Fifty Fly Fishing Tips: #36 — Dry flies and flotation — Building in some buoyancy and preserving it

by | Apr 2, 2018 | 20 comments

Hatch season is just around the corner. On some rivers we’ve already experienced good fishing over eager trout rising to delicate Blue Winged Olives. And somewhere in the distance, a chorus grows louder — the Grannoms are coming, the Grannoms are coming.

Oh sure, there are midge fishing opportunities around here all winter long. (I know a local guy who travels in shorts and picks his spots from the banks with no-see-um dry flies all winter long). But for most of us, the winter season is a subsurface fishing affair — we bottom bounce nymphs and strip streamers for eligible trout. And after four months of all that, I don’t know anyone who doesn’t get excited about a good dry fly opportunity. In fact, show me a legit chance to fish dries for active fish, and I’ll take it any day of the year.

And now, on the precipice of all the major hatches, right before mayflies, caddis, midges and stones start bumping into each other, we prepare at our vises. We tie flies, and we dream. We pack our gear and envision the surface slash, the gulp, the dimple and the ring of the rise. So it helps to consider for a moment — what keeps a dry fly floating on the surface in the first place?

READ: Troutbitten | Category | Dry Fly Fishing

Air

Buoyancy is all about trapped air. It’s what keeps an eight-hundred foot cargo carrier afloat at sea, and it’s what floats a #24 Trico Spinner. With just enough trapped air to overcome the weight of the hook and material, the fly floats on the surface and resist being pulled underneath and drowned. It’s simple.

Regarding this buoyancy, we must consider two things: the materials of a fly (what actually traps and holds the air), and a way to preserve the material’s ability to hold air (waterproofing).

Let’s tackle both.

Material Buoyancy

This article is not a comprehensive list of materials that keep flies afloat. But here’s an index of the buoyant materials that lie in the cedar-scented drawers of my own tying desk: foam, hackle, hair, CDC, snowshoe rabbit’s foot and yarn.

It helps to recognize the strengths and weaknesses of each material.

Foam, for example, floats all day with very little treatment, but it’s a material with no motion. So most flies incorporating foam also utilize other materials that provide attractive motion to a fly.

Hackle, on the other hand, moves. And that motion gives the impression of life. The barbules of good, stiff hackle, wrapped and stacked against each other, trap air next to the fly and hold the river at bay. I often over-wrap parachute style flies which I plan to use as suspenders in a dry dropper rig. Because the extra wraps trap more air, the fly can support more weight. But even the best hackle needs maintenance to sustain its buoyancy, so we dry and treat the hackle.

Hans Weilenmann’s Sledgehammer. Damn right.

Elk, moose and deer hair wings and tails are common on dry flies. Because good hair is semi-hollow, it carries built-in flotation with each strand. Elk and deer hair also have a natural sheen and water repellency, allowing them to shed excess moisture on a swift backcast. Not all elk or deer hair is suitable for dry flies, and once you tie about a thousand Comparaduns you’re cursed into the struggle of finding exactly what you’re looking for until the end of days.

I’ve bought and tied with just about every poly, hi-vis, extra-floaty-fly-tying stuff that comes on a card or in a tiny bag. All of these yarns float to some degree — the buzzword now is hydrophobic. That sounds really great, and it probably is. But the most important thing I’ve found for a dry fly yarn is crinkles. I want a yarn whose strands are not straight, but squiggled. When laid out and bunched together, all of those crinkles trap air and do what we want — they float a fly. My preferred yarn for parachute posts, Dorsey Yarn Indicators, and any other yarn used for flotation is Macrame Cord, specifically, the 6mm polypropylene cord sold by Carol’s Rugs. It’s hydrophobic!

While polypropylene is completely synthetic, you can’t get much more natural than the feathers plucked from a duck’s butt. Enter CDC. As the years pass I use more and more CDC, mostly because the trout tell me to. Wet or dry, it has a remarkable ability to imitate life. And that motion — that impression — catches fish. It’s like the dry fly equivalent of marabou.

CDC is a great option for subsurface patterns also, but when kept dry, a good CDC fly rides on the surface, with some of the fibers undulating around the fly and more fibers swirling in the surface. Two of my favorite styles are the CDC and Elk, and the Puffy. I love simple flies.

But CDC requires a lot of maintenance . . .

