Penns Creek Catch-and-Release Miles Doubled — Yes, You Did It

November 9, 2018

You probably voted this past Tuesday, right? You walked into the booth and cast a ballot in this midterm election cycle for your state and local representatives. Or maybe you voted early. Maybe you mailed in a ballot. However you voted, it’s pretty easy to think that your one, single vote didn’t matter much, because even close state elections are often determined by thousands of votes. It’s understandable to feel like your vote doesn’t make a difference. It does, but that’s another discussion . . .

By contrast, you can personally have a direct influence on the way wild trout policy is decided in Pennsylvania. And many of you have.

On October 16, 2018, the Pennsylvania Fish Commission voted to add 3.8 miles of Catch-and-Release regulated water on Penns Creek. This “Section 5” water now doubles the miles of C&R river available to anglers, and it protects the Class A wild trout population within. This is an enormous success, and many of you are part of it.

In September, I published the article, Two Percent — Penns Creek Needs Your Voice. It circulated well. There was a lot of discussion through email and on various social media channels, and hundreds of people followed the link in the article to the Pennsylvania Fish Commission website to quickly fill out a form and be part of the public comment period. But do hundreds of comments really matter? Yes. They absolutely do!


There were 549 comments in total, and 440 were in favor of Catch-and-Release regulations. According to Rob Shane, Mid-Atlantic Organizer for Trout Unlimited, the sheer number of comments was outstanding. Rob says that 100 comments on wild trout policy is more typical of past proposals. And these public comments are a key factor in the board’s decision to pass such regulations.

The point? If you want to make a difference in wild trout policy in Pennsylvania, you can. And many of you already have.

“It’s incredible to see the public engage so much on such a critical issue,” said Rob Shane. “Getting 549 people to take the time to make their voices heard is a testament to the quality of Penns Creek as a fishery and a treasured resource. It’s also proof that anglers are not shy to stand up for something that they know is the right choice.”


The move for a strong wild trout coalition in Pennsylvania came to a crescendo last August (2017), when the PA Fish Commission held their first Wild Trout Summit. You can read about that here:

READ: Troutbitten | We Are Wild Trout | Looking forward, after Pennsylvania’s first wild trout summit

And now, as my friend Chase Howard (President of the Seneca Valley Trout Unlimited Chapter of PA) said to me, “We’ve come a long way in a short period of time. But there’s still a lot of work to be done before we realize our potential in Pennsylvania.”

The future of wild trout in PA just received a major shot in the arm, with the doubling of Catch and Release miles to Penns Creek.

READ: Troutbitten | Why Wild Trout Matter

Thank you, to everyone who took the time to make your voices heard during the public comment. Know that it made a difference.

Further information:

PFBC: Addition of Penns Creek, Section 05, Union County, to the Catch-and-Release Artificial Lures Only program — PDF (Oct. 2018)

PFBC: Penns Creek, Section 05 Fishery Update and Regulation Review — PDF (Feb. 2018)


Here’s a video of the PFBC 129th Board of Commissioners Meeting | October 16, 2018. (The Penns Creek Section 5 discussion starts at the 1:04:30 mark.)


Now let’s keep moving forward.

Fish hard, friends.


Enjoy the day.
Domenick Swentosky


Read More Troutbitten Commentary


What do you think?

7 Comment threads
2 Thread replies
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
8 Comment authors
  Follow the comments on this article.  
Notify of
Alex Argyros

Excellent news!

David Weigle

Absolutely huge news. Thanks for sharing this.

Kerry Gubits


James Slepesky

Thanks for writing these articles in general. However I would have likely not known about the form or where to find it. Your article led me to it and I made sure my voice was heard. Popular sovereignty and consent of the governed at its finest. Now we can double how hard we fish on Penns

Andrew C DeLisle

Yes.. Congratulations
Protect them wild fish

Bob Posliff

Congratulations from the Province of Ontario Canada. Conservation Authorities oversee many of our coldwater streams and rivers and with input from Trout Unlimited many have been catch and release for several years. No live bait, no treble hook lures, barbless flies only. My home stream is 45 minutes from the Greater Toronto Area of near 5 million people and wild Brook and Brown trout are still resident there. One river 1 1/2 hours away has heritage status and draws anglers from far and wide for its outstanding Brown trout. Thanks to catch and release.


Great news. Penns creek is a phenomenal fishery from trout to smallmouth

Domenick Swentosky

Hi. I'm a father of two young boys, a husband, author, fly fishing guide and a musician. I fish for wild brown trout in the cool limestone waters of Central Pennsylvania year round. This is my home, and I love it. Friends. Family. And the river.

TCO Fly Shop
dead drift philosophy shark Night Fishing Wild Mushrooms summer small streams bar boots TU suspender fishing FishHard PFBC traction walking eggs spawning tight line nymphing George Daniel front ended friendship droppers Plans Fly Fishing wet flies rigs come on man beadhead tips Fifty Tips thunderstorm stinky bass dog Sawyer Quote big fish Whiskey giveaway etiquette split shot State College family rookies Wild Brown Trout spot burning Dry-Dropper home-stream knots wild trout fishing tips fall indicator nymphing saltwater DJS Fly Casting One Great Tip Galloup tight lining Floating fly line favorite catch and release Pennsylvania Burke fluke surf fishing regulations stocked trout comp fishing conservation PSA bite windows strip set drop shot nymphing Weather nymphs efficiency night-sighter Buggers dorsey yarn indicator tracks streamside hiking swinging Fly rods winter fly fishing flood mayfly nymphing winter fishing river strategy Joey Backing Barrel wading boots Wild vs Stocked reading water fly rod Trout Unlimited photography Night net Press BES Ask an Expert Tippet Rings Harvey Pusher Resources It's just fishing falling in explore indicator fishing backcountry leaders tenkara last cast Central PA Christmas Lights Stockies Troutbitten Fly Box Boat marginal water Joe Humphreys simplicity Mystery Namer big brown trout winter drifting camera musician silence carp Gierach wading DHALO Memories Sighter tippet wildlife brown trout science matters mousing patience History gear fighting fish nymphing tips fishing with kids ice Dad travel Bad Mother Camping Night Fishing Chapters fly patterns Grobe Industry Stuff Baseball Little Juniata River dry fly fishing cookout public land Doh Rich Dylan Headbanger Sculpin LBI Streamers Float Fishing waders Aiden wet fly fishing flies DIY Jeff Grandfather Peace George Harvey tightline Big Trout How it Started skunked Euro-Nymphing friends snags trout bum Presentations rules Trust mud Spring Creek summertime fishing club fishing montana safety high water fly fsihing boys mistakes float dry flies mono rig angler types PA Gold Streamer fishing brookies backcast wet wading posted land Whiskey Drinker the Mono Rig solitude Fish Hard Film Orvis brush fishing Davy Wotten tiny flies fly box Oakiewear Discovery time casting fly tying