Commentary Tips/Tactics

Pattern vs Presentation | Trout eat anything, but sometimes they eat another thing better

on
September 21, 2018

The other day I was listening to a podcast featuring Charlie Craven. I was dreaming of fishing while raking another giant pile of leaves in the backyard when something Charlie said caught my attention: “Trout are not very smart. They eat everything down there.”

It’s a point I’ve heard repeated time and again — that trout brains are small, and they eat sticks, leaves and rocks all the time. Ironically though, the next piece of the podcast interview rolled into what an excellent fly Charlie’s Two Bit Hooker is.

Does that duality make any sense? Sure it does. I think Charlie’s thoughts in the interview match what a lot of us think about fly selection — that trout will eat anything, but sometimes they eat another thing better.

Photo by Matt Grobe

Pattern vs Presentation

The old debate among fisherman about pattern vs presentation is a good one, because just as soon as we have things figured out on the river, the trout throw us a curve ball.

I believe the way you fish a fly is far more important than the way it looks, and I believe that everything works sometimes. But it only goes so far.

The other day, I got back into this recurring discussion with a friend who insisted that pattern means nothing. But he had to chuckle in agreement when I said, “I’ll bet I can tie a fly for you that won’t catch a fish.” Put that way, it makes sense, right?  I mean, there are some boundaries and limits to a trout’s gullibility.

Now back to what Charlie said — that trout are eating everything down there . . .

What are they eating?

I’ve killed a lot of trout. Sorry. I know that’s a little out of bounds to some in the fly fishing culture, but I grew up in western Pennsylvania, where acid mine drainage devastated the viability of wild trout in cold water fisheries. All of the creeks I fished as a kid either didn’t have the right PH level or they warmed too much in the summer to support wild trout. A lot of western Pennsylvania is still like that. Burke calls it trout purgatory.

So, because I grew up around a put-and-take system (where the state puts the trout in the river and fishermen take them out), and because I like to eat trout, that’s what I did for a long time. I kept most of the trout I caught.  I checked the stomach contents of all the trout I gutted, and I can confirm that they really do eat anything. It’s an interesting mess inside a trout. Sure, most of it is caddis parts and crayfish claws, but I found a lot of sticks, pine needles and pebbles. I’ve also seen gum wrappers, corn, cigarette butts and random pieces of plastic.

As a side note, stocked fish have a lot more junk in their stomach than wild ones. Freshly stocked fish are doing more sampling down there than wild trout.

When trout aren’t biting, I’d rather change my approach than change the fly . . . usually.

All trout sample things in the drift, trying to determine if they’re edible. You can watch videos of trout doing this: they pick something up, decide it’s not food and spit it out in a fraction of a second. Strike detection, therefore, is probably more important than pattern, right? And if you can get a trout to be curious enough to eat your fly, you have to set the hook before they drop it.

When trout aren’t biting, I’d rather change my approach than change the fly. In between casts, I’m better off stepping to the side and modifying the angle of delivery, adding weight, lengthening my tippet or moving on to target a different water type. The way I show the flies to the fish is what matters most.

Accepting that idea comes with time. Like everyone else, I’ve waded through the fly bins, the magazine articles and the endless catalogs of new patterns trying to understand what flies I should carry. But the best fishermen I know all have a handful of go to patterns that they use ninety percent of the time — probably more. Most of those patterns are dead simple. My own handful of flies is basic, yet refined enough to cover any situation encountered on the water.

READ:  Category | Troutbitten Fly Box

I carry nymphs, wets, streamers and dries that are big, small, bright, dull, colorful and drab. And I guess, over time, I’ve sorted out the excess and kept what works best. Pretty simple, really. Time with those patterns has given me confidence in them. They fooled more trout, so I took the other ones out of my box because I don’t want to be overwhelmed with options.

But just about the time I’m getting cocky about my handful of confidence flies, a slow day saved by a rogue pattern shakes me up.

Once in a while . . .

Yesterday morning I planned to methodically fish a wide and varied stretch of pocket water. I did that for three hours (fishing my handful of confidence flies) and turned up nothing. Disappointingly, all of the rig changes I made simply didn’t work. When I got to the top of the run, I walked far upstream to relocate and reassess.

The next piece of river had enough logs and undercut banks to inspire a new determination, so when I fished up through the section and still caught only a few small trout, I decided to mix things up. I walked back down to re-fish the same water, tied on a small #18 RS2 as a trailer, and I immediately started getting into fish. The RS2 apparently made all the difference. So I hiked up to some prime big fish water where a heavy run dumps into the next pool, and on the third cast I hooked this guy.

 

pattern-vs-presentation-2006

Whiskey

Technically, the RS2 is in my handful of flies. But it’s one that I don’t use very often these days. I had trailed two of my other small favorites yesterday morning with no luck. In fact, I went back to those other flies after a while to see if they would also produce. They didn’t. There was just something about the RS2 that turned the trout on, and it lasted for a few hours until they finally started taking other flies too.

READ: Troutbitten | Tags and Trailers

I’ve had that kind of thing happen enough times to believe that sometimes the specific pattern really does matter. And then again, it goes the other way just as often.

You probably have a story about the one time you slayed ‘em on the Prince nymph until the fly came apart: the ribbing came off, the herl unraveled, and all that was left were the crooked tail biots and a bare hook. And they kept taking it! Sure they did. I know they did. That’s my story.

