Quick Tips — Thumb on Top | Finger on Top

by | Nov 14, 2018 | 2 comments

There’s a reason for everything, right? It’s a truism of life. And that goes double for your fly fishing game. Most of us will never get the hours we really need to learn everything we’d like about the river. Trout fishing runs deep. Questions we ask of ourselves on the walk back after dark linger in our minds until the next time we hit the stream. Until then, we research — we read, watch and talk about trout on a fly rod, filling in the hours, days and weeks until our boots are wet again.

Sometimes, things like these quick tips might answer that nagging question in your mind. Other times, one of these tips might create a new question to chew on. Both are significant. Both are valuable.

Pick a side

When we hold the fly rod, should the thumb or the forefinger be on top?

I use both. There are good reasons for each hold, and we’ll get to that briefly. But accuracy and power suffer if you do anything else.

So finger or thumb. Pick one. Just don’t do this . . .

No good.

Thumb

The thumb-on-top hold is arguably more common. It’s the standard. I think it’s also the most natural. It allows the index finger to be the trigger finger, and that’s more natural too.

The thumb on the cork lends more power to the cast. I tend to switch over with the thumb on top when I’m casting at distance or if I’m pushing streamers through the cast with fly line.

 

The wrist also has more freedom with the thumb on top. That’s likely why it’s the standard — because good dry fly casting comes from the wrist. We want crisp and clean acceleration between ten and two, with short, compact motions mostly achieved through the wrist.

READ: Troutbitten | Fly Fishing Tips #28 — Ten and Two

For years, I used only the thumb-on-top approach. I tried the finger up there a few times because my friend, Rich (an excellent dry fly fishermen), cast with his index on top. His wrist got plenty of power and movement with the finger on top too. But when I tried it, I felt awkward.

Until . . .

Finger

I learned to tight line nymph with the Mono Rig on a five weight rod. At the time, specialized two and three weight rods designed for “euro nymphing” were not yet available. So we all used what we had — four and five weight rods — for the long leader styles.

Although I had tight line nymphed for years with a Joe Humphreys style, when I finally committed to a full Mono Rig, I struggled a bit with the casting.

One day that I spent with Loren Williams on the water changed all that. Loren saw my difficulty. He saw my thumb on the rod cork, and he recommended a change. He suggested putting my finger on top instead — fingertip on the rod blank — tucking the butt of the rod against the inside of my forearm.

“Take the wrist out of the cast,” he told me. Keep the wrist locked and cast with your arm bending at the elbow.

Notice how the butt of the rod is against the inside of the forearm.

Top angle

It worked right away. I gained distance and authority over my long leader casts, and within an hour I was comfortable with the new position.

It was so effective, that I never really looked back. Over time, I loosened the grip a bit. I don’t tuck the rod into my forearm as much, and I brought some wrist back into the cast. When I do cast with specialized, more flexible nymphing rods, I notice that I can cast them with a more traditional wrist approach.

READ: Troutbitten | For tight line nymphing and the Mono Rig, what’s a good fly rod?

I use the finger on top most often. I now use it for dries and even streamers on many days. And I also like the sensitivity I gain with my fingertip on the rod blank. When tightlining, it’s a real benefit.

Some anglers (like Rich) argue that the finger on top provides more accuracy than the thumb. I don’t know about that, but I’m open minded, if you want to prove it to me.

Either | Or | Both

You’ll find excellent anglers employing both styles. And that’s what it is, really — a personal style.

But the next time you’re on the water, try the other method. Give it an hour or so, and you’ll probably notice some advantages. Maybe you’ll end up using both positions too.

Fish hard, friends.

Photo by Josh Darling

Photo by Josh Darling

 

Enjoy the day.
Domenick Swentosky
T R O U T B I T T E N
domenick@troutbitten.com

 

 

Share This Article . . .

Since 2014 and 600 articles deep
Troutbitten is a free resource for all anglers
Your support is greatly appreciated

– Explore These Post Tags –

Domenick Swentosky

Central Pennsylvania

Hi. I’m a father of two young boys, a husband, author, fly fishing guide and a musician. I fish for wild brown trout in the cool limestone waters of Central Pennsylvania year round. This is my home, and I love it. Friends. Family. And the river.

