Nymphing: How to read a fly fishing indicator — What you might be missing

by | Oct 17, 2018 | 17 comments

I know, I know. You don’t like to fish with indicators, right? You think an indy removes the angler from contact with the nymphs. You believe a fly fishing indicator actually gets in the way of strike detection more than it helps the situation. Granted, there are big problems with the way most fly fishermen use indicators. And I know a lot of anglers who refuse to attach them to a leader.

But I also know many more good anglers who see the value of indicators, who reach for an indy (or a dry-dropper rig) when a tight line nymphing presentation fails, who recognize that an indicator is an amazing and useful tool that extends our effective nymphing range, balances out a drift and helps keep the flies in one current seam.

I think a lot of anglers miss the finer points of the indy game. Good indicator nymphing (or dry-dropper fishing) is not just a chuck it and chance it affair. Instead, careful attention to the indy itself, reading the water against the position and behavior of the indicator, is a necessary skill if the tactic is to be productive.

A fly fishing indicator is both a suspender of weight and an indicator of the drift.

Let’s dig in . . .

READ: Troutbitten | It’s a Suspender, not just an Indicator

 

Get tight first

All of this is predicated on the indy being in touch with the nymphs. And that happens at various points following the cast: sometimes sooner, sometimes later.

One of the great things about indy fishing is how effectively a slight amount of slack in the system can be managed. A tight line presentation tends to pull out any built in, useful slack, while an indy rig may maintain a bit of slack between the flies and the indicator for long stretches within a drift.

All of the subtleties discussed below, however, occur once the indy is in touch with the flies (or the weight) under the surface.

READ: Troutbitten | One Great Nymphing Trick

 

In touch yet?

A good indicator sends a signal to the angler once it gains contact with the nymphs.

Ideally, we land the nymphs upstream of the indy, all in one current seam. As the nymphs sink and drift downstream, they eventually gain contact with the indicator floating on the surface. (Skilled anglers manipulate the available slack between the nymphs and the indy as the pair hit the water.)

When the two are out of touch, the indicator may orient sideways a bit. It may canter off to the side. It may appear unstable, rocking and swaying with the currents. Watch the indy for all of that.

And then watch for it to change. See the indy tighten up a bit. See its orientation shift. Watch how it stands upright. All of this happens once it gains contact with the nymphs underneath. This is how you know the indy is in touch with the flies.

Importantly, gaining contact is different than slowing down. That’s the next thing to watch for . . .

READ: Troutbitten | Tight Line vs Indicator

 

The lag

“How do I know if my nymphs are on the bottom?” It’s a question considered by every fly fisher who’s ever probed the depths of a river. The better question to ask is, “Are my nymphs in the strike zone?”

The indicator signals the position of the nymphs to the angler. And when the nymphs are in the strike zone, the indy slows.

READ: Troutbitten | Forget the Bottom | Glide Nymphs Through the Strike Zone

Watch the surface currents. See the bubbles. Even without foam or bubbles on the surface, you can see the speed of the topwater if you look close enough.

When the indy first lands, it’s carried only by the influence of the surface currents. First, watch for the indy to gain contact with the nymphs — watch its orientation or stability, as described above. Next, watch for the indicator to lag behind the surface currents. See it drift slower than the top water. This is your indication that the nymphs are near the bottom.

Water flowing near the riverbed flows slower than the surface currents. It’s an elementary fact that should be printed on the back of every little plastic package of indicators. The water at the bottom of the river is slowed by the rocks, tree parts, weeds, etc. Trout live there. They sit on the bottom, conserving energy, while faster water flows above them. Get your nymphs down into this strike zone and catch fish.

And when the indy drifts slower than the top current, it’s a signal that the nymphs are where they should be.

 

Do you see it now?

We all watch the indy for a strike. That’s the obvious indication from our “strike indicators.” And I’ll leave it to you to decide whether to set on every jiggle, or only the major bumps of the indicator. Most of those jiggles and bumps are not trout takes, but we set anyway, because one out of twenty times . . .

READ: Troutbitten | Nymphing: Set on Anything Unusual

Does your fishing buddy who doubles up your fish count have a sixth sense for nymphing that you don’t?

Probably not.

Here’s the thing: by watching the other signals of the indy, by observing the orientation and stability, and by watching for the slow down, the best nymph fishermen gather more data about the drift than the guys who just chuck it and chance it. The skilled nympher processes all that data in real time. He factors in the positioning and the contact of the nymphs against the indicator. And he weighs all of that against the probability that each of those small jiggles or bumps is a strike. That is the sixth sense stuff.

READ: Troutbitten | Tight Line Nymphing with an Indicator — A Mono Rig Variant

 

Photo from Matt Grobe

What Indy?

I know enough good anglers to understand that indicators are a personal choice, and a skilled nymph fisher can make just about any indicator style work for him.

So fish what you like, but choose wisely. Select your indicator with the above properties in mind.

All indys will show you the slow down. But some don’t indicate the orientation very well — they don’t indicate contact with the nymphs.