Most days fall somewhere in the middle, though. And changing the approach instead of changing the pattern usually gets better results, because a trout will eat anything — sometimes. So I think it’s best to find a handful of flies, build confidence and stick with them until you have a really good reason not.

I’ve also come across a few really special patterns too. Because of that, I always have a few experimental flies in my box. I’m looking for the next wonderfly.

chris-kehres-brookie-1

Photo by Chris Kehres

pattern-vs-presentation-1976

Almost that time . . .

 

Enjoy the day.
Domenick Swentosky
T R O U T B I T T E N
domenick@troutbitten.com

 

 

Tips / Tactics

Read more Troutbitten Tips and Tactics
TAGS

15
What do you think?

7 Comment threads
8 Thread replies
6 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
10 Comment authors
  Follow the comments on this article.  
Notify of

I will take issue to some extent with the premise that “trout will eat anything”. In recent years, I have fished for wild trout exclusively (primarily because the Little j, my home stream, is not stocked). However, like Dom, I grew up killing everything I caught and this included lots of stocked trout. Their stomachs inevitably included debris (sticks etc.) from the flow. I also have killed and eaten many wild trout (before my age of enlightenment). I rarely saw non-food items in the wild trout stomachs. In fact, the wild browns I killed, or stomach pumped (yes I had… Read more »

Steve Troutman

Really appreciated this… thanks for sharing and wholeheartedly agree.

I’m of the opinion that on any given day, a trout will eat anything depending on unknown factors. I’ve tied some monstrosities just to see if the trout would eat. Eventually they do. I enjoyed this post tremendously and will keep it in the back of my mind when I’m out.

Dominick,
I really enjoy your articles. Keep them coming. I was listening to The Freq this past week and found out to late that you were playing at The Ale House. Sorry I missed you, maybe next time.
Take Care,
Steve(from Riffles and Runs B&B)

Kind of funny that in a post about flies you don’t have a picture of any.

Bruce

Hi Dom, I read your article and I agree. Then I read Bill’s reply and I agree. I agree with Howard, Too. It brought me back to the old saying that “there are no absolutes in fly fishing.”

Jason

absolutes or experts

Reminds me about a day I had in late fall four or five years ago on a mid-size CT freestone. Stocked in the spring only, so by that time it’s a mix of wild and holdover fish that have been pretty well pressured. I just couldn’t catch. On anything, fished any way. I found a consistent riser, one of many, that I couldn’t fool. I sat down and watched it for a bit. Then I tossed a little pine cone up-drift from it. You can probably guess what happened. Even after that I still didn’t catch it. Sometimes…. I just… Read more »

Thanks Domenic. I too carry just a few patterns and change presentation far more than flies. I’m getting back into the trout groove now that I’m stationed in PA after years in SoCal and the Middle-East.

Domenick Swentosky
BELLEFONTE, PA

Hi. I'm a father of two young boys, a husband, author, fly fishing guide and a musician. I fish for wild brown trout in the cool limestone waters of Central Pennsylvania year round. This is my home, and I love it. Friends. Family. And the river.

STICKERS
STICKERS
TCO Fly Shop
TAGS
knots split shot etiquette Camping nymphing tips angler types snags mousing net Peace It's just fishing Christmas Lights backcast saltwater Film Dry-Dropper streamside Streamer fishing gear Harvey Pusher montana Presentations fly rod Aiden Whiskey dry fly fishing camera BES safety tracks efficiency mud History winter indicator nymphing Whiskey Drinker Trust Wild Mushrooms tippet hiking Grobe cookout George Harvey giveaway explore photography Central PA simplicity Press wading boys suspender fishing waders stocked trout fishing tips last cast wet flies river TU walking rules Quote Euro-Nymphing Mystery reading water catch and release backcountry Fly rods Spring Creek fly fsihing club fishing mayfly thunderstorm winter fly fishing the Mono Rig ice Backing Barrel Weather Floating come on man travel family friends carp George Daniel beadhead tight line nymphing public land PSA night-sighter flies droppers Sighter dog dorsey yarn indicator Ask an Expert tenkara nymphing philosophy Wild Brown Trout Namer Gierach surf fishing wet fly fishing home-stream conservation indicator fishing Plans small streams Dad spawning Industry Stuff Troutbitten Fly Box Doh marginal water Joey bite windows friendship Davy Wotten tiny flies Resources brown trout float brookies favorite fishing with kids eggs nymphs mistakes big fish Big Trout strategy fluke Galloup Dylan Float Fishing fly patterns Rich dead drift Joe Humphreys Buggers Fly Casting Headbanger Sculpin mono rig brush fishing science matters Night Fishing Chapters summer comp fishing traction wading boots flood Baseball Discovery high water Night Fishing shark solitude Streamers Orvis winter fishing big brown trout wild trout Bad Mother Memories rigs fighting fish fly box fall tips casting State College Stockies Fly Fishing drifting bar boots Wild vs Stocked rookies patience DHALO spot burning Tippet Rings Boat strip set PA Gold fly tying LBI dry flies Grandfather PFBC falling in Pennsylvania Trout Unlimited Little Juniata River drop shot nymphing Sawyer silence wet wading Jeff trout bum Night DJS tight lining skunked posted land DIY stinky bass Burke musician summertime fishing Fish Hard Fifty Tips One Great Tip time Oakiewear wildlife regulations fly line FishHard swinging leaders tightline front ended How it Started