Among this list of buoyant material options, you’ll notice that more movement comes with more maintenance. Foam rides high for a very long time. Hair wings are similar. Stiff hackle and good yarn ride high only until water penetrates into the small air chambers. And CDC needs to be refreshed at regular intervals.

With more movement comes more maintenance.

Olive Puffies. Simple and convincing as an emerger, dry or spinner.

Preserving Buoyancy

To keep dry materials repelling water and riding high, the modern fly fisher has a few options that your grandfather did not.

Let’s quickly divide the floatants into three categories: paste, gel and powder.

Paste is the thickest option. It can overwhelm a small and delicate fly, but it’s perfect for floating large or bushy dry flies. Paste is also a great match for foam. Once applied, a paste treatment lasts longer than gel or powder. My favorite paste floatant is Loon Payette Paste, because it has no scent and is temperature stable.

Gel is the floatant I use most. For standard dries, Comparaduns, Parachutes, Klinkhammers, hairwings, spinners and many midges, a small drop of gel goes a long way. Work it into the fibers of the fly and start casting. Without a good floatant, many dries quickly become waterlogged. But protected with floatant, any gained water in the fly is often ejected on the backcast. Some gels are more temperature sensitive than other. I like Loon Aquel because it’s always the same consistency — it’s not too runny in the heat and doesn’t become sludgy in the cold.

I first bought desiccant powder to use with CDC, and now I use it for many dry fly styles. (Don’t use paste or gel on a CDC fly). When the fly is wet, dry it on a rag, and then apply powder with a brush or in a shaker. The desiccant is remarkably effective at pulling out excess water. Some of the powder clings to the fibers of the fly and protects it for a little while. Really, nothing rides higher than a freshly desiccant-treated dry fly. It’s as if the fly barely touches the water.

Frog’s Fanny was the first big hit on the market for powdered desiccant, and now every fly shop seems to have their own branded version. No wonder, really, because you can buy the stuff in bulk quart containers online. It’s just ground up silica, after all.

Rain-X

Last thing: Many years ago, a friend told me how he worked a drop or two of Rain-X into every dry fly he tied at the vise (not the CDC flies). Once I tried it, I’ve done the same ever since. Allow the Rain-X to dry, then store the fly in your box. Often, a fly pre-treated this way needs no other dressing — it will float high for a very long time.

And we’ll all float on, okay

Nothing’s worse that a sinking dry fly. Sure, some flies do very well when riding in the surface or just beneath, but if we intend for the fly to be on the surface, that’s where it should stay.

It’s necessary to balance movement and motion — natural buoyancy with the impression of life — how much you want to fiddle with pastes, gels and powers with how high and how long you want the fly riding on the surface.

Really, try everything and you’ll find your own preferences.

The days are short, but the life is long.

Fish hard, friends.

 

** Donate ** If you enjoy this article, please consider a donation. Your support is what keeps this Troutbitten project funded. Scroll below to find the Donate Button. And thank you.

 

Enjoy the day.
Domenick Swentosky
T R O U T B I T T E N
domenick@troutbitten.com

 

Share This Article . . .

Since 2014 and 700+ articles deep
Troutbitten is a free resource for all anglers.
Your support is greatly appreciated.

– Explore These Post Tags –

Domenick Swentosky

Central Pennsylvania

Hi. I’m a father of two young boys, a husband, author, fly fishing guide and a musician. I fish for wild brown trout in the cool limestone waters of Central Pennsylvania year round. This is my home, and I love it. Friends. Family. And the river.

More from this Category

Podcast — Ep. 5: Fly Fishing the Mono Rig — Versatility and the Tight Line Advantage Taken Further

Podcast — Ep. 5: Fly Fishing the Mono Rig — Versatility and the Tight Line Advantage Taken Further

After hundreds of Troutbitten articles featuring the versatility of the Mono Rig, now there’s a podcast. My friends Josh, Austin, Trevor and Bill join me to discuss how each of us fishes this hybrid rig as a complete fly fishing system, detailing the ultimate flexibility of this amazing tool.

The Troutbitten Mono Rig is a hybrid system for fishing all types of flies: nymphs (both tight line and indicator styles), streamers, dry-dropper, wets, and small dry flies. With twenty pound monofilament as a fly line substitute, better contact, control and strike detection are gained with the Mono Rig versus a traditional fly line approach. And yet, the casting here is still a fly line style cast. Ironically, it takes excellent fly casting skills to efficiently throw a Mono Rig.

