Your Indicator is too Big

December 5, 2017


Anyone who thinks indicators are just for indicating is missing the point. And yes, it’s a bobber.

Hatch Magazine published my article, “Your Indicator is too big.” It’s about the importance of balancing the size of the suspender with the weight underneath.

— — — — — —

. . . When we add a strike indicator to the leader, we transfer control of the nymph’s downstream path to the indicator itself. The bobber (sorry, but that’s what it is) now does the work of leading the nymph through the drift and determining the maximum depth of the flies. By adding an indicator, we also transfer the sensitivity — the strike detection — over to the bobber. And if the indicator is sized properly — if it is balanced with the weight suspended underneath — it’s exceptionally sensitive.

. . . The trout that inhales the nymph and turns back upstream will always move the indicator. Such aggressive takes move even a poorly balanced rig. But most trout don’t feed that way. Our trout are fickle creatures. They often slide left a few inches and mouth a nymph as it passes, feeling it for a moment like an old man testing hot soup with his tongue. They might release the nymph without us ever detecting a strike.

— — — — — —

Read the full article at Hatch Magazine.

As a follow up, and for a good explanation about what you can really do with an indicator/suspender, check out this Troutbitten article:

READ: Troutbitten | Tight Line Nymphing with an Indicator — A Mono Rig Variant

Enjoy the day
Domenick Swentosky

Nymphing Tips

Read all Troutbitten Nymphing Tips

What do you think?

1 Comment threads
1 Thread replies
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
2 Comment authors
  Follow the comments on this article.  
Notify of

With older weakening eyes, I to prefer to call my bobber (I like the orange styrofoam footballs) a “visual aid”. I recall reading in your past blogs that you used a colored section on your mono rig so you could follow your line. Is that a bobber line? btw..all of your blogs are excellent.


That’s funny! Bobber line……..

Domenick Swentosky

Hi. I'm a father of two young boys, a husband, author, fly fishing guide and a musician. I fish for wild brown trout in the cool limestone waters of Central Pennsylvania year round. This is my home, and I love it. Friends. Family. And the river.

fly patterns bite windows wild trout public land Grobe camera Dad Peace nymphing tips Christmas Lights bar boots leaders dog giveaway dead drift travel marginal water Grandfather photography Mystery home-stream dry fly fishing tenkara Rich tight lining summer tracks trout bum montana musician Spring Creek Fly Casting fishing with kids DHALO Weather Fly rods family Whiskey Drinker rules Whiskey favorite Troutbitten Fly Box TU Gierach Boat summertime fishing brookies walking small streams George Daniel rigs Camping tight line nymphing Sighter Joey nymphs DJS Fish Hard mayfly backcountry night-sighter PSA fly line Streamers catch and release silence solitude Sawyer PA Gold fly tying float indicator nymphing tightline Dylan last cast waders mousing Trout Unlimited Tippet Rings BES wet flies time big fish One Great Tip brush fishing Backing Barrel spawning Bad Mother club fishing Night Fishing big brown trout Pennsylvania Presentations Oakiewear How it Started Wild vs Stocked Quote Discovery spot burning wading fighting fish Fifty Tips come on man wet fly fishing fall Jeff winter fishing droppers brown trout Night tiny flies BadMoFo angler types winter fly fishing Stockies Galloup gear thunderstorm reading water PFBC mud backcast Big Trout Streamer fishing casting Aiden friendship Floating ice History It's just fishing stocked trout Float Fishing boys net simplicity the Mono Rig mono rig fly box dry flies Trust Davy Wotten Industry Stuff split shot Wild Brown Trout winter tips conservation philosophy rookies Ask an Expert beadhead tippet cookout explore knots flies Euro-Nymphing suspender fishing Burke efficiency mistakes Memories Press indicator fishing Namer comp fishing wildlife carp Orvis patience front ended wading boots Baseball Fly Fishing stinky bass Central PA poetry Wild Mushrooms Headbanger Sculpin friends science matters hiking DIY etiquette George Harvey Dry-Dropper fishing tips Resources streamside Little Juniata River nymphing skunked regulations Buggers dorsey yarn indicator