Troutbitten Hands Boy
August 29, 2018

Because I couldn’t fight back the tears, I turned away. Because I’d never had a moment where I felt such immediate loss, I surrendered to the defeat. The emotion was too big for a ten year old boy, and I fell apart.

— — — — — —

Hours earlier . . .

I walked behind Dad to the river. I kept my head down through the steady morning rain, watching water drops grow on the brim of my hat and then fall in rhythm with each step forward. On a muddy side trail I followed Dad: my boot tracks into his, my wide and awkward gait to keep up, the sucking sound of mud and rubber separating with each step, and more water rushing in to fill the hole behind — then the splashing of my own half-sized boots into his full-sized tracks.

We walked until our path finally ended underneath a stand of spruce trees at the edge of the river. Dad looked back.

“Son, you can fish here today, and I’ll go upstream a little ways.”

He’d never let me fish alone before. I knew that’s how Dad and his brother fished, but until today, we’d never split up, no matter how many times I’d asked.

After he turned and walked upstream, I yelled to him . . .

“OK, Dad. Good luck up there.”

He looked back and nodded. Then I watched him cross the river and disappear through tall ferns and thin poplar limbs.

As I fished, I was entranced by a small waterfall pouring down the hill. It crashed over the slate and into the river before me. I thought about how the water never stops coming down the hill, how it joins and grows and becomes something more, how it’s connected to both the water behind it and the water flowing ahead of it — how it comes to me and then passes me, and how the water never stops pouring over the hill and onto the rocks.

With my new hip boots and the scent of fresh rubber, with my new wading skills and my new independence, I was finally fishing on my own.

And then something remarkable happened.

The fishing line tightened with a strength and a powerful weight that I’d never before felt. I was astounded when the enormous fish jumped — I remember how the whole space was filled with a splash when it landed. I didn’t know what was at the end of my line, and I didn’t know what to do. So I held on. My arms trembled in concert with the rod while I gripped tight with two hands and let the handle spin the way I’d been taught. “Surely Dad never expected this,” I thought.

I shouted for Dad.

Moments later, he barreled down the ravine, running through heavy water up to his waist. A powerful man. A calm man.

But the fish was already gone. When the line snapped, the sound shrieked through the damp air and scattered somewhere behind me, leaving behind the only evidence  — a quivering rod tip and the bewilderment of my expression.

The air went still and transparent. And I began to fall apart . . .

— — — — — —

I turned back around. Dad stared at the river, and I stared at Dad. I felt like it was only us out there. All other life in the woods seemed to pause in deference to our moment, lending us the chance to recover.

He walked to me and placed his hand on my head. “That was a good fish,” he said simply.

We walked the path back together. And for the first time Dad followed me over the wooded trail, his footsteps into mine. I turned back to see him once. He looked at me and nodded with a determined half-smile that said, “You’re doing it right. You did it right. Some things just happen. Loss is part of this game and part of life.”

We made it home for an early supper.

Still damp from the rain, I told the story of the fish to my grandfather.

“Well of course you lose the biggest ones,” Pap said. “They test the limits of your tackle. They put a strain on your equipment and your own abilities. Most of all, luck is on the side of a truly legendary fish. That’s how it got that big in the first place, and that’s why you’ll probably lose the next big one too. That’s why a fish like that is called legendary, son.”

It was a long time before I could think of anything else.


Enjoy the day.
Domenick Swentosky


Click here for details.



Read More Troutbitten History

What do you think?

11 Comment threads
9 Thread replies
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
12 Comment authors
  Follow the comments on this article.  
Notify of

Excellent. I remember a day like that myself – same age, same reaction, always in the back of my mind.


Very well written and a nice story. My dad was never a wader. He loved to cast 2 lines into a lake, and sit there, enjoying the day. Drinking in nature was what made him happy. That’s all that mattered to him on the these trips. He was free.

Alex Argyros

Thanks for the moving story, Dom. It made me think of my own father. Even though he had no particular interest in trout fishing, he would take me on the bus from Manhattan up to Roscoe so I could fish the Beaverkill. He had a clunky spinning rod and a few Mepps spinners that I taught him to cast. One day, he caught a beautiful brownie right below the Roscoe Motel. It didn’t get away. But, years later, he did.