More from this Category

Nobody Home | Nobody Hungry

Nobody Home | Nobody Hungry

Nobody home means there’s no trout in the slot you were fishing. And sometimes that’s true. Nobody hungry suggests that a trout might be in the slot but he either isn’t eating, isn’t buying what you’re selling, or he doesn’t like the way you are selling it.

Does it matter? It sure does!

Be a Mobile Angler

Be a Mobile Angler

Wading is not just what happens between locations. And it’s not only about moving across the stream from one pocket to the next. Instead, wading happens continuously.

Many anglers wade to a spot in the river and set up, calf, knee or waist deep, seemingly relieved to have arrived safely. Then they proceed to fish far too much water without moving their feet again. When the fish don’t respond, these anglers finally pick up their feet. Maybe they grab a wading staff and begrudgingly take the steps necessary to reach new water and repeat the process.

This method of start and stop, of arriving and relocating, is a poor choice. Instead, the strategy of constant motion is what wins out . . .

Beyond Euro Nymphing

Beyond Euro Nymphing

Euro nymphing is an elegant, tight line solution. But don’t limit yourself. Why not use the tight line tools (leaders and tactics) for more than just euro nymphing?

Use it for fishing a tight-line style of indicators. Use it for dry dropper or even straight dries. And use it for streamers, both big and small.

Refining these tactics is the natural progression of anglers who fish hard, are thoughtful about the tactics and don’t like limitations. I know many good fly fishers who have all come out the other side with the same set of tools. Because fishing a contact system like the Mono Rig eventually teaches you all that is possible . . .

New Structure | Old Structure

New Structure | Old Structure

One of my favorite places in the world is a deeply shaded valley that runs north and south between two towering mountains of mixed hardwoods. The forest floor has enough conifers mixed in to block much of the sunlight, even in the winter. The ferns of spring grow tall, and thick moss is spread throughout. The ground remains soft enough here that all large trees eventually surrender to the valley. When they can no longer support their weight in the soft spongy ground, they fall over, leaving a broken forest of deep greens and the dark-chocolate browns of wet, dead bark. It’s gorgeous.

Fallen timber also dictates the course of this cold water stream. The fresh tree falls force the creek to bend away from the hillside. Rolling water carves away the earth and lays bare the rocks — these stones of time, as Maclean puts it. And when water cuts into a neighboring channel, previously dry for centuries, new river banks are undercut and fresh roots exposed . . .

Light Dry Dropper in the Flow

Light Dry Dropper in the Flow

. . .The flow of the fly line through the air is finesse and freedom. Contrasted with nymphing, streamer fishing, or any other method that adds weight to the system, casting the weightless dry fly with a fly line is poetry.

The cast is unaffected because the small soft hackle on a twelve-inch tether simply isn’t heavy enough to steal any provided slack from the dry. It’s an elegant addition that keeps the art of dry fly fishing intact . . .

Streamer Presentations — The Cross-Current Strip

Streamer Presentations — The Cross-Current Strip

There are a lot of ways to retrieve a long fly after the cast. And that’s really what’s so much fun about the streamer game. Fly anglers might spend hours fretting over the imperfection of a drag free drift on a dry fly or twice as long considering the depth and drift of a nymph, but when the streamer is tied on, it’s a chance to let loose. Nothing else in fly fishing allows for such freedom of presentation. “Everything works sometimes.” No other fly type fits that tenant so well.

But what will trout respond to most? That’s the question. And on many days — most perhaps — the answer is a cross-current strip. Here’s why . . .

What do you think?

Be part of the Troutbitten community of ideas.
Be helpful. And be nice.

2 Comments

  1. 95 percent of my casting is with my forefinger on top. I tore the tendons in my casting arm a long time ago and casting this way was much more comfortable and didn’t aggravate it one it healed. Casting this way now is normal for me.

    Reply
  2. I find all this discussion of rivers fascinating. I dont have one nearby and havent been on one fishing is a long time….

    Theres a third grip position, what I call the “Paintbrush Hold.”
    I think of it as a finesse casting grip; its end result is to treat the cast like flipping paint off the end of a brush.

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Recent Articles

Recent Posts

Pin It on Pinterest