Fifty Tips

Fifty Fly Fishing Tips: #22 — Find Feeding Fish

December 25, 2017

Trout have a strange way of all doing the same things at once. Although they rarely pod up like a school of suckers, they tend to function as a collective order, especially during feeding periods.

Trout fishing is unpredictable, and sometimes it can be maddening, but that’s what makes it wonderful too. We sense that it’s a fair game. We find trends. And while they’re not a sure thing, we start to say “usually this” and “mostly that” with some confidence. The more time we spend learning our waters, studying the habits of trout, the more predictable some of those patterns become. Where and when trout feed is likely the most important pattern to a fisherman.

— — — — — —

My uncle first taught me this lesson as a young boy. I was knee-deep in a perfect grey-green pool, firing one cast after another into the depths. I’d been there alone for an hour when my fishing hero walked toward me from downstream. Five feet above the creek, on the bankside trail, my uncle approached as I looked over my shoulder.

“There’s a bunch of them in there,” I said. “I’ve tried everything, and I cast from different angles like you told me, but they won’t take it.”

“Those trout aren’t feeding,” he chuckled, waving his hand toward the pool. “Let’s go upstream into the woods and find some fish that want to eat.”

The rest of our morning was spent fooling trout in the pocket water, mostly in current a foot deep and always near structure.

Find one, find another

It’s not always easy to locate feeding fish. Sure, rising trout are a dead giveaway, but even at that, it helps to notice exactly what water type your risers are using. If you find them in a tailout, you’ll eventually catch or spook all the rising fish. So walk up to the next tailout, and if the hatch or spinner fall is still on, you’ll likely find another group of trout that are willing to take a well-placed fly.

Discovering underwater feeding patterns is tougher, by the mere fact that most of it goes unseen to our eyes. But that’s alright. When fishing nymphs, wets or streamers, take note of where the takes happen. If you hook a trout, put the fly right back in the same spot, and catch another. Then look for nearby water that is identical to where you caught the first fish.

Learn the trends

Over time, feeding patterns emerge. You come to expect actively feeding trout in the riffles before a mayfly hatch, and you find them in the soft, almost foamy backwater at the end of a spinner fall. You learn that larger fish are bolder in low light, and you might target shallow water in the morning hours.

Seasonally, you follow feeding fish into the fast, oxygen rich, broken water of summertime and come back to the gentler, deeper glides for the slow feeders of winter.

These patterns are found everywhere, and you’ll find them by fishing thoughtfully and being observant. They’re unique to your own stream, year after year, season to season and day to day. The habits of trout are unpredictable by the minute and yet reliable within a larger frame of time. And good fishing follows the patterns of feeding trout.

Enjoy the day
Domenick Swentosky


Read All of the Fifty Tips Series

December 21, 2017

December 27, 2017

  1. Reply


    December 28, 2017

    When it comes to surface feeding, in addition to observing the water type, it is even more critical to pattern the types of rise forms, timing/rhythm, and feeding positions. If you fish dry flies exclusively on bug rich rivers, this type of pattern fishing will make or break your season.

    • Reply

      Domenick Swentosky

      December 28, 2017

      Good point, Rick. Thanks.

  2. Reply

    Adrienne McGuire

    February 6, 2018

    Great info and a very well-written piece. Rick’s comments was also helpful to me as I learn how to identify the feeding patterns of trout near my home.

    • Reply

      Domenick Swentosky

      February 7, 2018


What do you think?

Domenick Swentosky

Hi. I'm a father of two young boys, a husband, writer, musician and fisherman. I fly fish for wild brown trout in the cool limestone waters of Central Pennsylvania year round. This is my home, and I love it. Friends. Family. And the river.

Trust small streams camera nymphs It's just fishing History favorite the Mono Rig mud Weather Quote fly box Night knots tiny flies regulations photography thunderstorm solitude beadhead nymphing tightline flies Orvis comp fishing DIY BadMoFo Fly Fishing fighting fish rookies brookies posted land Wild Brown Trout spawning winter fly fishing spot burning wading boots front ended tips patience George Harvey Little Juniata River tight lining travel public land Gierach science matters club fishing tenkara conservation Sawyer mono rig Ask an Expert streamside Bad Mother backcast TU Dad fly tying Float Fishing friends bar boots ice dead drift walking Backing Barrel big brown trout PSA fishing tips Camping Spring Creek Pennsylvania Tippet Rings fishing with kids waders mousing Boat net philosophy boys cookout Floating DHALO montana musician BES Whiskey giveaway Davy Wotten Dylan Oakiewear skunked Central PA Grandfather brown trout Fifty Tips Rich Dry-Dropper mistakes tippet suspender fishing home-stream wild trout float Whiskey Drinker Christmas Lights Big Trout catch and release casting PFBC bite windows trout bum etiquette stocked trout Burke winter fishing summertime fishing dorsey yarn indicator Aiden family summer Streamers carp PA Gold wildlife brush fishing Discovery simplicity backcountry Headbanger Sculpin dry flies Buggers Trout Unlimited dog stinky bass Namer Grobe Wild vs Stocked come on man fly patterns Euro-Nymphing wet flies leaders Wild Mushrooms Sighter How it Started nymphing tips rigs tight line nymphing silence Memories angler types poetry last cast Streamer fishing indicator fishing Galloup Night Fishing Mystery Peace Stockies DJS night-sighter Joey tracks Fish Hard gear Fly rods friendship marginal water split shot wading efficiency hiking reading water fly line Resources fall