Finding the (Almost) Invisible Potholes — Reading Water

Finding the (Almost) Invisible Potholes — Reading Water

Just as the taller rock creates a surface wave, the pothole, bucket or depression in the riverbed has a corresponding feature on the surface. It’s a flatter, calmer piece of water — smoother than the surrounding surface currents. Is it harder to recognize? Sure it is. It’s also not as reliable of a sign. But quite often, if you find a calm piece of water, surrounded by mixed currents and minor waves, a pothole lies below.

Be careful what you’re reading, though. The stall, or slower piece of water that lies just downstream of every rock, is not the same thing as a pothole — not at all . . .

#8. The Strike: Nine Essential Skills for Tight Line and Euro Nymphing

#8. The Strike: Nine Essential Skills for Tight Line and Euro Nymphing

The strike is the best part of fishing. It’s what we’re all out there waiting for, or rather, what we’re trying to make happen all day long. And the trout eats because we get so many things right.

We fool a fish, and we fulfill the wish of every angler.

When the fish strikes, we strike back. Short, swift and effective, the hook finds fish flesh. Then we try to keep the trout buttoned and get it to the net.

In the next article, this series concludes with the focus on putting it all together . . .

The Backing Barrel Might Be The Best Sighter Ever

The Backing Barrel Might Be The Best Sighter Ever

A simple piece of Dacron, tied in a barrel, is a visible and sensitive addition to your tight line and euro nymphing rig. The versatile Backing Barrel serves as a stand-alone sighter, especially when tied with a one-inch tag. Better yet, it draws your eyes to the colored monofilament of any sighter and enhances visibility threefold. The Backing Barrel adds a third dimension of strike detection, with the Dacron flag just stiff enough to stand away from the line, but just soft enough to twitch upon even the most subtle takes . . .

Podcast — Ep. 3: Night Fishing, and the Mouse Emerger Concept

Podcast — Ep. 3: Night Fishing, and the Mouse Emerger Concept

My night fishing friends, Josh and Trevor join me for a fun and detailed discussion about mouse emergers. This style is about taking the benefits of a top water pattern at night and making it a little harder for the trout to resist. Then, sometimes, we fish similar patterns that remain in the first 3-12 inches of the water column. My friends and I also trade night fishing stories about the scariest and most unusual things that happen while fly fishing after dark.

What do you think?

Be part of the Troutbitten community of ideas.
Be helpful. And be nice.

20 Comments

  1. Never heard of using Rain-X. I guess I figured it would add some weird scent to the fly. I’ve always wondered how much scent actually goes on a fly. I know Trevor from Fly-Carpin has mentioned going so far as to boil his flies to kill any sign of scent. That seems like way over kill but it works for him.

    Reply
    • Personally, I don’t think scent matters much for a trout fly. I agree that it matters a lot to carp, but they feed differently and in different areas that trout (usually). I don’t believe trout hunt by scent very much.

      That said, Rain-X dries with almost no scent.

      Just my thought. Cheers.

      Reply
  2. Dom,
    I was with you all the way until the end.
    I have used a product by Hareline Dubbin called Watershed.
    Now you have me wondering if it’s nothing more than Rain X
    in a fancy 1 oz bottle.
    No ingredients listed so a smell test is in order.
    …and I like Diddies too.

    Reply
    • Hey Rick, I used Watershed too. After the bottle ran out, I did the Rain-X. I notice no difference. They both really help materials float.

      Reply
  3. There is one other key factor that keeps dry flies afloat: surface tension. Water repellent (hydrophobic) pastes, gels, spray treatments, and powders all prevent the breaking of the extra-strong, elastic-like surface tension bonds that form at the water-air interface. Try this visually entertaining home experiment to prove the point: Fill a drinking glass with cold water and gently place a small dry fly so that it floats on the surface. Now, place a drop of dishwashing detergent on the tip of a butter knife and gently transfer the detergent to the surface of the water . The detergent will instantly break the surface tension and you can watch in wonder as your fly instantly loses the support force that had kept it floating!