I fish Dorsey yarn indicators and Thingamabobbers, and when I fish indys, it’s most often with a tight-line-to-the-indicator style on a Mono Rig.

READ: Troutbitten | The Dorsey Yarn Indicator — Everything you need to know and a little more

I love the Dorsey as a first choice because of how well it indicates everything discussed above. It’s extremely sensitive because it’s so light. Even better, the varied angles at the tips of the yarn show me a lot more about a drift than most other indy styles. The Dorsey usually canters to the side or lays down a bit when it’s out of touch with the weight underneath. Then it perks up and sits tall on the surface once it feels the payload. What’s more, by using two colors in the Dorsey, I see slight rotations and minor twists as the Dorsey floats on the surface. Those motions provide an angler with a full picture of what’s going on with the flies underneath the water.

My own second choice of indicator is a Thingamabobber. I like it for casting at distance, and I like it for extra long drifts that I plan to finish out all the way below my position (down and across). The Thingamabobber doesn’t send nearly as many subtle signals as the Dorsey, but it has its own set of strengths.

The Troutbitten slide-able Thingamabobber hack

READ: Troutbitten | Your Indicator is too Big

Last thing here: Whatever you choose, go with lighter and smaller indicators, because they are more sensitive. Less built-in buoyancy means a more reactive indicator — and you can better read the subtle signs. Use indys that are on the edge of sinking under the payload. Adjust often. Watch closely.

. . . and fish hard.

 

Enjoy the day.
Domenick Swentosky
T R O U T B I T T E N
domenick@troutbitten.com

 

 

Share This Article . . .

Since 2014 and 600 articles deep
Troutbitten is a free resource for all anglers
Your support is greatly appreciated

– Explore These Post Tags –

Domenick Swentosky

Central Pennsylvania

Hi. I’m a father of two young boys, a husband, author, fly fishing guide and a musician. I fish for wild brown trout in the cool limestone waters of Central Pennsylvania year round. This is my home, and I love it. Friends. Family. And the river.

More from this Category

Be a Mobile Angler

Be a Mobile Angler

Wading is not just what happens between locations. And it’s not only about moving across the stream from one pocket to the next. Instead, wading happens continuously.

Many anglers wade to a spot in the river and set up, calf, knee or waist deep, seemingly relieved to have arrived safely. Then they proceed to fish far too much water without moving their feet again. When the fish don’t respond, these anglers finally pick up their feet. Maybe they grab a wading staff and begrudgingly take the steps necessary to reach new water and repeat the process.

This method of start and stop, of arriving and relocating, is a poor choice. Instead, the strategy of constant motion is what wins out . . .

Beyond Euro Nymphing

Beyond Euro Nymphing

Euro nymphing is an elegant, tight line solution. But don’t limit yourself. Why not use the tight line tools (leaders and tactics) for more than just euro nymphing?

Use it for fishing a tight-line style of indicators. Use it for dry dropper or even straight dries. And use it for streamers, both big and small.

Refining these tactics is the natural progression of anglers who fish hard, are thoughtful about the tactics and don’t like limitations. I know many good fly fishers who have all come out the other side with the same set of tools. Because fishing a contact system like the Mono Rig eventually teaches you all that is possible . . .

New Structure | Old Structure

New Structure | Old Structure

One of my favorite places in the world is a deeply shaded valley that runs north and south between two towering mountains of mixed hardwoods. The forest floor has enough conifers mixed in to block much of the sunlight, even in the winter. The ferns of spring grow tall, and thick moss is spread throughout. The ground remains soft enough here that all large trees eventually surrender to the valley. When they can no longer support their weight in the soft spongy ground, they fall over, leaving a broken forest of deep greens and the dark-chocolate browns of wet, dead bark. It’s gorgeous.

Fallen timber also dictates the course of this cold water stream. The fresh tree falls force the creek to bend away from the hillside. Rolling water carves away the earth and lays bare the rocks — these stones of time, as Maclean puts it. And when water cuts into a neighboring channel, previously dry for centuries, new river banks are undercut and fresh roots exposed . . .

Light Dry Dropper in the Flow

Light Dry Dropper in the Flow

. . .The flow of the fly line through the air is finesse and freedom. Contrasted with nymphing, streamer fishing, or any other method that adds weight to the system, casting the weightless dry fly with a fly line is poetry.

The cast is unaffected because the small soft hackle on a twelve-inch tether simply isn’t heavy enough to steal any provided slack from the dry. It’s an elegant addition that keeps the art of dry fly fishing intact . . .

Streamer Presentations — The Cross-Current Strip

Streamer Presentations — The Cross-Current Strip

There are a lot of ways to retrieve a long fly after the cast. And that’s really what’s so much fun about the streamer game. Fly anglers might spend hours fretting over the imperfection of a drag free drift on a dry fly or twice as long considering the depth and drift of a nymph, but when the streamer is tied on, it’s a chance to let loose. Nothing else in fly fishing allows for such freedom of presentation. “Everything works sometimes.” No other fly type fits that tenant so well.

