Tending your tags and point flies — A DIY hack for multiple hook keepers

by | Nov 3, 2019 | 26 comments

I busted through the last few feet of underbrush and into a wide open space. Now standing on dry rocks, I gazed upon the perfect, rippling flat across from me, just downstream of a prime spillout. In average flows, this river bumps up against a thick tangle of briers and a maze of bank side tree parts. But as the water recedes to low flows, the eastern bank becomes an exposed bed of broken limestone. And here I stood.

The faint smell of decaying crayfish and stranded caddis cases caught my attention. It signaled that the water had only recently dropped below this dry shelf. I thought about all of this and more. Then I sighed and breathed deep while stretching my arms toward the sunless sky. After being hunched over and half-crawling through fifty yards of tangled brush to get here, the contrast of open space was startling — and welcome.

I almost forgot that I wasn’t alone — until I heard Smith grumbling from behind. Lost somewhere back in the dense woods, he bellowed loud enough to reach over the far ridge.

“Where the hell is the path? Where are you, Dom?!”

I chuckled a bit. This is one time that Smith’s lumberjack size was a clear disadvantage.

“There’s no path, man. Just keep fighting through that mess.” I spoke with an average volume, without straining, and my calmness carried over to my friend.

“Alright. Yeah,” he replied.

I heard Smith from just ten yards away. Then I saw the waving tops of saplings and rustling rhododendron.

You’re not very far, are you?” he asked.

I paused for a moment to let Smith pop out of the brush before I answered.


When my friend broke out of the woods, I immediately pointed toward the prime spillout just upstream.

“. . . And this is why we came here, buddy. Look at it. There’s no other way in here without a boat. You won’t find any boot tracks or . . .”

I stopped, because Smith seemed unimpressed. Distracted by something gone wrong, he hadn’t really looked up yet.

“Dammit!” Smith cursed. “It happened again.” He pointed to his fly rod blank, about two feet up from the cork. “This morning the tag fly broke off my tippet, and this time it’s all tangled up.”

“Hey Smith,” I said, only slightly taunting. “You can’t expect to go through brush like that dangling a line without problems.”

“Yeah, that’s true,” Smith agreed. “I guess I could have clipped off the fly and then tied it back on but . . .”

“Nah, don’t do that,” I interrupted.

I stepped across the limestone chunks and reached for Smith’s fly rod. With two hands I popped the second and third sections loose from his four-piece Sage.

“Hold this,” I said, as I handed him the upper part. I stuck the lower section with the reel between my legs. Reaching into my vest. I quickly found a small, ¼ inch rubber band — the same ones I use to attach my favorite yarn indicators. Then I slipped the band over the ferrule and doubled it up before sliding it down to about the same point where Smith’s tag fly should be dangling. With the band in place around the rod blank, I took the upper section back from Smith and joined his rod together again, with the line still strung up and doubled back.

I looked at my friend and handed him the rod.

“I would just cut it and tie on a new tag this time.” I said. “But it shouldn’t happen again if you use that band to secure your tag fly from now on.”

“Dude, that’s genius,” Smith said, staring at the improvised and movable hook keeper.

“No it’s not,” I said. “But it works.”

“Dom, you have so many of those little system tips that you could fill a book with them,” Smith said.

“I’m working on it,” I told my friend.

And we turned to the river.

— — — — — —


One of the more irritating trends in the fly rod market these days is the absence of a hook keeper above the cork. Plenty of us think it’s an oversight. And I’m tired of the worn out excuse that there’s a hook keeper at every guide. Rod guides aren’t the same. Give me that thin little u-shaped hook keeper just above my cork, please. Because, if I use the stripping guide for a hook keeper, my tag fly is about four feet away from me.

Yeah, it’s a rough life. These aren’t third-world problems, but efficiency is something that most good anglers appreciate.

Some guys use the rod cork to hold the point fly, but that tears up your grip pretty quickly. Others affix the fly to the reel somehow. But any time the fly is behind your hand, there’s the chance of embedding a hook into your flesh if something tugs on the line the wrong way — like when walking through brush.

I’ve also seen where guys take their tippet around the reel and then attach the fly to the stripping guide. Don’t get me started on that one. If you have a tag fly involved, you’re asking for even more trouble.

This one is tending the tag


So the tiny rubber band trick just makes sense. A couple of years ago, I used one as a substitute hook keeper when the manufacturer mistakenly decided that I didn’t want one. It worked really well, and later that day I decided to put another band further up the rod, like I did for Smith.

It solved a problem that I’d struggled with for years. Because a dangling tag fly does hang up and twist while walking around to relocate. It happens too often, and if you’re busting through any brush, it’s guaranteed trouble.

The position is easily adjustable, too. And that’s a great thing for the tag fly. Because the distance from tag to point is often variable. The band slides easily to wherever it’s needed to maintain tension.

I guess you could employ a variety of rubber bands for the trick. But I find the small ¼ inch orthodontic rubber bands that I carry for mounting yarn indy’s and Thingamabobbers to be perfect. Doubling them up creates enough tension to hold the hooks without sliding, but if you want more tension, you could add another turn or perhaps use a second band.


Buy 1/4' Medium Gauge Orthodontic Bands HERE


The bands add no weight to the rod, and they are small enough not to spoil the handsome look of your fly rod that cost you a week’s pay (if you actually care about that stuff).

Barbless hooks slide in and out from under the band with ease. But barbed hooks can stick a bit, so go barbless — duh.

These bands will eventually break. However, mine last a long time before I replace them. Last time I fished with Smith, the band on his rod was the same one that I’d placed there a couple months ago. And he used it all day without comment. That means he liked it.