    Reply
  4. Great tips, as always. I agree with you that movement is a frequently overlooked aspect of dry flies. To wit, something to think about is using soft hackles on dry flies. Properly treated, they float rather well, and they impart a lot of movement. For example, a simple fly would have a tail, fur body, CDC wings, and a sparse collar of soft hackle.

    Reply
  5. Once again, another succinct and excellent post. New to tying and been tying the nymphs. After witnessing a rare mayfly hatch here on our southern mountain waters, I’m now exploring dry tying. The perspective provided here is extremely helpful. Thanks.

    Reply
  6. It’s not advised that one use Rain-X on flies: It’s a pollutant and a toxin to fish. The product’s current Safety Data Sheet shows its chemistry to be Ethyl Alcohol and Isopropyl Alcohol, and it’s harmful to both algae and fish.

    Reply
    • Thanks. But do you understand that the RainX is dry before the fly touches the water? It’s applied when the fly is tied at the bench.
      And if by chance you are still concerned about the effects of dried RainX on a stream, have you considered the finish coatings of everything else that you fish with and touches the water? Like your boots, laces, waders? What about your sunscreen, the handsoap you used before fishing, etc?

      Reply
  7. Great song and nicely done on the connection to the article!

    Reply
  8. I’ve been tying for a while but still don’t quite understand some of the choices for dry (and parachute) fly dubbing that is has no water shedding. One western fly tyer said anything can be made to float with the floatant. What are your thoughts on substituting something with float characteristics for dubbing like sub’ing beaver for rabbit fur etc? Does it matter?

    Reply
    • Honestly, no. I have found that the dubbing matters very little. I also agree that you can get just about any dubbing to float. A fish Parachute Hare’s Ear’s a lot. I fish a Sledgehammer. Both use rabbit fur instead of “dry fly” dubbing. The bugginess of the dubbing may add a little more life to the bodies, or it may not. But I like it. And I have no troubles keeping that material floating. There’s really so little dubbing on a fly, that it’s up to the other materials to keep it floating — the things described above.

      Those are my thoughts.

      Cheers.
      Dom

      Reply
  9. Dom, You mention it in passing, but substituting polypropylene, a bouyant material used for water skiing rope, is my answer for all my dry flies. As you know I created the CET (Crippled Emerger Transformer) nearly 20 years ago. It consists of polypropylene yarn wings (upright for mayflies and down for caddis), a bit of dubbing, tying thread and a hook. I tie all mayfly species as CET’s, all sizes from 24’s to 8’s. I am as fussy with my polypro as I used to be with dry fly hackles (sold all my Whiting hackles for big bucks for hairdos). I use a little Aquel on my poly wings initially and catch trout after trout without redressing! I can pull them under and they pop back up! I have a YouTube video for those who want to tie them.

    Reply
    • Nice. And I agree. The macrame yarn I referred to above is also polypro. It’s Bonnie Braid and can be found readily. I like the crinkle that it has because it traps more air, and I think it’s just right for wings, parachute posts and yarn indys.

      Cheers, Bill.
      Dom

      Reply
  10. Fished the Salmonfly hatch on the Henry’s Fork a week or so ago. Took a guide out for day 1 and he grabbed a bottle of Fly Agra (by Yellowstone Fly Goods). We fished a 2-3 fly rig anchored by a Chernobyl Chubby and I used the same rig (flies, leaders, etc) for two more days. I caught more huge fish than I ever have in my life and that Agra kept the indicator fly floating for days at a time. We caught multiple fish every hour or so and never reapplied. I was blown away by how effective it was as a float at. Each morning I re-applied some and that was it. 10 hours of fishing later the fly was floating great. Every few hours I’d throw in some shadow casting to wash it off. Came home and hit up Amazon to order more.

    Reply
  11. Thanks, Dom, for the details on waterproofing. Wildly helpful.
    And thanks, too, for the Modest Mouse link.
    In a nod to a return to “normal” from the throes of the pandemic, I see Modest Mouse will tour this summer / fall with a date outdoors here in Boston 6 Aug 21 (and in Philly the night before).
    Live music and trout – pretty good combo. Thanks again.

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Articles

Recent Posts

Domenick Swentosky

Central Pennsylvania

Hi. I’m a father of two young boys, a husband, author, fly fishing guide and a musician. I fish for wild brown trout in the cool limestone waters of Central Pennsylvania year round. This is my home, and I love it. Friends. Family. And the river.

Pin It on Pinterest