Fifty Fly Fishing Tips: #11– Tie your own flies — Here’s why

by | Oct 9, 2017 | 12 comments

Every top-notch fly angler I know ties his own flies. The only exceptions are a couple friends who used to sit behind the vise but now have friends who tie custom patterns for them.

Custom. That’s the important word here. And having your own set of flies, tied just the way you like, is the key reason for rolling your own. Custom flies are confidence flies. The slight variations on a Hare’s Ear nymph that a fly tyer wraps on the hook are what connect us to the fly. It’s more personal, more individual and ultimately more effective. We fish our own patterns with conviction, certain that our adjustments and refinements are what make the fly a fish-catcher.

In the beginning, we choose a fly with some measure of hope. Maybe a friend recommends the pattern, or perhaps we see it on a list of go-to flies written on a fly shop’s dry erase board. If we’re lucky enough to have some success with the pattern, we go back to the vise and change a thing or two. Maybe the gold rib is a bit too flashy, so we substitute it with copper. We might decide to dub the body in a slimmer profile, thinking it’s a more accurate match for the nymphs we find living among the weedy limestone rocks of our home water. And when those changes work — when more fish come to the net — our hope for a fly changes to faith.

That’s how confidence flies are born.

Truthfully, tying your own flies significantly deepens your involvement in fly fishing. It fundamentally affects the way you see things on the water. It’s another aspect of fly fishing that draws you further into the sport. Tying your own provides you with more control over the outcome on the water. It keeps you involved. There’s more to prepare and more to do when you’re off the water. And there’s more fly fishing stuff for you to ponder on the way to work.

Forget any idea of saving money. Sure, you can cut costs by tying your own flies, but most of us go a little overboard with the materials list at first. So it takes a lot of fishing trips and lost flies to overcome that startup cost.

With a little restrain, however, fly tying quickly pays for itself. I recommend a decent set of tools, a simple vise and the materials for just a few favorite patterns. Buy only what you need, not what you plan to need in the future. And learn to tie just one pattern at a time.

In a few years you’ll have a box full of faithful confidence flies that look a little different than the rest. And you’ll be a better fisherman.

Fish hard, friends.

 

Here are a few more Troutbitten articles about fly patterns:

READ: Troutbitten | It’s not the same

READ: Troutbitten | Pattern vs Presentation — Trout eat anything, but sometimes they eat another thing better

READ: Troutbitten | What Moves a Trout to the Fly?

 

Enjoy the day
Domenick Swentosky
T R O U T B I T T E N
domenick@troutbitten.com

 

Share This Article . . .

Since 2014 and 600 articles deep
Troutbitten is a free resource for all anglers
Your support is greatly appreciated

– Explore These Post Tags –

Domenick Swentosky

Central Pennsylvania

Hi. I’m a father of two young boys, a husband, author, fly fishing guide and a musician. I fish for wild brown trout in the cool limestone waters of Central Pennsylvania year round. This is my home, and I love it. Friends. Family. And the river.

More from this Category

Fly Fishing with Streamers on the Mono Rig — More Control and More Contact

Fly Fishing with Streamers on the Mono Rig — More Control and More Contact

So why do we use a Mono Rig over fly line? What’s the advantage?

Just like a tight line nymph rig, we gain more control over the presentation of the flies, and we have better contact throughout the cast and the drift. With fly line in the game, we cast and manage the fly line itself. With the Mono Rig, we cast and manage the streamers more directly.

With the Mono Rig, we can stay tight to the streamer after the cast, we can dead drift it with precision for the first five feet, keeping all the leader off the water. Then we might activate the streamer with some jigs and pops for the next ten feet of the drift. And for the last twenty feet, as the streamer finishes out below and across from us, we may employ long strips. All these options are open . . .

High Light — Low Light

High Light — Low Light

My article, "High Light -- Low Light," is over at Hatch Magazine. Here are a few excerpts..... -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- ... Finding the shady cracks that harbor resting and wary trout is a good challenge on bright days. Offering the flies to them in those small...

Tight Line Nymphing with an Indicator — A Mono Rig Variant

Tight Line Nymphing with an Indicator — A Mono Rig Variant

I dislike arbitrary limits. Placing restrictions on tackle and techniques, when they inhibit my ability to adapt to the fishing conditions, makes no sense to me. I’m bound by no set of rules other than my own. And my philosophy is — Do what works.

I guess that’s why I’ve grown into this fishing system. Most of the time I use what I refer to as the Mono Rig. It’s a very long leader that substitutes for fly line, and I’ve written about it extensively on Troutbitten. Tight line and euro nymphing principles are at the heart of the Mono Rig, but there are multiple variations that deviate from those standard setups. Sometimes I use split shot rather than weighted flies. Sometimes I add suspenders to the rig. I even throw large, articulated streamers and strip aggressively with the Mono Rig. All of this works on the basic principle of substituting #20 monofilament for fly line.