Fish hard, friends.


Enjoy the day
Domenick Swentosky


Share This Article . . .

Since 2014 and 700+ articles deep
Troutbitten is a free resource for all anglers.
Your support is greatly appreciated.

– Explore These Post Tags –

Domenick Swentosky

Central Pennsylvania

Hi. I’m a father of two young boys, a husband, author, fly fishing guide and a musician. I fish for wild brown trout in the cool limestone waters of Central Pennsylvania year round. This is my home, and I love it. Friends. Family. And the river.

More from this Category

Podcast: Stick the Landing — Tight Line Skills Series, #3

Podcast: Stick the Landing — Tight Line Skills Series, #3

Part three of this Troutbitten Skills Series focuses on sticking the landing. Because after putting ourselves in great position to present the fly, we shouldn’t waste the perfect tuck cast and delivery. As the fly hits the water, all the elements of our system are in position and ready to drift. That’s sticking the landing.

Like a gymnast who tumbles, somersaults and then lands on two feet with no body movement, the best completion of a cast happens with no extra movement. Instead of landing and then recovering or correcting, we stick the landing, ready to drift.

Strategies for Pressured Trout — Something Different or Something Natural?

Strategies for Pressured Trout — Something Different or Something Natural?

Trout learn to see some colors, some materials, some shapes and movements as fake. And when they see the same fake fly often enough, they stop eating it. That’s what we mean by angler pressure. So, part of the game becomes a guess about what flies the trout have learned to reject and how we can turn the fish on again.

That’s the unnatural thing about trout seeing too many fishermen and too many flies . . .

Podcast: Turnover and Tuck Casting — Tight Line Skills Series, #2

Podcast: Turnover and Tuck Casting — Tight Line Skills Series, #2

Part two of this Troutbitten Skills Series focuses on the tuck cast. A good tuck is a turnover cast — where the loop unfolds completely in the air. In fact, a tuck cast is a fly-first entry, and it’s perfect for setting up the tight line advantage, where we keep everything up and out of the water that we possibly can.

We tuck cast not just to get deeper, but to setup the fly, tippet, sighter and leader in the best possible position to drift the flies down one seam. Accuracy starts with a good tuck, and not just accuracy over where the fly goes, but where all the parts of the leader go too . . .

The Advantages of Working Upstream

The Advantages of Working Upstream

For the majority of our tactics, fishing upstream is the best way to present the flies. And sometimes it’s the only way to get the preferred drift.

So too, working upstream allows for stealth. The angler becomes the hunter. With a close, targeted approach to smaller zones, we get great drifts in rhythm, one at a time . . .

Find Your Rhythm

Find Your Rhythm

With confusion and some sense of despair, I wondered what was wrong with my presentation? What else could I adjust to convince these trout?

Then it hit me. I was fishing hard, but I was hardly fishing. With all of those changes, I’d had no rhythm. I’d been inefficient and had struggled for consistency . . .

What do you think?

Be part of the Troutbitten community of ideas.
Be helpful. And be nice.


  1. This is “genius”! I’ll buy the book when it comes out!

  2. I’ve been using a small piece of sticky back Velcro as a hook keeper. I’m satisfied with how it works

    • That’s a great idea for the hook keeper, John. I used some permanent thing like that too. The band is nice for tending the tag because its position is slidable. You might like that as well.



  3. Thanks for yet another brilliant, life-enhancing fishing tip!

  4. Great tip Dom! I’m going to try this the next time out.

  5. My kid wears braces. I’ll snag some of those rubber bands! Thanks

  6. The perfect solution for the problem as far as I’m concerned. Thanks Dom.

  7. You are way to humble. This is the best fly fishing hack of 2019. I bust trail a lot and the dreaded dangling tag use to drive me nuts. Even on my older rods with a hook keep I always seem to be just shy of the keep. Anyway great hack, keep on with the articles.

  8. Great tip, Dom. Thank you.

  9. Simple yet brilliant. When can we expect the book?

  10. simple and effective. isn’t that the definition of a genius idea?

  11. Well,my friend,after survived the full size spare to the donut,the lack of ash tray,and now no CD player,we are just all victims of the rise and fall occurring during the 21 century. After a intense cost analysis all rod manufacturers came to the same conclusion,we can not keep profitable numbers and include a fly hook,so damn the consumer,we are eliminating this,and they’re lucky we still include a second tip section. Huh? Really!!! OMG it’s happening,profits over integrity.

    • Put five 1/4″ rubber bands in a bag, write Orvis adjustable hook keepers on the front and sell for $15.99.

      • You jest, but probably under discussion in marketing departments as I write this. LOL.

  12. Great little tip Dom – Thanks. For the past few years I’ve been using a 3″ rubberized fliexible utility twist to keep my fly tags in place. They work fine; however, I have to place them in my pocket after each use. The ortho rubber bands sounds much more convenient. Thanks!

  13. What a great idea! I just use an old twist-tie from a loaf of bread bag. I can easily put it anywhere I need it, or a couple of them if I’m fishing 3 flies. It works great but I’m trying your orthodontic band next trip out.

  14. I could tell where this is going just from the picture. I’ve been where Smith was MANY times. This will be on my fly rod from now on.

  15. I use a small “mounting hole” cable tie. Works perfectly. The hook fits right in the hole without getting too close to the rod.


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Articles

Recent Posts

Domenick Swentosky

Central Pennsylvania

Hi. I’m a father of two young boys, a husband, author, fly fishing guide and a musician. I fish for wild brown trout in the cool limestone waters of Central Pennsylvania year round. This is my home, and I love it. Friends. Family. And the river.

Pin It on Pinterest