easy meal.) The cut points of the deer hair head provide the angler visibility from above, it fishes well with or without split shot, and It looks good stripped or drifted . . . . .

Troutbitten Fly Box — The Bread-n-Butter Nymph

Troutbitten Fly Box — The Bread-n-Butter Nymph

This simple nymph is a winner. The Bread-n-Butter looks enough like a mayfly nymph, enough like a caddis, or enough like a small stonefly to be a very productive pattern. Whatever trout take it for, it gets attention and seals the deal frequently. It’s on my short list of confidence flies.

Yes. It looks like a Hare’s Ear nymph. Half the stuff in my box looks like a Hare’s Ear or a Pheasant Tail. When you turn over rocks to see what kind of bugs trout are eating, most of what you find fits under the category of “little brown things with some moving parts.”

My theory of fly selection is based in simplicity. I don’t carry hundreds of patterns, because I’ve found that I don’t need to. And carrying fewer flies forces me to adjust my presentation — to fish harder — instead of blaming the fly and changing what’s on the end of my line.

The Perfect Parachute Ant

The Perfect Parachute Ant

What’s your favorite hatch? Sulphurs? Drakes? Tricos? Mine’s the ant hatch -- and I don't mean the flying ones. Every year I look forward to the end of Spring hatch season. In Pennsylvania, mayfly activity tapers off in June, and so do the crowds. The free-for-all is...

What do you think?

Be part of the Troutbitten community of ideas.
Be helpful. And be nice.

18 Comments

  1. Good advice. To quote Thoreau:
    Our life is frittered away by detail. Simplify, simplify, simplify! I say, let your affairs be as two or three, and not a hundred or a thousand; instead of a million count half a dozen, and keep your accounts on your thumb-nail.
    The few will catch many.

    Reply
  2. Hey Dom,

    What hook are you using on the Olive Walt’s? Looks mean.

    Thank you!

    Reply
    • Hi Mike,

      You’re probably looking at the Daiichi 1120. There’s also an Umpqua 202 in that picture.

      Cheers.

      Dom

      Reply
  3. But why do we call it hare’s EAR? Is it because the traditional fly used long fibers from the hares inner ear for tailing material? Or does hares ear dubbing really include ear hair? I usually just pull fur from right between the eyes for dubbing, where do you recommend pulling hair from when making your own dubbing?

    Reply
    • I think most resources will tell you it’s really the whole mask, or at least most of it. It should more accurately be called Hare’s Mask dubbing. Around the ear, there are certainly different types of hair, a little fluffier, than the stuff around the eyes, for example. You could probably find a good tutorial online for blending your own Hare’s Ear dubbing from a mask. Or buy that Skip Morris book. 🙂

      Cheers.
      Dom

      Reply
  4. Dom, just curious what type of “operating lights” you ar1e using. My tying room has very poor lighting and need to improve it

    Reply
    • Hi Scott.

      I don’t think there’s any reason to buy special lights for your tying desk. Not at all necessary. Just get desk lamps with articulated swing arms. I have two of them, and then a central light that is stationary. The bulbs and the angles matter more than the lamps. And that will be your own personal preference. I like GE Reveal bulbs. Wattage doesn’t matter as much as lumens. Just get it bright. I’d say at least 1200 lumens per lamp.

      Hope that helps.

      Cheers.
      Dom

      Reply
  5. Have you tried Joe Achourey blends really nice stuff ?
    Joeack12 @ hotmail.com

    Reply
    • No, not yet. But I’m sure it’s great. There are a ton of really good blends out there, and I like mixing my own too.

      Cheers.
      Dom

      Reply
    • Hi do you have to email him or is it available online?

      Reply
      • You have to email him. He takes PayPal. It truly is wonderful dubbing. George Daniel wrote about it a while back. Joe tells me it is secret blend from his father. I just know it dubs well and looks incredibly buggy

        Reply
        • Your comment about the importance of the movement of the tying material of a fly is why I’ve found the gold ribbed hares ear soft hackle to be my most successful fly given situations that favor soft hackle fishing.
          Love your posts.

          Reply
  6. Domenick –
    Cover something for me (us).
    We put all kinds of threads and feathers and furs and dubbing on a hook. We elect each for their required colors and mottling and stiffness We’re careful to wax it and fluff it and cinch them all properly. Then we carefully tie the result of this selection and craft to the end of a transparent wisp of chemicals and toss it into the current. It immediately interacts with H2O and everything changes. Colors change or disappear or all transition toward the same brown as every other fly. Stiffness disappears…sometimes. Mottling becomes more or less intense. What are we to do? Is all this effort pre-ordained? Intended for the changes and alterations once our creation hits water? How can we be sure it’s all correct, tested, confirmed, verified and authenticated by some higher authority.
    I’ll trust your response.
    Ron

    Reply
    • Hi Ron,

      Good to hear from you.

      I think well designed flies already take all this into account. And I think the answer is just that simple. Good fly designers aren’t just fly tyers. They are excellent anglers who test the pattern. So the flies are tested on the water, and we see what color they are. Many of us appropriate the bathtub, the kids fishbowl or the neighbor’s pool to test flies as well. All of this comes into account. And, honestly, I think you can see, around the web, some tyers and companies that don’t do much but throw some materials together that look pretty and interesting. They give it a clever name and go sell it. It’s the old adage that most flies are designed to attract fishermen more than fish.

      Cheers.
      Dom

      Reply
  7. One of my mentors was a dry fly guy almost exclusively. His favorite was a 16 hair’s ear dry. It was a traditional hackle grizzly/ginger with lemon wood duck wings with a hairs ear body. He used to say “if you start with a 16 hair’s ear dry (on his river), you are usually very close to what they are eating” Just tie it on and go fishing.

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Recent Articles

Recent Posts

Domenick Swentosky

Central Pennsylvania

Hi. I’m a father of two young boys, a husband, author, fly fishing guide and a musician. I fish for wild brown trout in the cool limestone waters of Central Pennsylvania year round. This is my home, and I love it. Friends. Family. And the river.

Pin It on Pinterest