Tight line nymphing is my default approach on most rivers. I like the control, the contact and the immediacy of strike detection. But sometimes adding a suspender (an indicator that suspends weight) just works better.

Often, I add a dry fly to my tight line nymphing rig. “The Duo” (European fishermen’s term for dry/dropper) is widely popular because it’s a deadly variation of the standard tight line approach. But dry/dropper rigs have their issues. And choosing a Thingamabobber or a Dorsey Yarn Indicator for the suspender not only solves those issues but also includes extra benefits.

This isn’t about which method is better. Invariably, the answer to such questions in fishing is, “It depends.” Everything has its place. This is about how to use tight line principles with a suspender rig. I hate arbitrary limits. Do what works.

Kinda Slow

Kinda Slow

I was either born or raised with an abundance of fishing optimism.

. . . No matter the situation, I have an ability to regroup and believe in big possibilities again. Within a few hours of making it home and saying to my sons, “It was kinda slow,” I’m ready for more. After a bowl of cereal and a few talks with friends, after a couple flies tied with something just a little different than last time, I always find a reason to believe the next trip will be better . . .

Split Shot vs Weighted Flies

Split Shot vs Weighted Flies

So you hate split shot, right? I’ve never had anyone tell me that they like using it. But for me, split shot is a convenient and useful tool in my vest, and I think it’s underrated. It does things for me that can’t be done any other way, and I like it. Yes, I like split shot. Sure, I prefer weighted flies over having shot crimped to the line. (My nymph box is full of tungsten beaded flies.) But I also carry a selection of unweighted patterns that get a regular workout while using split shot for the weight.

Here are some thoughts about all that . . .

What do you think?

Be part of the Troutbitten community of ideas.
Be helpful. And be nice.

12 Comments

  1. Dominick,
    Another excellent take. They just keep getting better. Can’t wait for #50. The ‘gold’ here is a simple vise. My first flies were tied at age 11 (1965) on my Dad’s 4” bench vise in the garage. I used size 10 Eagle Claw baitholder hooks, thread and wool from my Mother’s sewing kit, soft hackles and wing quills out of Dad’s hunting vest and dry fly hackle either scavenged from the chicken yard, plucked off a deranged rooster, or sorted out of the pillows that were filled with mixed hen and rooster feathers. And…. they caught fish. I believe what made the difference for me was my parents bought me a copy of “McClane’s Standard Fishing Encyclopedia” published that same year, and I tried to make every fly look like it was tied by Elsie or Harry Darbee. I had never seen anybody actually tie a fly and learned in a vacuum. How easy it is to learn today. Thank you for being a part of that.

    Phil

    Reply
  2. Another reason to tie your own flies is that you can be a little more adventurous on the stream knowing that a few hours at the vice can replace a lot of lost flies. I know that you can buy replacement flies too, but, somehow, at least to me, that seems more of an obstacle to risk taking than knowing that you can replace lost flies by tying up a bunch yourself.

    Alex

    Reply
    • My flies are all”cripples” to the fish. Sometimes they do just fine.

      Reply
  3. Just bought my vise and tools for this very reason. To learn. If you know a pattern to that detail you will know why. And that leads to a better understanding. Confidence matters so much. 3 months in and I see the difference when I am confident and when I am not.

    Reply
  4. Hey Dom, that nickel black bead PT is still producing for me. 🙂 Go figure. Tight lines.

    Reply
  5. This is why I will be diving fully into tying this winter. Thank you for your excellent advice.

    Reply
  6. Love ALL your posts and you are such a diplomat. but I don’t agree here. I used to tie my own in the Swicher/Richards, Marinaro days. But there are such great custom fly tiers today I just order what I want and great stuff shows up. I think tying is an art of tying and the trout.

    Reply
    • Ha! Thank you, John.

      Reply
  7. Just started tying my own flies for a trip to Ascension bay tomorrow. It’s funny you said ‘confidence’ flies because I’m deeply skeptical mine will work. The guys at the local fly shop assure me they will, but they’re all so sloppy compared to the ones I bought from the store. Hopefully I’m wrong! In any event, i’ve had a blast tying them. Thanks for the enjoyable read and Merry Christmas.

    Reply
    • Joe. When tying your own flies, avoid the most common mistakes: keep the profile thinner than you probably think it should be. Don’t try to cram too many materials on the hook, and don’t crowd the eye. If you do that, and you follow any standard fly pattern, I have confidence in saying that YOU should have confidence.

      Cheers.

      Dom

      Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Articles

Domenick Swentosky

Central Pennsylvania

Hi. I’m a father of two young boys, a husband, author, fly fishing guide and a musician. I fish for wild brown trout in the cool limestone waters of Central Pennsylvania year round. This is my home, and I love it. Friends. Family. And the river.

Pin It on Pinterest