Awesome post. I’ve only had one fish like that. It was at Flathead Lake in MT, I was 15 and it was my first time there. We were staying with some friend that had pedal boats. I had never fished much in lakes and I decided to try my luck with what I knew worked. Mainly panther martins and red devil spoons. I had some luck with lake trout and feisty sunfish. As the sun died down I thought it might be a good time to go for big boys. There was this huge 5inch red devil spoon I had… Read more »



Thoroughly enjoyed that memory. Mine took place when I was older but the feeling felt the same.

Great story Dom! Appreciate you sharing something personally powerful.

Jonathan R Schmidt

Awesome story. Thanks for sharing. I lost a big trout last summer close to my house (ain’t supposed to be big ones there) but I learned and have a caught a few since, including a rare large pike in a blue ribbon trout river. The surprise was enough of a thrill (though a tad disappointed it wasn’t my first large brown). Keep up the stories.


The thing I like most about you, you daydream. When I was little most of my report cards had a comment from my teacher…..”Alex daydreams in class” I dreaded the fact that the truth was so obvious to my teachers, and now my parents would know. My father never looked at my report card though. His statement to me was always the same. Alex, I know you, I don’t need a teacher telling me something about you I already know. I’m 60 years now, and I still daydream. It’s why I trout fish……’s why I fish! I don’t regret it… Read more »

will price

I remember sitting near a pond with my Dad the summer before he passed. We were catching bluegills and the occasional bass. I moved over about twenty or so yards, and glanced over at my Dad. His hair was white now, no longer the handsome black crop he had worn throughout his life. He stared out over the water and it seemed he was very happy at that moment, not a care in the world, fishing with me. I smiled and thought of those other days we had fished…never enough. He’s gone now, but I still remember the last time… Read more »

Curtis Reeves

You have to appreciate the wisdom of those who went well before us but more importantly, the validation of those we hold dearest. Great story

Domenick Swentosky

Hi. I'm a father of two young boys, a husband, author, fly fishing guide and a musician. I fish for wild brown trout in the cool limestone waters of Central Pennsylvania year round. This is my home, and I love it. Friends. Family. And the river.

Backing Barrel Night Fishing Chapters camera musician tips favorite Night Fishing tippet DJS Aiden wet fly fishing brown trout mud suspender fishing tightline Pennsylvania Fly Fishing beadhead LBI backcast walking cookout fly box Streamer fishing Peace Buggers dry flies time Weather photography fly tying Fly rods saltwater summertime fishing Ask an Expert Oakiewear comp fishing tracks science matters spawning George Daniel DHALO Press knots Trust big fish Harvey Pusher dry fly fishing shark Fifty Tips Headbanger Sculpin Boat streamside How it Started brookies History mistakes stocked trout mono rig carp Presentations One Great Tip flood flies Floating rules high water casting philosophy traction etiquette spot burning Baseball float DIY catch and release PSA montana Christmas Lights hiking Wild vs Stocked winter fishing falling in conservation come on man Joey fishing tips solitude Namer droppers Burke Jeff boys wet wading indicator fishing Davy Wotten Quote Tippet Rings Dry-Dropper Whiskey Drinker night-sighter wildlife fishing with kids family Mystery bite windows front ended club fishing angler types stinky bass last cast winter fly fishing dorsey yarn indicator Resources wild trout wading boots small streams brush fishing Camping split shot Spring Creek Rich skunked Central PA Streamers Night Little Juniata River posted land Doh giveaway Euro-Nymphing tenkara Plans bar boots public land George Harvey fall winter indicator nymphing Troutbitten Fly Box leaders reading water tiny flies Industry Stuff fighting fish Dad nymphs Memories silence fly line Wild Mushrooms BES thunderstorm tight line nymphing PA Gold swinging dead drift home-stream nymphing It's just fishing nymphing tips friends fluke drifting Bad Mother Big Trout regulations Galloup Gierach fly patterns rookies waders wading Grandfather strategy Float Fishing big brown trout ice mousing Stockies marginal water Fly Casting drop shot nymphing patience safety PFBC Wild Brown Trout Whiskey simplicity Sawyer Orvis tight lining net backcountry surf fishing the Mono Rig dog Dylan TU travel efficiency friendship Fish Hard trout bum Sighter mayfly Trout Unlimited Discovery Grobe explore summer gear wet flies rigs