But what will trout respond to most? That’s the question. And on many days — most perhaps — the answer is a cross-current strip. Here’s why . . .

Streamside | Dave Rothrock’s Drop Shot Video

Streamside | Dave Rothrock’s Drop Shot Video

I get a lot of questions about drop shot nymphing, and though I’ve mentioned it countless times in other Troutbitten articles, I’ve never devoted a whole piece to it. Why? Probably because it would take a full series of articles and many diagrams to convey my own take on drop shot nymphing. I’m sure I’ll get to it someday, but for now, here’s a quick rundown of my own drop shot thoughts, followed by a link to Dave Rothrock’s new video, How to Set Up a Drop Shot Nymphing Rig . . .

What do you think?

Be part of the Troutbitten community of ideas.
Be helpful. And be nice.

17 Comments

  1. Good points! If one really wants to see how the indicator can convey what the flies are doing I would recommend getting a 4 gram Blackbird Phantom float and drift it a few times. Because of their length and being rigged in-line they will exaggerate all the movements you mentioned.

    Reply
    • Yowsa! Those are huge, budy. So, anything that heavy and with that much buoyancy won’t react very well to the relatively light pull of a pair of nymphs — not the nymphs we use, anyway. I’m familiar with those floats, but the Dorsey, for example, will show you the same thing at a fraction of the weight and be much more sensitive. Those are my thoughts.

      Reply
  2. I think i am moving away from the thingamabobber and moving towards the air lock ones or the New Zealand type. I would also be interested in the mentioned thingamabobber hack in your last pic.

    Reply
    • Hi Jason. I’ll post the TB hack someday. It uses the same attachment system as the Dorsey and allows for the TB to slide up and down a piece of tippet very easily.

      Reply
      • Good. I’d like to see that hack also.

        Reply
  3. Great post, Dom: a graduate level course in nymphing with an indy.

    As you say, the choice of indy is quite personal. I fish with both Dorsey and Thingamabobber indies, but I especially like balloon indies because they give me so much information. For example, a balloon indy that is somewhat oblong will lie on its side as the nymphs are sinking and then perk up when they first hit bottom. Then it will record the nymph’s journey on the stream bottom with a series of very telling bumps and jerks.

    I struggled with balloon indicators until I came up with a way of attaching them that is simple, and allows for easy adjustment up and down the leader. Find an old ballpoint pen and remove the plastic cylinder that used to hold the ink. Cut it into little pieces, around 3/8″. When you want to attach a balloon, double your leader and stick it through on of the cylinders. You now have a loop on the other side of the cylinder. Now, put a small, cheap water balloon through the cylinder (how far determines how large the indicator is), blow into the balloon a little (just enough to inflate it tiny bit), and then pull the leader plus balloon back into the plastic cylinder (you can see the balloon through the clear cylinder) and cut off the tag end of the balloon. The resulting indy will not kink the leader, will slide up and down the leader easily, and the balloon won’t lose air for a couple of days.

    Alex

    Reply
    • Thanks for this suggestion, Alex. I’m going to give this a try. I’ll be fishing out west next summer, and balloons can be especially good on some of the big rivers.

      Reply
  4. Now, for a question. Everyone has to start somewhere. When you start a day of nymphing on a medium sized stream, do you tend to begin with or without an indy, and why?

    Alex

    Reply
    • I prefer to tight line nymph. So I usually start with water that lends itself to the technique.

      Reply
  5. WOW !!! Great info Dominick I just read it a couple of times

    Reply
  6. Thanks Dom. Since reading this https://troutbitten.com/2015/09/13/fishing-with-the-dorsey-yarn-indicator/ and your other writings the Dorsey has become an integral part of my approach to the river. It’s the inherent versatility and speed in which it allows an angler to adapt to the water that makes it so effective for me. From the more usual applications to the less usual like using a micro Dorsey to better control the tippet’s entry into the water when sight fishing.
    With neon wax to form different functioning in-line indicators, Dorsey and a dry fly I find one long-leader covers all my trout and grayling fishing.

    The only real downside being that the Dorsey isn’t particularly aerodynamic which can cause some issues when fishing with a very light leader but I think I found a solution to that in Daniel’s latest book.

    Reply
    • Very nice, Justin. What is the solution in GD’s book? My solution is to keep the Dorsey small.

      Reply
      • I try and keep them small too, with a ballenced rig that does solve most problems. I’ll often fish a Dorsey too small to suspend the nymph(s) but my two go to leaders for 99% of my trout fishing are made from fairly stiff flurocarbon weighting 0.4g per 12ft (the same as 12lbs maxima) or 0.36 per 12ft so every little helps.

        On page 79 GD talks about wanting the wool to look like the “head of a troll”. When I’m prepping the Dorseys at the tying table I trim some so when folded double they form more of a symmetrical airfoil shape/troll head.

        Reply
  7. Do you have an article or video on the slide-able thingamabobber hack? I couldn’t find anything in a search
    Thanks, Jimmy H

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Recent Articles

Recent Posts

Pin It on Pinterest